Paris, April 12, 1787.
My Dear Hamilton:
It is an age since I heard from you. Of you I hear by some of our
friends, and in the newspapers. But although I have a right to
complain, I want to let you know the proceedings of our Assembly,
which, as it is unusual in France, may raise your curiosity.
Our Constitution is pretty much what it was in England before it had
been fairly written down and minutely preserved; so that we have great
claims to freedom, to a National Representation, to the denial of
taxes, &c., &c. But disposition on one hand, and levity on the other
have manœuvred us out of almost every privilege. They will still
subsist, however, more or less, in some provinces, and particularly in
those of Bretagne.
Now that the follies of Courts had obliged Government to saddle us with
new taxes, and the opposition of our magistrates did present itself
as an obstacle to the ministers, they have thought proper to call an
Assembly of Notables, chosen by the king, but taken among the first
people in _each_ order, and to begin with granting them what is more
wished for by the nation, an Assembly in each Province.
The last Assembly of Notables, in 1626, had been obedient to the
ministers. This one came at a more enlightened period. It happened
under a minister, who, although he has parts, is not equal to some of
the members--men of fine abilities. We are backed by the nation, and
although not her representatives, have behaved as her interpreters, and
we have formed a great majority in favor of popular measures.
The speeches from the throne, those of M. de Calonne, have been
printed: the last one contains many falsehoods. The first measure
we took was for the clergy to declare they were ready to pay in the
same proportion with other people, for the Noblesse to make the same
declaration, and reject a pecuniary privilege that was offered, in lieu
of the other that is taken off.
We have gratefully accepted the provincial elective assemblies, but
have united on such alterations as will invigorate them. M. de Calonne
had made a mixture of democracy and despotism which did annihilate
those checks and gradations that are necessary evils, wherever there is
a king. But I think the provincial assemblies, as they are proposed by
us, may lay a foundation for a good building.
Several plans for the removal of internal Custom offices, for the
free exportation of corn, for the change in the salt tax, for the
annihilation of some duties, and now for the disposal of the king’s
domanial possessions, have been examined, and underwent several
alterations. To some we have only left the titles of the chapters, but
changed them, in my opinion, much for the better.
The idea of a general tax in kind, was proposed by the government,
but we said it was not practicable. As to any new imposition, we have
answered, it is impossible to form an opinion before we know the return
of the exports of the two last years, and the plans of economy that
are intended. We have not, it is true, any powers from the nation,
but our opinion is asked, and in a measure has become necessary, and
a majority of us do not think their opinion can be given, until those
preliminaries are fulfilled.
There is a very interesting contrast between the king’s power at
Versailles, and the opposition of that Assembly which is held there,
and divided in seven committees of twenty, or twenty-two each, presided
by a prince of the blood. Hitherto we have not voted in a General
Assembly, although we had some to hear the Minister. But the opinions
of the committees only are now taken, and in the end each vote will be
pronounced in the whole house, beginning from the last up to the first
in rank. You know that we have the Clergy, Magistracy, Noblesse, and
Tiers Etat.
At the last meeting we had before the recess of these holidays, I had
a personal battle of some importance. The king’s domanial property has
been a pretence to lavish money on the princes of the blood, favorites,
and the powerful people of the country. I had the day before moved for
an examination of those bargains, wherein more than fifty millions have
been thrown away. The great people being afraid of being found out,
and particularly M. de Calonne, who is guilty of the most indecent
depredation, thought they must intimidate me and the Bishop of Langres,
M. de la Luzerne’s brother, who had seconded my motion. They, in
consequence of it, persuaded the king to have us told by his brother,
our president, that such motions ought to be signed. Upon which, we
signed the inclosed paper; and the bishop said, that after the rents,
he would bring in some accounts, signed by him, of the bargain of
sinecure, made by M. de Calonne. The king was very angry with me; M.
de Calonne, who had his confidence, intended signal revenge. I was
preparing to support what I had said, when we suddenly heard that M. de
Calonne had been dismissed. The keeper of the seal was also sent off.
I am glad we got rid of M. de Calonne; and with his successor, who,
unfortunately, is an old broken man, may improve the opportunity of
this Assembly, and let us make useful arrangements.
Adieu, my dear Hamilton; my best respects wait on Mrs. Hamilton.
Remember me to Gen. Knox, Wadsworth--all our friends, and particularly
the good doctor.
Most affectionately yours,
La Fayette.
P. S. Don’t tell the French Chargé d’Affairs that you have this paper
from me, except that there is nothing in it, for topics have spread
every _where_.