Ibbetson was not quite himself the next morning, Miss Cartwright thought
with a gentle uneasiness. He did not always hear when he was addressed,
and he did not say much about the event which was filling her own mind--
the arrival of the travellers. They were to come from Bologna by the
evening train, and Miss Cartwright would willingly have talked of
nothing else. Miss Preston, whose delight it was to paint darkly the
characters of her friend's friends, had shaken her head with great
energy over all she had gathered of the villa, and Jack's conduct in
absenting himself there, but Miss Cartwright was altogether impervious
to the most direct innuendoes. She was very glad he had made pleasant
friends, and seen a little of Italian villa life; she was very sorry for
the two fatherless young things, and when Phillis came, perhaps they
might all drive out together to Villa Carlina; worst of all, she was
quite sure Miss Preston would enjoy the change. As for any danger to
Phillis's happiness, the idea never crossed her simple and loyal mind.
Nor, after all, was there much danger as yet Jack was struck,
interested, touched, but the feelings kept themselves where they
started, not having run on into any thrill of love. Whether if he had
been free when he saw Beatrice matters might not have been different,
one cannot say. Perhaps. But he, too, was loyal. To him his
engagement was a fact, and his word a bond; and bonds and facts do exert
an influence over an honourable man, let passion say what it will
against them. That there was a certain peril cannot be denied, and it
lay in the fact that he did not love Phillis. He felt a sort of
attraction, a pitying tenderness, a conviction that to marry her was the
best way of bringing a skein or two out of their tangle, but this was
not love. And, meanwhile, the white villa set on the hillside, with its
flowers, its sweets, its Italian charm; the girl with her beauty, her
passionate nature, and yet her revolt against that very nature,
interested him. Who was this man, this Oliver Trent, who had so
suddenly appeared among them? A red-faced, hard-featured man, the
cousin, as, they said, of Kitty. But it was not Kitty whom he had
watched when they sat on the steps the evening before. It was not Kitty
who had seemed the most disturbed at his coming. Jack said to himself
that it was all nothing to him, still he could not help feeling curious,
and of course common courtesy demanded that he should go that morning to
the villa in order to inquire for the injured hand. After that morning
he would not be so completely his own master.
This, it will be seen, was the man's view of the matter, neither more
nor less. His imagination had been touched, but his mind was clear
enough to see things as they were, uncoloured by any strange and
dream-like tints. For the girl's, it was different.
Think at what a time of ferment he had suddenly touched her life. She
had grown through a childhood, saddened by that dreariest sorrow which
can befall a child--want of faith in those it should love--to a
womanhood from which it seemed as if all the sweetest belongings of her
age--care, watchfulness, guiding, were withdrawn. Its brightness was
darkened by memories, burdened by pledges. No doubt her state of
feeling was exaggerated, but through what strivings, seekings after
light, yearnings for justice, had that poor bent shoot struggled
upwards. The girl had an instinctive hatred of oppression, a longing to
protect, to deliver; the sort of spirit which has made heroines before
now, but also has often wrecked a woman's own peace. For those who have
it sometimes give up what is not theirs to give, the happiness of
others--or their own hearts, when they have passed from their keeping.
They have, too, their moments of revulsion, such a moment as had come to
Bice. She had believed that she had the strength to do anything which
could shield her mother or Kitty--whom she loved with all her heart--
from trouble, and the trouble was there like a threatening cloud. Clive
Masters, Kitty's brother, had gone to England, and the lad, never very
wise, had fallen into some scrape such as the women out at the
Florentine villa did not understand and could but tremble over, when
Oliver Trent hinted darkly at its consequences. How darkly, only Bice
knew. It had been a revelation to him to note the eagerness, the
anxiety with which she listened when first he let drop the suggestion
that all was not going well with Clive; a revelation and--a temptation.
Nothing of his had touched her before beyond the surface; he had felt
with sharp bitterness that the girl in her beauty and her simplicity was
absolutely inaccessible. But not now. The tears would spring into her
beautiful eyes, a mute anguish of pleading would rise in her face when
he talked to her about Clive, the dangers of his position, the
probability of some dreadful discovery and disgrace. And then he would
gently let fall hints of his own efforts, of how his was the only hand
which could restrain the lad, his the one influence staving off exposure
and ruin. Very often he wondered at the readiness with which his
inventions were received, but what did Beatrice know of the world--such
a world as he described? To her it was all vague, unreal, far off; for
her, alas, it was not difficult to believe in its wickedness!
But it was only by little and little, by subtile touches on the strings
of gratitude and hope, by a gradual coiling round her of a net made up
of threads so fine that they were scarcely palpable, that he dared hint
at his purpose. If he had shown his hand too openly, and asked her to
be his wife as the price of his saving Clive, she might have yielded;
but all the generosity of her nature would have risen in revolt against
his meanness, she would have married and have hated him. Oliver wanted
something better than that for himself, and felt sure of gaining it. To
do so he would risk anything, and it seemed as if his purpose were on
the verge of accomplishment; Bice knew what he wanted, knew it in a
manner which let it seem the most natural thing in the world, and then
Oliver Trent made his great mistake. He went back to England, believing
that reflection and solitude, and the judicious letters he would write,
would all work for him, believing that he had skilfully provided against
all emergencies.
But how could he provide against Cartouche frightening a turkey to
death?
If it is strange that two days' acquaintanceship with another man should
have been enough to shake his influence, and to awaken the revulsion
which has been hinted at, surely the strangeness is not improbable.
Oliver's influence had been a power from without, a bewildering mist
raised with which he had hidden or distorted one thing after another,
and skilfully enveloped Bice's perceptions, but there was nothing in her
nature which was in sympathy with his; nay, rather there was something
which drew back shuddering. She might have been stirred to a blind leap
for those she loved, but to walk slowly along towards the gulf made it
seem a hundred times more terrible. And when--though as it were only in
passing--she came face to face with a man out of whose eyes looked truth
and straightforward honesty, the contrast affected her, although she
hardly knew how. Although she had believed Oliver, she had never really
trusted him, and Jack was a person whom you could not help trusting
absolutely. Certain characteristics write their signs in a face with
unerring accuracy. That night, in the shadowy fragrance of the garden,
Oliver Trent, jealously and uneasily watching the girl, did not know
that she too was watching him, noting, comparing, growing stiller and
sadder as she did so. A wild longing to escape and to burst her bonds
had seized her; horror at what she had done, hope that Ibbetson might
find a way to help them; none of them knew what a tumult was driving
through her heart as she sat silent.
When the two girls went up to their room, Bice hurriedly pushed back the
outer persiennes, and knelt down with her arms on the ledge. A sweet
cool air came up laden with the delicious sent of tuberoses, water
splashed dreamily in the distance, the grating croak of frogs and the
saw of the _grilli_ gave a little sharp invigoration to the softness of
the evening. Presently one of the odd little owls which Italians call
_civette_ began to hoot and call, and Kitty answered it back.
"I wish Pasquale would get us a _civetta_," she said. "Why don't you
tell him to do it, Bice? Pasquale never minds what I say, and they are
the dearest, wisest little things in the world. By the by, did you hear
Nina telling Oliver that Italians call a girl who jilts her lover a
_civetta_? And then--"
Kitty hesitated. Bice, still kneeling at the window, turned her head
towards her sister, with her cheek resting on her crossed arms--
"And then?" she repeated inquiringly.
"I don't quite like to tell you. Sometimes Nina is horrid. Well, she
gave a little nod towards you, as if Oliver should take care. Wasn't it
a shame?"
No answer came. Bice was looking out into the night again. Kitty, who
was very affectionate, but not quick in her perceptions, went on with
her small ripple of talk.
"What business has Nina to know anything? I can't think how she is
clever enough to find out, she has not seen much of Oliver. And why
should she trouble herself about it?"
"Don't you know?" said Bice, in a proud and bitter voice, "she is afraid
of Giovanni."
"Of Giovanni? Oh, nonsense! Why--he is a boy, he is nobody but just--
Giovanni! She can't be quite so silly. Bice, I do think you must be
mistaken; besides, why should she be afraid?"
Kitty's merry laugh rang out childlike and confident. Bice started to
her feet and turned round with a gesture that was almost fierce.
"You don't understand; you don't know anything about the world, you are
only a girl. Why should she be afraid?--because we are poor, and Nina
is a contessa living in a palace, and so she has found out that there is
nothing in all the world so good as money; and as she is fond of
Giovanni, she wants him to have a great _dola_ with his wife. That is
all, if you want to know."
"Then she is a silly," said Kitty, unmoved by this outburst. "As if
Giovanni were good enough for you!--or as if money were everything!"
"Perhaps it is more than we think," said Bice, still bitterly;
"sometimes I feel almost sure it is."
"It would give us some new dresses, to be sure," Kitty said, with a
general readiness to assent to her sister's ideas, "and a piano. I
should enjoy a piano."
"It would do more than that," Bice said abruptly. And then her voice
softened, the beautiful eyes grew wistful; she put her hands on the
girl's shoulders, and looked into her face. "Oh, Kitty," she said, "if
we only had a little money, you or I, we could save poor Clive
without--"
She stopped suddenly, and Kitty looked startled, for something in Bice's
manner thrilled through her.
"But," she said hesitatingly, "Oliver will do that. He has promised,
hasn't he?"
"Yes," said Bice, very slowly.
Alas! but it was she who had to promise also. "Then it's all right.
Oliver can do anything."
"Only if he is to do this, I must marry him."
She still spoke slowly, but her voice sounded strained and unnatural.
Kitty answered cheerfully--
"Yes, I know. But you like him, don't you? You made up your mind the
last time he was here, and there has been nothing to make you change.
And you always wanted to live in England. I don't think Oliver would be
at all a bad sort of person to marry."
"I have never said I would marry him," interrupted her sister.
"No," said Kitty doubtfully, "not exactly. Still you intended it."
"What has Clive done?" said Bice, looking at her with troubled eyes.
"We know very little about it all. Oliver always says we cannot
understand, and that it is better for us that he should not attempt to
explain; but I think it would be better if he _did_ explain; for now it
is like some dreadful dark shadow of disgrace hanging over us, never off
one's mind day and night." Kitty's eyes filled with tears.
"Is it so bad for you, dear?" she said sadly. "I have not troubled
myself much about it since Oliver said he would arrange. Surely he
knows best, and he is the only person to do anything."
"Why shouldn't Mr Ibbetson help us?" said Bice in a low voice. Her
sister cried out in astonishment, but the girl persisted. "There are
kind people in the world," she said, as her eyes brightened. "If you or
I saw anyone in trouble we should do what we could; and he is a man, he
knows about England and this world into which poor Clive has tumbled--he
might advise us."
"Not better than Oliver!" exclaimed Kitty, amazed. "Oh, I'm tired of
Oliver," cried Bice with petulant impatience. Her heart was rising up
in revolt against its fate till it burned within her. She was angry
with Clive, with Oliver, with Kitty, who could only praise him; most of
all with herself, the self which had grown all of a sudden discontented,
frightened, and indignant. How was it that the change had come, if it
was a change and not rather an awakening? How was it that life had in a
few hours blossomed into a hundred possibilities? She had thought of
Oliver Trent before with a sort of dull satisfaction, as a means of
helping Clive and of averting sorrow from those she loved; and as he had
skilfully managed to make himself necessary to her, her feelings towards
him were passive. But this calm was at an end. All that evening she
had been comparing, watching, reflecting; a light seemed suddenly to
have been turned upon him; she saw things written in his features which
she had never discovered before--some, very likely, which were not there
at all. "His eyes are close together, and there is a broad piece of
face beyond them--that is not good, I know," said the critic, "and his
face is red and hard." And all the time, joined with this revolt, some
strong new hope seemed to have leapt into her heart, uncalled for and
inexplicable. "There are kind people in the world," she had said to
Kitty, but what had brought her the sudden conviction? Is it not
pathetic sometimes to see how little will win a heart, and yet how much
fails to touch it? We take some trifling trouble, and, lo, an affection
is laid at our feet which years cannot change or parting cool. And
then, again, we give our life blood, and the gift is scorned. Jack had
felt attracted and touched, and had looked and spoken as he felt--
kindly, but it was no more than the commonest kindness, though to her it
seemed altogether special and delightful.
When Ibbetson reached Villa Carlina that morning, only Mrs Masters, in
her usual condition of good-natured drowsiness, was in the
breakfast-room, eating grapes from a great golden bunch which had just
been brought in with stalk and leaves attached; but before he had had
much time to ponder where he should find the others, Bice came, flushed
and smiling, and carrying a great bunch of flowers, jack felt himself
again wondering at her beauty. She had a white dress--indeed, as yet,
he had seen her in no other colour--but over her head she had flung a
veil of black lace, Milanese fashion, and the bright flowers in her
hands--big scarlet lilies, blue larkspurs, and another blue flower with
green spikes--made a brilliant flash of colour against the cool white
folds. Mrs Masters said plaintively--
"Where can you have been, Bice? They have been looking for you
everywhere until Oliver is quite vexed; go and find them in the garden,
and say that you are come."
"There is no hurry," said the girl lightly; "they do not want me."
"But where have you been?"
"To gather flowers for the Virgin's niche; and they are so scarce at
this time of the year, that I had to go a long way."
"So it is you who keep the flowers supplied?" said Ibbetson, remembering
that on the day he first saw the villa he had wondered whose hand had
placed the pretty nosegay.
"Yes. But we are English, and belong to the English Church," said
Beatrice quickly. "You will see us in Florence to-morrow. Only it
seemed so sad to leave that little shrine in the wall desolate after
flowers had been laid there for so many years; and the poor peasants who
come along that dusty road like to see something fresh and pretty when
they look up and pray; and so I am going there now," she said smiling;
"and you may come if you will, just to see how they get into the
grating."
"But there is Oliver," said Mrs Masters anxiously. "He has Kitty,"
Bice answered. "Or, if that does not content you, they are in the
garden, for I heard their voices, and it is there we are going."
Nevertheless Ibbetson fancied that she led him along paths which looked
mossy and unfrequented. There was a gloom about these paths even on
this bright day; dark ilexes shut out the sun overhead, long leaves of
narcissus straggled about, weedy-looking and untidy, amid the
undergrowth; one or two mutilated statues kept desolate ward over the
silence and dimness. The girl glanced round her and shivered.
"I wish I had not brought you here," she said uneasily; "there is
something in this walk which always oppresses me."
"If I had not seen it you would not have made me believe there was so
cheerless a spot so near the villa. But then, if you had not told me
the contrary, I could not have thought there was any dark shadow near
you in your happy country life."
Foolish, kind Jack! Ever since he had seen the tears in her eyes he had
felt that he should like to help her.
Bice stopped and looked earnestly at him.
"That is why I asked you to come with me," she said with a simple
straightforwardness which he had noticed in her before. "I thought if I
could tell you about Clive you might advise us what to do. I fancied I
understood, but it has all got into a tangle in my head. May I really
tell you?"
If Ibbetson had been less interested than he was, it would have been
impossible to have remained untouched by the frank simplicity of her
appeal.
"You may depend upon me," he said gravely.
Then she told her little story in a quiet voice, trying to put it into
as few words as possible. Clive was their brother, a lad of twenty-one.
About two years before, he had gone to London, having, by Oliver's
help, got into some great business house; "because we are poor, and it
was necessary he should do something to make money," she explained. At
first things had seemed to go well; he was quick and pleased his
employers, so that lately he had been promoted, but since then all had
been unsatisfactory. Oliver had been the kindest friend, and was the
first to give them a warning that the young fellow was not going on so
steadily. They had written imploring letters, and Clive had answered
them with such a frank acknowledgment that he had been wrong, and such a
clearly-expressed determination to turn over a new leaf, that they had
been happier. But, alas, six weeks ago Oliver Trent had come out from
England and had brought the worst news with him. He persistently
refused to tell them in plain words what had happened, but he hinted at
conduct on the part of Clive which had come to his knowledge though not
as yet to his employers, conduct which--known--must bring terrible
disgrace and ruin. The poor women were overwhelmed. He was not Mrs
Masters' son, but he was Kitty's brother, and the others entirely
accepted him as their own. What was to be done? Bice's first impulse
had been to write and question Clive, but that Mr Trent had absolutely
forbidden. Clive must not know that he was aware of his guilt, or it
would be impossible for him to help him. Whatever was done must be done
through himself alone, and this at a great risk. Bice could not
understand what plan Mr Trent had in his head; he did not confide it to
her: she imagined only that there was some man whose silence he meant to
buy; at any rate he had promised to help them provided everything was
left in his hands. She flushed and looked down as she said these words,
and Ibbetson, whose suspicions had been awakened the night before,
guessed that there was another "provided" which had received a tacit
acquiescence. But, good heavens, what was he to say! He had not
bargained for a story like this, for being asked to assist in condoning
a felony--to which it all pointed. Probably the unfortunate boy had
forged a signature, and Trent held the proofs, and meant to use them.
He remained altogether silent.
In the trouble of her own feelings the girl was not at first conscious
of his dismay. She was walking along and looking down, but as he did
not speak she glanced at him and stopped with a little cry.
"Oh!" she exclaimed, "I shouldn't have told you, I have only set you
against him. I should have believed Oliver when he said that no one
must know."
"You need not fear me," said the young man gravely. "I mayn't be able
to help, but you may be sure I will never betray your trust. And if I
can't help, perhaps I may at least advise."
She stood still and began nervously to pick off the leaves of a branch
of ilex and to roll them together.
"If there is any way by which we could save him from disgrace," she
began hurriedly, when Ibbetson interrupted her--
"But if I understand you rightly, that is just what Mr Trent has
promised to do?"
The girl became very pale.
"Yes," she said at last with an effort. "You are right. I don't know
why I appealed to you. Forget it, and don't let us say any more."
Her voice was proud and hurt. She looked straight before her, and was
moving forwards when Jack detained her.
"You must let me give you my advice," he said kindly. "It will not be
the same as Mr Trent's, and I fear you mayn't like it so well, but if I
had a brother in the same position as your brother, I should not rest
until--"
"Until--?" she asked with eagerness.
"Until I had induced him to make a clean breast of it."
"You mean to us?"
"No: I mean to his employers."
The girl started as if she had been stung. She stood still, her breast
heaved, the burning colour rushed into her face.
"But that is the very disgrace we are trying to avoid!" she cried with a
sharp ring in her voice. "It is cruel to mock me with such words. Why,
why that is the worst that could happen, and you speak of it as calmly
as if--"
"Mock you!" cried Jack, hurt in his turn. "Have I ever said anything
which should make you think me such a brute? At least hear me until I
have explained myself. This affair, whatever it is, if it is covered up
and concealed in the manner in which you have hinted, will hang over
your heads with a never-ending dread. Something may always bring it to
light, and your brother will be haunted by fear of it. But if he takes
courage and speaks openly, his employers will be at once half won over,
I am sure of it; they will think of his youth, of his inexperience--even
business men have hearts, Miss Masters. Believe me, it is the most
honourable way."
She listened very quietly, though her face was still flushed, and when
he had finished she remained silent. Suddenly, at a little distance,
they heard voices, and Bice said hurriedly--
"This is your only advice?"
"I can think of nothing else."
"I must have time for considering it, and I don't want Oliver to guess
that we have been talking: if you will go straight along this path you
will come to a door in the wall by which you can get into the road. Do
not be vexed with me for sending you away."
"One word--how is your hand?"
"Oh, almost well."
"And when shall I see you again?"
"When you like to come," said Bice smiling; "or, perhaps, to-morrow in
Florence. We shall be there, as I said, for the service."
"Then will you come afterwards to luncheon at my aunt's--Casa Giulia?
She is longing to make your acquaintance, and I shall feel sure you have
forgiven me."
"Oh, I have forgiven you," said Bice, after a pause, "Well, we will
come--"