For a moment he hesitated. “The house is saturated with a thought. It is
haunted by treachery.”
“You mean something happened here?”
“I mean—” He bent forward, groping for the right word, while his gaze
sought the river, where a golden web of mist hung midway between sky and
water. “I am an old man, and I have lived long enough to see every act
merely as the husk of an idea. The act dies; it decays like the body,
but the idea is immortal. The thing that happened at Dare’s Gift was
over fifty years ago, but the thought of it still lives—still utters its
profound and terrible message. The house is a shell, and if one listens
long enough one can hear in its heart the low murmur of the past—of that
past which is but a single wave of the great sea of human experience—”
“But the story?” I was becoming impatient of his theories. After all, if
Mildred was the victim of some phantasmal hypnosis, I was anxious to
meet the ghost who had hypnotized her. Even Drayton, I reflected, keen
as he was about the fact of mental suggestion, would never have regarded
seriously the suggestion of a phantom. And the house looked so
peaceful—so hospitable in the afternoon light.
“The story? Oh, I am coming to that—but of late the story has meant so
little to me beside the idea. I like to stop by the way. I am getting
old, and an amble suits me better than too brisk a trot—particularly in
this weather—”
Yes, he was getting old. I lit a fresh cigarette and waited impatiently.
After all, this ghost that he rambled about was real enough to destroy
me, and my nerves were quivering like harp-strings.
“Well, I came into the story—I was in the very thick of it, by accident,
if there is such a thing as accident in this world of incomprehensible
laws. The Incomprehensible! That has always seemed to me the supreme
fact of life, the one truth overshadowing all others—the truth that we
know nothing. We nibble at the edges of the mystery, and the great
Reality—the Incomprehensible—is still untouched, undiscovered. It
unfolds hour by hour, day by day, creating, enslaving, killing us, while
we painfully gnaw off—what? A crumb or two, a grain from that vastness
which envelops us, which remains impenetrable—”
Again he broke off, and again I jerked him back from his reverie.
“As I have said, I was placed, by an act of Providence, or of chance, in
the very heart of the tragedy. I was with Lucy Dare on the day, the
unforgettable day, when she made her choice—her heroic or devilish
choice, according to the way one has been educated. In Europe a thousand
years ago such an act committed for the sake of religion would have made
her a saint; in New England, a few centuries past, it would have
entitled her to a respectable position in history—the little history of
New England. But Lucy Dare was a Virginian, and in Virginia—except in
the brief, exalted Virginia of the Confederacy—the personal loyalties
have always been esteemed beyond the impersonal. I cannot imagine us as
a people canonizing a woman who sacrificed the human ties for the
superhuman—even for the divine. I cannot imagine it, I repeat; and so
Lucy Dare—though she rose to greatness in that one instant of
sacrifice—has not even a name among us to-day. I doubt if you can find a
child in the State who has ever heard of her—or a grown man, outside of
this neighbourhood, who could give you a single fact of her history. She
is as completely forgotten as Sir Roderick, who betrayed Bacon—she is
forgotten because the thing she did, though it might have made a Greek
tragedy, was alien to the temperament of the people among whom she
lived. Her tremendous sacrifice failed to arrest the imagination of her
time. After all, the sublime cannot touch us unless it is akin to our
ideal; and though Lucy Dare was sublime, according to the moral code of
the Romans, she was a stranger to the racial soul of the South. Her
memory died because it was the bloom of an hour—because there was
nothing in the soil of her age for it to thrive on. She missed her time;
she is one of the mute inglorious heroines of history; and yet, born in
another century, she might have stood side by side with Antigone—” For
an instant he paused. “But she has always seemed to me diabolical,” he
added.
“What she did, then, was so terrible that it has haunted the house ever
since?” I asked again, for, wrapped in memories, he had lost the thread
of his story.
“What she did was so terrible that the house has never forgotten. The
thought in Lucy Dare’s mind during those hours while she made her choice
has left an ineffaceable impression on the things that surrounded her.
She created in the horror of that hour an unseen environment more real,
because more spiritual, than the material fact of the house. You won’t
believe this, of course—if people believed in the unseen as in the seen,
would life be what it is?”
The afternoon light slept on the river; the birds were mute in the
elm-trees; from the garden of herbs at the end of the terrace an
aromatic fragrance rose like invisible incense.
“To understand it all, you must remember that the South was dominated,
was possessed by an idea—the idea of the Confederacy. It was an exalted
idea—supremely vivid, supremely romantic—but, after all, it was only an
idea. It existed nowhere within the bounds of the actual unless the
souls of its devoted people may be regarded as actual. But it is the
dream, not the actuality, that commands the noblest devotion, the
completest self-sacrifice. It is the dream, the ideal, that has ruled
mankind from the beginning.
“I saw a great deal of the Dares that year. It was a lonely life I led
after I lost my leg at Seven Pines, and dropped out of the army, and, as
you may imagine, a country doctor’s practice in wartimes was far from
lucrative. Our one comfort was that we were all poor, that we were all
starving together; and the Dares—there were only two of them, father and
daughter—were as poor as the rest of us. They had given their last coin
to the government—had poured their last bushel of meal into the sacks of
the army. I can imagine the superb gesture with which Lucy Dare flung
her dearest heirloom—her one remaining brooch or pin—into the bare
coffers of the Confederacy. She was a small woman, pretty rather than
beautiful—not the least heroic in build—yet I wager that she was heroic
enough on that occasion. She was a strange soul, though I never so much
as suspected her strangeness while I knew her—while she moved among us
with her small oval face, her gentle blue eyes, her smoothly banded
hair, which shone like satin in the sunlight. Beauty she must have had
in a way, though I confess a natural preference for queenly women; I
dare say I should have preferred Octavia to Cleopatra, who, they tell
me, was small and slight. But Lucy Dare wasn’t the sort to blind your
eyes when you first looked at her. Her charm was like a fragrance rather
than a colour—a subtle fragrance that steals into the senses and is the
last thing a man ever forgets. I knew half a dozen men who would have
died for her—and yet she gave them nothing, nothing, barely a smile. She
appeared cold—she who was destined to flame to life in an act. I can see
her distinctly as she looked then, in that last year—grave, still, with
the curious, unearthly loveliness that comes to pretty women who are
underfed—who are slowly starving for bread and meat, for bodily
nourishment. She had the look of one dedicated—as ethereal as a saint,
and yet I never saw it at the time; I only remember it now, after fifty
years, when I think of her. Starvation, when it is slow, not quick—when
it means, not acute hunger, but merely lack of the right food, of the
blood-making, nerve-building elements—starvation like this often plays
strange pranks with one. The visions of the saints, the glories of
martyrdom, come to the underfed, the anaemic. Can you recall one of the
saints—the genuine sort—whose regular diet was roast beef and ale?
“Well, I have said that Lucy Dare was a strange soul, and she was,
though to this day I don’t know how much of her strangeness was the
result of improper nourishment, of too little blood to the brain. Be
that as it may, she seems to me when I look back on her to have been one
of those women whose characters are shaped entirely by external
events—who are the playthings of circumstance. There are many such
women. They move among us in obscurity—reserved, passive,
commonplace—and we never suspect the spark of fire in their natures
until it flares up at the touch of the unexpected. In ordinary
circumstances Lucy Dare would have been ordinary, submissive, feminine,
domestic; she adored children. That she possessed a stronger will than
the average Southern girl, brought up in the conventional manner, none
of us—least of all I, myself—ever imagined. She was, of course,
intoxicated, obsessed, with the idea of the Confederacy; but, then, so
were all of us. There wasn’t anything unusual or abnormal in that
exalted illusion. It was the common property of our generation....
“Like most non-combatants, the Dares were extremists, and I, who had got
rid of a little of my bad blood when I lost my leg, used to regret
sometimes that the Colonel—I never knew where he got his title—was too
old to do a share of the actual fighting. There is nothing that takes
the fever out of one so quickly as a fight; and in the army I had never
met a hint of this concentrated, vitriolic bitterness towards the enemy.
Why, I’ve seen the Colonel, sitting here on this terrace, and crippled
to the knees with gout, grow purple in the face if I spoke so much as a
good word for the climate of the North. For him, and for the girl, too,
the Lord had drawn a divine circle round the Confederacy. Everything
inside of that circle was perfection; everything outside of it was evil.
Well, that was fifty years ago, and his hate is all dust now; yet I can
sit here, where he used to brood on this terrace, sipping his blackberry
wine—I can sit here and remember it all as if it were yesterday. The
place has changed so little, except for Duncan’s grotesque additions to
the wings, that one can scarcely believe all these years have passed
over it. Many an afternoon just like this I’ve sat here, while the
Colonel nodded and Lucy knitted for the soldiers, and watched these same
shadows creep down the terrace and that mist of light—it looks just as
it used to—hang there over the James. Even the smell from those herbs
hasn’t changed. Lucy used to keep her little garden at the end of the
terrace, for she was fond of making essences and beauty lotions. I used
to give her all the prescriptions I could find in old books I read—and
I’ve heard people say that she owed her wonderful white skin to the
concoctions she brewed from shrubs and herbs. I couldn’t convince them
that lack of meat, not lotions, was responsible for the pallor—pallor
was all the fashion then—that they admired and envied.”
He stopped a minute, just long enough to refill his pipe, while I
glanced with fresh interest at the garden of herbs.
“It was a March day when it happened,” he went on presently; “cloudless,
mild, with the taste and smell of spring in the air. I had been at
Dare’s Gift almost every day for a year. We had suffered together,
hoped, feared, and wept together, hungered and sacrificed together. We
had felt together the divine, invincible sway of an idea.
“Stop for a minute and picture to yourself what it is to be of a war and
yet not in it; to live in imagination until the mind becomes inflamed
with the vision; to have no outlet for the passion that consumes one
except the outlet of thought. Add to this the fact that we really knew
nothing. We were as far away from the truth, stranded here on our river,
as if we had been anchored in a canal on Mars. Two men—one crippled, one
too old to fight—and a girl—and the three living for a country which in
a few weeks would be nothing—would be nowhere—not on any map of the
world....
“When I look back now it seems to me incredible that at that time any
persons in the Confederacy should have been ignorant of its want of
resources. Yet remember we lived apart, remote, unvisited, out of touch
with realities, thinking the one thought. We believed in the ultimate
triumph of the South with that indomitable belief which is rooted not in
reason, but in emotion. To believe had become an act of religion; to
doubt was rank infidelity. So we sat there in our little world, the
world of unrealities, bounded by the river and the garden, and talked
from noon till sunset about our illusion—not daring to look a single
naked fact in the face—talking of plenty when there were no crops in the
ground and no flour in the storeroom, prophesying victory while the
Confederacy was in her death-struggle. Folly! All folly, and yet I am
sure even now that we were sincere, that we believed the nonsense we
were uttering. We believed, I have said, because to doubt would have
been far too horrible. Hemmed in by the river and the garden, there
wasn’t anything left for us to do—since we couldn’t fight—but believe.
Someone has said, or ought to have said, that faith is the last refuge
of the inefficient. The twin devils of famine and despair were at work
in the country, and we sat there—we three, on this damned terrace—and
prophesied about the second president of the Confederacy. We agreed, I
remember, that Lee would be the next president. And all the time, a few
miles away, the demoralization of defeat was abroad, was around us, was
in the air....
“It was a March afternoon when Lucy sent for me, and while I walked up
the drive—there was not a horse left among us, and I made all my rounds
on foot—I noticed that patches of spring flowers were blooming in the
long grass on the lawn. The air was as soft as May, and in the woods at
the back of the house buds of maple-trees ran like a flame. There were,
I remember, leaves—dead leaves, last year’s leaves—everywhere, as if, in
the demoralization of panic, the place had been forgotten, had been
untouched since autumn. I remember rotting leaves that gave like moss
underfoot; dried leaves that stirred and murmured as one walked over
them; black leaves, brown leaves, wine-coloured leaves, and the still
glossy leaves of the evergreens. But they were everywhere—in the road,
over the grass on the lawn, beside the steps, piled in wind-drifts
against the walls of the house.
“On the terrace, wrapped in shawls, the old Colonel was sitting; and he
called out excitedly, ‘Are you bringing news of a victory?’ Victory!
when the whole country had been scraped with a fine-tooth comb for
provisions.
“‘No, I bring no news except that Mrs. Morson has just heard of the
death of her youngest son in Petersburg. Gangrene, they say. The truth
is the men are so ill-nourished that the smallest scratch turns to
gangrene—’
“‘Well, it won’t be for long—not for long. Let Lee and Johnston get
together and things will go our way with a rush. A victory or two, and
the enemy will be asking for terms of peace before the summer is over.’
“A lock of his silver-white hair had fallen over his forehead, and
pushing it back with his clawlike hand, he peered up at me with his
little nearsighted eyes, which were of a peculiar burning blackness,
like the eyes of some small enraged animal. I can see him now as vividly
as if I had left him only an hour ago, and yet it is fifty years since
then—fifty years filled with memories and with forgetfulness. Behind him
the warm red of the bricks glowed as the sunshine fell, sprinkled with
shadows, through the elm boughs. Even the soft wind was too much for
him, for he shivered occasionally in his blanket shawls, and coughed the
dry, hacking cough which had troubled him for a year. He was a shell of
a man—a shell vitalized and animated by an immense, an indestructible
illusion. While he sat there, sipping his blackberry wine, with his
little fiery dark eyes searching the river in hope of something that
would end his interminable expectancy, there was about him a fitful
sombre gleam of romance. For him the external world, the actual truth of
things, had vanished—all of it, that is, except the shawl that wrapped
him and the glass of blackberry wine he sipped. He had died already to
the material fact, but he lived intensely, vividly, profoundly, in the
idea. It was the idea that nourished him, that gave him his one hold on
reality.
“‘It was Lucy who sent for you,’ said the old man presently. ‘She has
been on the upper veranda all day overlooking something—the sunning of
winter clothes, I think. She wants to see you about one of the
servants—a sick child, Nancy’s child, in the quarters.’
“‘Then I’ll find her,’ I answered readily, for I had, I confess, a mild
curiosity to find out why Lucy had sent for me.
“She was alone on the upper veranda, and I noticed that she closed her
Bible and laid it aside as I stepped through the long window that opened
from the end of the hall. Her face, usually so pale, glowed now with a
wan illumination, like ivory before the flame of a lamp. In this
illumination her eyes, beneath delicately pencilled eyebrows, looked
unnaturally large and brilliant, and so deeply, so angelically blue that
they made me think of the Biblical heaven of my childhood. Her beauty,
which had never struck me sharply before, pierced through me. But it was
her fate—her misfortune perhaps—to appear commonplace, to pass
unrecognized, until the fire shot from her soul.
“‘No, I want to see you about myself, not about one of the servants.’
“At my first question she had risen and held out her hand—a white, thin
hand, small and frail as a child’s.
“‘You are not well, then?’ I had known from the first that her starved
look meant something.
“‘It isn’t that; I am quite well.’ She paused a moment, and then looked
at me with a clear shining gaze. ‘I have had a letter,’ she said.
“‘A letter?’ I have realized since how dull I must have seemed to her in
that moment of excitement, of exaltation.
“‘You didn’t know. I forgot that you didn’t know that I was once
engaged—long ago—before the beginning of the war. I cared a great
deal—we both cared a great deal, but he was not one of us; he was on the
other side—and when the war came, of course there was no question. We
broke it off; we had to break it off. How could it have been possible to
do otherwise?’
“‘How, indeed!’ I murmured; and I had a vision of the old man downstairs
on the terrace, of the intrepid and absurd old man.
“‘My first duty is to my country,’ she went on after a minute, and the
words might have been spoken by her father. ‘There has been no thought
of anything else in my mind since the beginning of the war. Even if
peace comes I can never feel the same again—I can never forget that he
has been a part of all we have suffered—of the thing that has made us
suffer. I could never forget—I can never forgive.’
“Her words sound strange now, you think, after fifty years; but on that
day, in this house surrounded by dead leaves, inhabited by an
inextinguishable ideal—in this county, where the spirit had fed on the
body until the impoverished brain reacted to transcendent visions—in
this place, at that time, they were natural enough. Scarcely a woman of
the South but would have uttered them from her soul. In every age one
ideal enthralls the imagination of mankind; it is in the air; it
subjugates the will; it enchants the emotions. Well, in the South fifty
years ago this ideal was patriotism; and the passion of patriotism,
which bloomed like some red flower, the flower of carnage, over the
land, had grown in Lucy Dare’s soul into an exotic blossom.
“Yet even to-day, after fifty years, I cannot get over the impression
she made upon me of a woman who was, in the essence of her nature, thin
and colourless. I may have been wrong. Perhaps I never knew her. It is
not easy to judge people, especially women, who wear a mask by instinct.
What I thought lack of character, of personality, may have been merely
reticence; but again and again there comes back to me the thought that
she never said or did a thing—except the one terrible thing—that one
could remember. There was nothing remarkable that one could point to
about her. I cannot recall either her smile or her voice, though both
were sweet, no doubt, as the smile and the voice of a Southern woman
would be. Until that morning on the upper veranda I had not noticed that
her eyes were wonderful. She was like a shadow, a phantom, that attains
in one supreme instant, by one immortal gesture, union with reality.
Even I remember her only by that one lurid flash.
“‘And you say you have had a letter?’
“‘It was brought by one of the old servants—Jacob, the one who used to
wait on him when he stayed here. He was a prisoner. A few days ago he
escaped. He asked me to see him—and I told him to come. He wishes to see
me once again before he goes North—for ever—’ She spoke in gasps in a
dry voice. Never once did she mention his name. Long afterwards I
remembered that I had never heard his name spoken. Even to-day I do not
know it. He also was a shadow, a phantom—a part of the encompassing
unreality.
“‘And he will come here?’
“For a moment she hesitated; then she spoke quite simply, knowing that
she could trust me.
“‘He is here. He is in the chamber beyond.’ She pointed to one of the
long windows that gave on the veranda. ‘The blue chamber at the front.’
“I remember that I made a step towards the window when her voice
arrested me. ‘Don’t go in. He is resting. He is very tired and hungry.’
“‘You didn’t send for me, then, to see him?’
“‘I sent for you to be with father. I knew you would help me—that you
would keep him from suspecting. He must not know, of course. He must be
kept quiet.’
“‘I will stay with him,’ I answered, and then, ‘Is that all you wish to
say to me?’
“‘That is all. It is only for a day or two. He will go on in a little
while, and I can never see him again. I do not wish to see him again.’
“I turned away, crossed the veranda, entered the hall, walked the length
of it, and descended the staircase. The sun was going down in a
ball—just as it will begin to go down in a few minutes—and as I
descended the stairs I saw it through the mullioned window over the
door—huge and red and round above the black cloud of the cedars.
“The old man was still on the terrace. I wondered vaguely why the
servants had not brought him indoors; and then, as I stepped over the
threshold, I saw that a company of soldiers—Confederates—had crossed the
lawn and were already gathering about the house. The commanding
officer—I was shaking hands with him presently—was a Dare, a distant
cousin of the Colonel’s, one of those excitable, nervous, and slightly
theatrical natures who become utterly demoralized under the spell of any
violent emotion. He had been wounded at least a dozen times, and his
lean, sallow, still handsome features had the greenish look which I had
learned to associate with chronic malaria.
“When I look back now I can see it all as a part of the general
disorganization—of the fever, the malnutrition, the complete
demoralization of panic. I know now that each man of us was facing in
his soul defeat and despair; and that we—each one of us—had gone mad
with the thought of it. In a little while, after the certainty of
failure had come to us, we met it quietly—we braced our souls for the
issue; but in those last weeks defeat had all the horror, all the insane
terror of a nightmare, and all the vividness. The thought was like a
delusion from which we fled, and which no flight could put farther away
from us.
“Have you ever lived, I wonder, from day to day in that ever-present and
unchanging sense of unreality, as if the moment before you were but an
imaginary experience which must dissolve and evaporate before the touch
of an actual event? Well, that was the sensation I had felt for days,
weeks, months, and it swept over me again while I stood there, shaking
hands with the Colonel’s cousin, on the terrace. The soldiers, in their
ragged uniforms, appeared as visionary as the world in which we had been
living. I think now that they were as ignorant as we were of the things
that had happened—that were happening day by day to the army. The truth
is that it was impossible for a single one of us to believe that our
heroic army could be beaten even by unseen powers—even by hunger and
death.
“‘And you say he was a prisoner?’ It was the old man’s quavering voice,
and it sounded avid for news, for certainty.
“‘Caught in disguise. Then he slipped through our fingers.’ The cousin’s
tone was querulous, as if he were irritated by loss of sleep or of food.
‘Nobody knows how it happened. Nobody ever knows. But he has found out
things that will ruin us. He has plans. He has learned things that mean
the fall of Richmond if he escapes.’
“Since then I have wondered how much they sincerely believed—how much
was simply the hallucination of fever, of desperation? Were they trying
to bully themselves by violence into hoping? Or had they honestly
convinced themselves that victory was still possible? If one only
repeats a phrase often and emphatically enough one comes in time to
believe it; and they had talked so long of that coming triumph, of the
established Confederacy, that it had ceased to be, for them at least,
merely a phrase. It wasn’t the first occasion in life when I had seen
words bullied—yes, literally bullied into beliefs.
“Well, looking back now after fifty years, you see, of course, the
weakness of it all, the futility. At that instant, when all was lost,
how could any plans, any plotting have ruined us? It seems irrational
enough now—a dream, a shadow, that belief—and yet not one of us but
would have given our lives for it. In order to understand you must
remember that we were, one and all, victims of an idea—of a divine
frenzy.
“‘And we are lost—the Confederacy is lost, you say, if he escapes?’
“It was Lucy’s voice; and turning quickly, I saw that she was standing
in the doorway. She must have followed me closely. It was possible that
she had overheard every word of the conversation.
“‘If Lucy knows anything, she will tell you. There is no need to search
the house,’ quavered the old man, ‘she is my daughter.’
“‘Of course we wouldn’t search the house—not Dare’s Gift,’ said the
cousin. He was excited, famished, malarial, but he was a gentleman,
every inch of him.
“He talked on rapidly, giving details of the capture, the escape, the
pursuit. It was all rather confused. I think he must have frightfully
exaggerated the incident. Nothing could have been more unreal than it
sounded. And he was just out of a hospital—was suffering still, I could
see, from malaria. While he drank his blackberry wine—the best the house
had to offer—I remember wishing that I had a good dose of quinine and
whiskey to give him.
“The narrative lasted a long time; I think he was glad of a rest and of
the blackberry wine and biscuits. Lucy had gone to fetch food for the
soldiers; but after she had brought it she sat down in her accustomed
chair by the old man’s side and bent her head over her knitting. She was
a wonderful knitter. During all the years of the war I seldom saw her
without her ball of yam and her needles—the long wooden kind that the
women used at that time. Even after the dusk fell in the evenings the
click of her needles sounded in the darkness.
“‘And if he escapes it will mean the capture of Richmond?’ she asked
once again when the story was finished. There was no hint of excitement
in her manner. Her voice was perfectly toneless. To this day I have no
idea what she felt—what she was thinking.
“‘If he gets away it is the ruin of us—but he won’t get away. We’ll find
him before morning.’
“Rising from his chair, he turned to shake hands with the old man before
descending the steps. ‘We’ve got to go on now. I shouldn’t have stopped
if we hadn’t been half starved. You’ve done us a world of good, Cousin
Lucy. I reckon you’d give your last crust to the soldiers?’
“‘She’d give more than that,’ quavered the old man. ‘You’d give more
than that, wouldn’t you, Lucy?’
“‘Yes, I’d give more than that,’ repeated the girl quietly, so quietly
that it came as a shock to me—like a throb of actual pain in the midst
of a nightmare—when she rose to her feet and added, without a movement,
without a gesture, ‘You must not go, Cousin George. He is upstairs in
the blue chamber at the front of the house.’
“For an instant surprise held me speechless, transfixed, incredulous;
and in that instant I saw a face—a white face of horror and
disbelief—look down on us from one of the side-windows of the blue
chamber. Then, in a rush it seemed to me the soldiers were everywhere,
swarming over the terrace, into the hall, surrounding the house. I had
never imagined that a small body of men in uniforms, even ragged
uniforms, could so possess and obscure one’s surroundings. The three of
us waited there—Lucy had sat down again and taken up her knitting—for
what seemed hours, or an eternity. We were still waiting—though, for
once, I noticed, the needles did not click in her fingers—when a single
shot, followed by a volley, rang out from the rear of the house, from
the veranda that looked down on the grove of oaks and the kitchen.
“Rising, I left them—the old man and the girl—and passed from the
terrace down the little walk which led to the back. As I reached the
lower veranda one of the soldiers ran into me.
“‘I was coming after you,’ he said, and I observed that his excitement
had left him. ‘We brought him down while he was trying to jump from the
veranda. He is there now on the grass.’
“The man on the grass was quite dead, shot through the heart; and while
I bent over to wipe the blood from his lips, I saw him for the first
time distinctly. A young face, hardly more than a boy—twenty-five at the
most. Handsome, too, in a poetic and dreamy way; just the face, I
thought, that a woman might have fallen in love with. He had dark hair,
I remember, though his features have long ago faded from my memory. What
will never fade, what I shall never forget, is the look he wore—the look
he was still wearing when we laid him in the old graveyard next day—a
look of mingled surprise, disbelief, terror, and indignation.
“I had done all that I could, which was nothing, and rising to my feet,
I saw for the first time that Lucy had joined me. She was standing
perfectly motionless. Her knitting was still in her hands, but the light
had gone from her face, and she looked old—old and gray—beside the
glowing youth of her lover. For a moment her eyes held me while she
spoke as quietly as she had spoken to the soldiers on the terrace.
“‘I had to do it,’ she said. ‘I would do it again.’”
Suddenly, like the cessation of running water, or of wind in the
tree-tops, the doctor’s voice ceased. For a long pause we stared in
silence at the sunset; then, without looking at me, he added slowly:
“Three weeks later Lee surrendered and the Confederacy was over.”
* * * * *
The sun had slipped, as if by magic, behind the tops of the cedars, and
dusk fell quickly, like a heavy shadow, over the terrace. In the dimness
a piercing sweetness floated up from the garden of herbs, and it seemed
to me that in a minute the twilight was saturated with fragrance. Then I
heard the cry of a solitary whippoorwill in the graveyard, and it
sounded so near that I started.
“So she died of the futility, and her unhappy ghost haunts the house?”
“No, she is not dead. It is not her ghost; it is the memory of her act
that has haunted the house. Lucy Dare is still living. I saw her a few
months ago.”
“You saw her? You spoke to her after all these years?”
He had refilled his pipe, and the smell of it gave me a comfortable
assurance that I was living here, now, in the present. A moment ago I
had shivered as if the hand of the past, reaching from the open door at
my back, had touched my shoulder.
“I was in Richmond. My friend Beverly, an old classmate, had asked me up
for a week-end, and on Saturday afternoon, before motoring into the
country for supper, we started out to make a few calls which had been
left over from the morning. For a doctor, a busy doctor, he had always
seemed to me to possess unlimited leisure, so I was not surprised when a
single visit sometimes stretched over twenty-five minutes. We had
stopped several times, and I confess that I was getting a little
impatient when he remarked abruptly while he turned his car into a shady
street,
“‘There is only one more. If you don’t mind, I’d like you to see her.
She is a friend of yours, I believe.’
“Before us, as the car stopped, I saw a red-brick house, very large,
with green shutters, and over the wide door, which stood open, a sign
reading ‘St. Luke’s Church Home.’ Several old ladies sat, half asleep,
on the long veranda; a clergyman, with a prayer-book in his hand, was
just leaving; a few pots of red geraniums stood on little green-wicker
stands; and from the hall, through which floated the smell of freshly
baked bread, there came the music of a victrola—sacred music, I
remember. Not one of these details escaped me. It was as if every
trivial impression was stamped indelibly in my memory by the shock of
the next instant.
“In the centre of the large, smoothly shaven lawn an old woman was
sitting on a wooden bench under an ailantus-tree which was in blossom.
As we approached her, I saw that her figure was shapeless, and that her
eyes, of a faded blue, had the vacant and listless expression of the old
who have ceased to think, who have ceased even to wonder or regret. So
unlike was she to anything I had ever imagined Lucy Dare could become,
that not until my friend called her name and she glanced up from the
muffler she was knitting—the omnipresent dun-coloured muffler for the
war relief associations—not until then did I recognize her.
“‘I have brought an old friend to see you, Miss Lucy.’
“She looked up, smiled slightly, and after greeting me pleasantly,
relapsed into silence. I remembered that the Lucy Dare I had known was
never much of a talker.
“Dropping on the bench at her side, my friend began asking her about her
sciatica, and, to my surprise, she became almost animated. Yes, the pain
in her hip was better—far better than it had been for weeks. The new
medicine had done her a great deal of good; but her fingers were getting
rheumatic. She found trouble holding her needles. She couldn’t knit as
fast as she used to.
“Unfolding the end of the muffler, she held it out to us. ‘I have
managed to do twenty of these since Christmas. I’ve promised fifty to
the War Relief Association by autumn, and if my fingers don’t get stiff
I can easily do them.’
“The sunshine falling through the ailantus-tree powdered with dusty gold
her shapeless, relaxed figure and the dun-coloured wool of the muffler.
While she talked her fingers flew with the click of the needles—older
fingers than they had been at Dare’s Gift, heavier, stiffer, a little
knotted in the joints. As I watched her the old familiar sense of
strangeness, of encompassing and hostile mystery, stole over me.
“When we rose to go she looked up, and, without pausing for an instant
in her knitting, said, gravely, ‘It gives me something to do, this work
for the Allies. It helps to pass the time, and in an Old Ladies’ Home
one has so much time on one’s hands.’
“Then, as we parted from her, she dropped her eyes again to her needles.
Looking back at the gate, I saw that she still sat there in the faint
sunshine knitting—knitting—”
“And you think she has forgotten?”
He hesitated, as if gathering his thoughts. “I was with her when she
came back from the shock—from the illness that followed—and she had
forgotten. Yes, she has forgotten, but the house has remembered.”
Pushing back his chair, he rose unsteadily on his crutch, and stood
staring across the twilight which was spangled with fireflies. While I
waited I heard again the loud cry of the whippoorwill.
“Well, what could one expect?” he asked, presently. “She had drained the
whole of experience in an instant, and there was left to her only the
empty and withered husks of the hours. She had felt too much ever to
feel again. After all,” he added slowly, “it is the high moments that
make a life, and the flat ones that fill the years.”