I imagine that thereafter for a time John Fulton's attitude toward Lucy
was now dignified and manly, and now almost childlike in its despair.
Having made her love him once, he must have felt at first that he could
make her love him again. I imagine him making love to her with all the
chivalry and poetry that was in him, and then breaking off short to
rail against fate, against the whole treacherous race of women,
perhaps, and to ask what he had done to deserve so much suffering?
"Why didn't you do this to me when I was proposing? Why did you wait
till I was stone broke and worried half sick, with everything going
from bad to worse? Is it anything I've done, anything I've failed to
do? Why, Lucy, we were such a model of happiness that people looked up
to us. How can anybody suddenly stop caring the way you have? If it
had been gradual! But you were in love with me the night I went away,
weren't you? _Weren't_ you?"
Here he catches her shoulders and forces that one admission from her,
and makes the great praying woebegone eyes meet his. Then, almost, he
pushes her away from him.
"And I go away for a few days," he cries, "and come back and everything
is changed. I who had a sweetheart, haven't even a wife. Why have you
changed so? There must be a reason? What is it? Are you sick? Have
you eaten something that has made you forget? Have you been bewitched?
That's no fool question. Have you? Have you?"
"Have I what?"
"Have you been bewitched? Tell me, dear, who has done this thing to
you?"
Again he has her by the shoulders.
"Lucy, is there someone? Never mind the other things, just tell me
that? You've gotten to like someone else? Is that it?"
And Lucy must have answered that there was no one else. And there is
no question but that to the best of her belief and knowledge she was
telling the truth.
But the mere thought that there might be someone else had moved Fulton
as he had never been moved before. He once told me that even as a
little boy he had never in all his life known one pang of jealousy. He
will never be able to make that boast again. And like some damned
insidious tropical malaria, the passion has taken root in his system,
so that only death can wholly cure him.
Like some vile reptile it had found within him some cave from which it
might emerge to brandish its hideous envenomed horned head, and into
which betimes it might withdraw.
I can imagine no one so stupid as to question any serious statement of
fact that Lucy might make. Her eyes were wells of truth; her voice
fearless and sure, like that of some kingly boy.
So when she said there was _no one_, Fulton, who knew her far better
than anyone else, believed her without any question. And a great
weight must have been lifted from his heart. With the truth that he
had wrung from her, I think he must have rested almost content for a
few hours.
But contentment is far off from a man who hears the great edifice of
love and happiness which he has reared, crashing about his ears.
He could not make up his mind to any definite course of action. Now,
calm and judicial, I hear him discussing matters with coolness, and
self-forgetfulness.
"If there is any chance for me, ever," he would say, "it would be silly
of us to take any action which would be final. And, besides, I don't
see how I could reconcile my conscience to giving you a divorce. Or
you yours to getting one. It would be hard enough for you to lie about
the most trifling thing. You couldn't, you simply couldn't face the
court and tell them that I had been cruel and unfaithful. You couldn't
accuse me of anything so gross, and so unlike me, as the other woman
who would have to be hired for the occasion. There's another side to
it. I think the children are better off with you than with me. You're
the best mother that ever was, the most sensible and the most careful.
But I don't think I could give them up. If you and the babies were all
three to drop out of my life, I'd have nothing left but the duty of
finding money to support you. There's a certain pleasure in doing your
duty, of course, but in this case hardly enough. Honestly, dear, with
never a sight or touch of you, I simply couldn't keep things going
long."
Then perhaps Lucy asked some such question as this: "Don't people
often, when they've stopped caring about each other, go on living
together just the same, as far as other people know? And really just
be good friends and live their own lives?"
"This is very different. We haven't stopped caring about each other.
You've stopped caring about me. I care about you, just as I did in the
beginning, and always shall. We _couldn't_ lead separate lives under
the same roof. God knows I feel old enough, but I'm still a young man,
and like it or not, you are still my wife. It is something to own the
shell that once contained the pearl."
Another time he goes hurrying through the house, prayer-book in hand, a
thumb marking the marriage ceremony. He has been brooding and brooding
and snatching at straws.
"Read this, Lucy. Just look it over. It's what you and I stood up and
promised before a lot of people. I'm glad I looked it up. You'll see
right away that it's a contract which nobody could have the face to
break. I want you to read it over to yourself."
[Illustration: "'It's what you and I stood up and promised before a lot
of people.'"]
Finally she does, just to please him, in the sad knowledge that no good
will come of it.
"You'd forgotten, hadn't you? But just see what you promised. Didn't
you mean to keep these promises when you made them?"
"Oh, of course I did. Why ask that?"
"But now you want to back out."
Then the old argument that a promise which one is powerless to keep
isn't a bona fide promise and cannot be so regarded. Fulton sees that
for himself presently.
"No, of course," he says. "If you don't love me, you can't make
yourself by an effort of will. And if you don't honor me . . ."
"You _know_ I do."
"How about the other thing, the promise to obey? That is surely in
your power to keep."
She admits that she can keep that promise; but she leaves herself a
loophole. She does not say that she _will_ keep it.
And so the words of the prayer book shed no light on the situation, and
I shouldn't wonder if Fulton raged against the book, and flung it into
a far corner, and was immediately sorry.
For a man situated as Fulton was, some definite plan of action is
necessary; and to my mind the one that would be best would be one in
which the least possible consideration for the woman should be shown.
When Lucy began to play clench-dummy with her own life, with her
husband's love, and with the institution of marriage, Fulton, I think,
would have made no mistake if he had stripped her to the skin and taken
a great whip to her.
Her whole life had been one of self-indulgence. She had indulged
herself with Fulton's love till she was glutted with it; that she was
the mother of two children may, perhaps, be traced to self-indulgence,
and surely it must be laid down to self-indulgence that she was not the
mother of more than two. Her self-indulgence kept Fulton poor and in
debt, and it had come to this: that her impulse to self-indulgence
would now stop at nothing unless circumstances should prove too strong
for it.
It is not the gentle, faithful, self-sacrificing man who keeps his
wife's love; it never was. It was always the man who had in him a good
deal of the brute.
But, except in a moment of insanity, a man does not go against his
nature. Fulton has too good a brain not to think that if Lucy were
locked up for a week or so, and fed on bread and water, good might come
of it. But his was not the hand to turn the key in the lock. He could
no more have done it than he could have struck her. This sudden
failure of her love for him was only another evidence of that
wastefulness and extravagance which had so often hurt him financially.
Surely it must have occurred to him more than once to publish notices
in the newspapers to the effect that he would only be responsible for
his own debts. He must, I think, have threatened the thing from time
to time, knowing in his heart that he could never bring himself to put
it into execution.
I wonder how Fulton felt when hard upon the knowledge that she no
longer loved him, he received the bill for the dance which she had
given against his wishes, and in full knowledge of his present
financial predicament?
She had treated him so badly that it is a wonder of wonders that he
kept on loving her.
For one thing they deserve great credit. Even Evelyn Gray, a guest in
the house, did not know that there was any trouble between them. All
she thought was that owing to financial and other worries, which time
would right, Fulton seemed a little graver and less enthusiastic than
usual.
Nor was I any wiser. I had not, of course, so many chances of seeing
the two together, but I saw as much of Lucy as ever, for we rode
together nearly every day.