COUSIN MARY’S OPINION.
Geoff spent the remainder of this day at home, looking once more over
the file of old newspapers in which the Musgrave case was printed at
such length, the _Times_ and the local papers, with all their little
diversities of evidence, one supplementing another; but lie could not
make out any reference at all distinct to a third person in the story.
The two suitors of the village beauty, one of whom she preferred in
feeling, though the second of them had evidently made her waver in her
allegiance by the attractions of his superior rank and wealth, were
enough to fill up the canvas. They were so naturally and appropriately
pitted against each other, that neither the curiosity of the period nor
the art of the story-teller required any additional actor in the little
tragedy. What more natural than that these two rivals should
meet--should go from angry words to blows--and that, in the frenzy of
the moment, one should give to the other the fatal but unpremeditated
stroke which made an end of his rivalry and his life? The public
imagination is simple, and loves a simple story, and this was so
well-constructed and well-balanced--perfect in all its parts. What more
likely than that the humble coquette should hesitate and almost swerve
from her faith to her accepted lover when the young lord, so much more
splendid than the young squire, came on the scene? or that, when her
wavering produced such fatal consequences, the poor girl, not being
wicked, but only foolish, should have devoted herself with heroism to
the man whom she had been the means of drawing into deadly peril? Geoff,
however, with his eyes enlightened, could dimly perceive the traces of
another person unaccounted for, who had appeared casually in the course
of the drama. Indeed, the counsel for the prosecution had expressed his
regret that he could not call this person as a witness, as he was
supposed to have emigrated, and no trace could be found of him. His
name, however, was not mentioned, though the counsel for the defence,
evidently in complete ignorance, taunted his learned brother with the
non-appearance of this mysterious stranger, and defied him to prove, by
the production of him, that there had ever been feelings of bitter
animosity between Musgrave and Lord Stanton. “The jury would like to
know more about this anonymous gentleman,” the coroner had said. But no
evidence had ever been produced. Geoff searched through the whole case
carefully, making various notes, and feeling that he himself, anxious as
he had been, had never before noticed, except in the most incidental
way, these slight, mysterious references. Even now he was misty about
it. He was so tired, indeed, that his mind was less clear than usual;
and when good Mr. Tritton appeared in the afternoon, very red with
perpetual sneezing, his eyes running as with tears, he found Geoff in
the library, in a great chair, with all the papers strewed about,
sleeping profoundly, the old yellow _Times_ in his hand, and the
_Dalesman’s Gazette_ at his feet. The young man jumped up when Mr.
Tritton laid his hand on his shoulder, with quite unnecessary energy,
almost knocking down his respected instructor. “Take care, take care,
Geoff!” he cried; “I am not going to hurt you, my boy!” a speech which
amused Geoff greatly, who could have picked Mr. Tritton up and thrown
him across his shoulder. This interruption of his studies stopped them
for the time; but next morning--not without causing his mother some
anxiety--he proposed to ride over once more to Elfdale, to consult
Cousin Mary.
“It is but two days since we left, my dear,” Lady Stanton said, with a
sigh, thinking of all she had heard on the subject of “elderly sirens”;
but Geoff showed her so clearly how it was that he must refer his
difficulties to the person most qualified to solve them, that his mother
yielded; though she too began to ask herself why her son should be so
much concerned about John Musgrave. What was John Musgrave to Geoff? She
did not feel that it was quite appropriate that the person most
interested about poor Walter’s slayer should be Walter’s successor, he
who had most profited by the deed.
Geoff, however, had his way, and went to his cousin Mary with a great
deal of caution and anxiety, to hear all that she knew, and carefully to
conceal from her what he knew. He found her fortunately by herself, in
the languor of the afternoon, even Annie and Fanny having left her for
some garden game or other. Lady Stanton the younger was much surprised
to see her young cousin, and startled by his sudden appearance. “What is
the matter?” she asked, with a woman’s ready terror; and was still more
surprised that nothing was the matter, and that Geoff was but paying her
a simple visit. It may even be suspected that for a moment his mother’s
alarm communicated itself to Mary. Was it to see _her_ the boy had come
back so soon and so far? The innocent, kind woman was alarmed. She had
known herself a beauty for years, and she knew the common opinion (not
in her experience quite corroborated by fact) that for a beautiful face
a man will commit any folly. Was she in danger (“at my age!”) of
becoming a difficulty and a trouble to Geoff? But Geoff soon relieved
her mind, making her blush hotly at her own self-conceit and folly.
“I have come to ask you some questions,” he said; “you remember the man,
the poacher, whom you spoke to me about--the brother, you
know?--Bampfylde, whom they call Wild Bampfylde?”
“I know,” said Lady Stanton, with a suppressed shiver.
“I met him--the other night--and we got talking. I want you to tell me,
Cousin Mary: did you ever hear of--another of them--a brother they had?”
“Ah! that is it,” said Lady Stanton, clasping her hands together.
“That is what? Do you know anything about him? I should like to find
out; from something they--from something this poacher fellow said--he is
not a bad fellow,” said Geoff, in an undertone, with a kind of apology
in his mind to the vagrant of whom he seemed to be speaking
disrespectfully.
“Oh, Geoff, don’t have anything to do with them, dear. You don’t know
the ways of people like that. Young men think it is fine to show that
they are above the prejudices of their class, but it never comes to any
good. Poor Walter, if he had never seen her face, might have been--and
poor John--”
“But, Cousin Mary, about the brother?”
“Yes: he was their brother, but we did not find it out for a long time.
He was very clever, they said, and a scholar, but ashamed to belong to
such poor people. He never went there when he could help it. He took no
notice, I believe, of the others. He pretended to be a stranger visiting
the Lakes.”
“Cur!” said Geoff.
“Ye--es: it was not--nice; but it must be a temptation, Geoff, when a
man has been brought up so differently. Some relation had given him his
education, and he was very clever. I have never felt sure whether it was
a happy thing for a boy to be brought so far out of his class. He met
John Musgrave somewhere, but John did not know who he was. And just
about the time it all happened he went away. I used to think perhaps he
might have known something; but I suppose he thought it would all come
out, and his family be known. Fancy being ashamed of your own mother,
Geoff! But it was hard upon him too--an old woman who would tell your
fortune--who would stand with her basket in the market, you know: and
he, a great scholar, and considered a gentleman. It _was_ hard; I don’t
excuse him, but I was sorry for him; and I always thought if he came
back again, that he might know----”
Lady Stanton was not accustomed to speak so long and continuously. Her
delicate cheeks were stained with red patches; her breath came quick.
“Do you mean to say he has turned up again--at last?” she added, with a
little gasp.
“I have heard of him,” said Geoff. “I wondered--if he could have
anything to do with it.”
“I will tell you all about him, Geoff. It was John Musgrave who met with
him somewhere. Mary could tell you, too. She was John’s only sister, and
I her great friend; and I always took an interest. They met, I think,
abroad--and he--was of use to John somehow--I forget exactly:--that is
to say, Mr. Bampfield (he spelt his name differently from the others)
did something for him--in short, John said he saved his life. It was
among the Alps, on some precipice, or something of that sort. You see I
can only give you my recollection,” said Lady Stanton, falteringly
conscious of remembering everything about it. “John asked him to
Penninghame, but he would not come. He told us this new friend of his
knew the country quite well, but no one could get out of him where he
had lived. And then he came on a visit to some one else--to the
Fieldings, at Langdale--that was the family; and we all knew him. He was
very handsome; but who was to suppose that a gentleman visiting in such
a house was old ’Lizabeth’s son, or--or--that girl’s brother? No one
thought of such a thing. It was John who found it out at the very last.
It was because of something about myself. Oh, Geoff, I was not
offended--I was only sorry. Poor fellow! he was wrong, but it was hard
upon him. He thought he--took a fancy to me; and poor John was so
indignant. No, I assure you not on that account,” said Lady Stanton,
growing crimson to the eyes, and becoming incoherent. “Never! we were
like brother and sister. John never had such a thought in his mind. I
always--always took an interest in _him_--but there was never anything
of _that_ kind.”
Young Geoff felt himself blush too, as he listened to this confession.
He coloured in sympathy and tender fellow-feeling for her; for it was
not hard to read between the lines of Cousin Mary’s humble story. John
“never had such a thought in his mind;” but she “had always taken an
interest.” And the blush on her cheek and the water in her eyes told of
that interest still.
Then Geoff grew redder still, with another feeling. The madman in the
cottage had dared to lift his eyes to this woman so much above him.
“I don’t wonder Musgrave was furious,” he said.
“That is the right word,” she said, with a faint smile; “he was furious;
and Walter--your brother--laughed. I did not like that--it was
insulting. We were all young people together. Why should not he have
cared for--me?--when both of _them_----. But we must not think of
that--we must not talk of that, Geoff--we cannot blame your poor
brother. He is dead, poor fellow; and such a death, in the very flower
of his youth! What were a few little silly boyish faults to that? He
died, you know, and all the trouble came. Walter had been very
stinging--very insulting, to that poor fellow just the day before, and
he could not bear it. He went off that very day, and I have never heard
of him again. I don’t think people in general even knew who he was. The
Fieldings do not to this day. But Walter’s foolish joking drove him
away. Poor Walter, he had a way of talking--and I suppose he must have
found the secret out--or guessed. I have often--often wondered whether
Mr. Bampfield knew anything, whether if he had come back he would have
said anything about any quarrel between them. I used to pray for him to
be found, and then I used to pray that he might not be found; for I
always thought he could throw some light--and after all, what could that
light be but of one kind?”
“Did any one ever--suspect--_him_?”
“Geoff! you frighten me. Him! whom? You know who was suspected. I don’t
think it was intended, Geoff. I know--I know he did not mean it; but who
but one could have done if? There could not, alas, be any doubt about
that.”
“If Bampfield had been insulted and made angry, as you say, why should
not he have been suspected as well as Musgrave? The one, it seems to me,
was just as likely as the other----”
“Geoff! you take away my breath! But he was away; he left the day
before.”
“Suppose it was found out that he did not go away, Cousin Mary? Was he
more or less likely than Musgrave was to have done a crime?”
Lady Stanton looked at him with her eyes wide open, and her lips apart.
“You do not--mean anything? You have not--found out anything, Geoff?”
“I--can’t tell,” he said. “I think I have got a clue. If it were found
out that Bampfield did not go away--that he was still here, and met poor
Walter that fatal morning, what would you say then, you who knew them
all?”
All the colour ebbed out of Lady Stanton’s face. She kept looking at
him with wistful eyes, into which tears had risen, questioning him with
an earnestness beyond speech.
“I dare not say the words,” she said, faltering; “I don’t venture to say
the words. But, Geoff, you would not speak like this if you did not mean
something. Do you think--really _think_--oh, it is not possible--it is
not possible!--it is only a fancy. You can’t--suppose--that it
matters--much--to me. You are only--speculating. Perhaps it ought not to
matter much to me. But oh, Geoff! if--if you knew what that time was in
my life. Do you mean anything--do you mean anything, my dear?”
“You have not answered my question,” he said. “Which was the most likely
to have done a crime?”
Lady Stanton wrung her hands; she could not speak, but kept her eyes
upon him in beseeching suspense.
Geoff felt that he had raised a spirit beyond his power to calm again,
and he had not intended to commit himself or betray so soon what he had
heard.
“Nothing must be known as yet,” he said; “but I think I have some reason
to speak. Bampfield did not leave the country when you thought he did.
He saw poor Walter that morning. If Musgrave saw him at all----”
Lady Stanton gave a little cry--“You mean Walter, Geoff?”
“Yes; if Musgrave saw him at all, it was not till after. And Bampfield
was the brother of the girl John was going to marry, and had saved his
life.”
“My God!” This was no profane exclamation in Mary’s mouth. She said it
low to herself, clasping her hands together, her face utterly
colourless, her eyes wild with wonder and excitement. The shock of this
disclosure had driven away the rising tears: and yet Geoff did not mean
it as a disclosure. He had trusted in the gentle slowness of her
understanding. But there are cases in which feeling supplies all, and
more than all, that intellect could give. She said nothing, but sat
there silent, with her hands clasped, thinking it over, piecing
everything together. No one like Mary had kept hold of every detail; she
remembered everything as clearly as if (God forbid!) it had happened
yesterday. She put one thing to another which she remembered but no one
else did: and gradually it all became clear to her. Geoff, though he was
so much more clever, did not understand the process by which in silence
she arranged and perceived every point; but then Geoff had not the
minute acquaintance with the subject nor the feeling which touched every
point with interest. By and by Mary began to sob, her gentle breast
heading with emotion. “Oh, Geoff,” she cried, “what a heart--what a
heart! He is like our Saviour; he has given his life for his enemy. Not
even his friend; he was not fond of him; he did not love him. Who could
love him--a man who was ashamed of his own, his very own people? I--oh,
how little and how poor we are! I might have done it perhaps for my
friend; but he--he is like our Saviour.”
“Don’t say so. It was not just--it was not right; he ought not to have
done it,” cried Geoff. “Think, if it saved something, how much trouble
it has made.”
“Then it is all true!” she cried, triumphant. In perfect good faith and
tender feeling Mary had made her comment upon this strange, sad
revelation; yet she could not but feel all the same the triumph of
having thus caught Geoff, and of establishing beyond all doubt that it
was true. She fell a-crying in the happiness of the discovery. The
moment it was certain, the solemnity of it blew aside, as do the mists
before the wind. “Then he will come home again; he will have his poor
little children, and all will be well,” she said; and cried as if her
heart would break. It was vain for Geoff to tell her that nothing was as
yet proved, that he did not know how to approach the subject; no
difficulties troubled Mary. Her heart was delivered as of a load; and
why should not everything at once be told? But she wept all the same,
and Geoff had no clue to the meaning of her tears. She was glad beyond
measure for John Musgrave; but yet while he was an exile, who had
(secretly) stood up for him as she had done? But when he came home, what
would Mary have to do with him? Nothing! She would never see him, though
she had always taken an interest, and he would never know what interest
she had taken. How glad she was! and yet how the tears poured down!
Geoff had a long ride home. He was half alarmed that he had allowed so
much to be known, but yet he had not revealed Lizabeth’s secret. Mary
had required no particulars, no proof. The suggestion was enough for
her. She was not judge or jury--but one to whom the slightest outlet
from that dark maze meant full illumination. Geoff could not but
speculate a little on the surface of the subject as he rode along
through the soft evening, in that unbroken yet active solitude which
makes a long ride or walk the most pleasant and sure moment for
“thinking over.” Geoff’s thoughts were quite superficial, as his
knowledge was. He wondered if John Musgrave had “taken an interest” in
Mary as she had done in him; and how it was that Mary had been his
brother’s betrothed, yet with so warm a sympathy for his brother’s
supposed slayer? And how it was that John Musgrave, if he had responded
at all to the “interest” she took in him, could have loved and married
Lily? All this perplexed Geoff. He did not go any deeper; he did not
think of the mingled feelings of the present moment, but only of the
tangled web of the past.
It grew dark before he got home. No moon, and a cloudy night disturbed
by threatenings or rather promise of rain, which the farmers were
anxious for, as they generally are when a short break of fine weather
bewilders their operations, in the north. As he turned out of the last
cross road, and got upon the straight way to Stanton, he suddenly became
aware of some one running by him on the green turf that edged the road
and in the shadow of the hedgerow. Geoff was startled by the first sight
of this moving shadow running noiselessly by his side. It was a safe
country, where there was no danger from thieves, and a “highwayman” was
a thing of the last century. But still Geoff shortened his whip in his
hand with a certain sense of insecurity. As he did so a voice came from
the shadow of the hedge. “It is but me, my young lord.” “You!” he cried.
He was relieved by the sound, for a close attendant on the road in the
dark, when all faces are alike undiscernible, is not pleasant. “What are
you doing here, Bampfylde? Are you snaring my birds, or scaring them, or
have you come to look after me?”
“Neither the one nor the other,” said Wild Bampfylde. “I have other
thoughts in my mind than the innocent creatures that harm no one. My
young lord, I cannot tell you what is coming, but something is coming.
It’s no you, and it’s no me, but it’s in the air; and I’m about,
whatever happens. If you want me, I’ll aye be within call. Not that I’m
spying on you; but whatever happens, I’m here.”
“And I want you. I want to ask you something,” cried Geoff; but he was
slow in putting his next question. It was about his cousin; and what he
wanted was some one who would see, without forcing him to put them into
words, the thoughts that arose in his mind. Therefore it was a long time
before he spoke again. But in the silence that ensued it soon became
evident to Geoff that the figure running along under the shadow of the
bushes had disappeared. He stopped his horse, but heard no footfall.
“Are you there, Bampfylde?” but his own voice was all he heard, falling
with startling effect into the silence. The vagrant had disappeared, and
not a creature was near. Geoff went on with a strange mixture of
satisfaction and annoyance. To have this wanderer “about” seemed a kind
of aid, and yet to have his movements spied upon did not please the
young man. But Bampfylde was no spy.