“Why, I’m in no position as yet to give definite orders, Jackman. The

decisions must be yours; I decline any responsibility. But this I will

suggest: disarm your men, lock up the guns, and give me the keys to the

gunroom and the cellars where you keep the gelignite. Send all the men

down to the New House except Tompkins and Royall. Light a beacon, or

send up flares, and put Carnglass in communication with the mainland

through ordinary channels. Leave me in charge of the Old House. Then

wait the turn of events. If you do this, I’ll put in my good word for

you with my superiors.”

This was spreading it perilously thick, Logan thought, but one might as

well be taken for a tiger as for an alley-cat.

Jackman sucked in his breath. “You ask too much, Logan, whoever

or whatever you are. Is this some plan to make Royall and me the

scapegoats? To hand us over to the police or intelligence, possibly, by

way of covering some one else’s blunders? I’ve been treated that way

before, Logan, and I’ll not endure it again. Sooner than that--sooner

than the gaol or the gallows--I’d walk into the cellars and detonate

the gelignite. I’d rather blow Carnglass into pebbles than be the dupe

once more.”

“You asked for suggestions, Jackman. I told you I’d assume no

responsibilities.” Logan had not dared to hope that Jackman actually

would fall into his impromptu snare; but at least it served to bewilder

Jackman and Royall.

“And if we did disarm the men,” Royall volunteered, “who would keep

off your friends outside? The ones that made away with Carruthers,

and sent Rab mad? What’s your scheme, Logan--to liquidate all of us

in Carnglass? To send us to join Gare and Dowie and Jock Anderson

and Donley? To make sure that no one here ever has an opportunity to

furnish evidence to the government?”

Inadvertently, he might have carried the game too far, Logan saw: he

might get himself drowned for a commissar instead of a police-agent.

“Damn it,” Jackman almost shouted, the patch in the middle of his

forehead twitching, “are you really from Vlanarov? Do you have another

name?”

“I’ll tell you when there’s need for it,” was all Logan answered him.

For Jackman was losing control of himself, and it was conceivable that

he might shoot Logan where he stood.

“Now, now, Dr. Jackman,” Royall murmured, “if he _is_ from Vlanarov,

we’d best not....”

“No!” Jackman cried, his air of power returning to him. “No, you’ll

tell me soon enough. If you’re sent by that mutual-admiration circle

in the Continent, I’ll have that news out of you, and make you pay

for it. And if you’re something worse, I’ll twist that truth from you.

I know your medicine, Logan. You’re going into the Whiskey Bottle;

there’s no man who can endure that place long. You’ll talk with me, and

thank me for the chance.”

“Dr. Jackman, I really do think ...” Royall began, uneasily. But

Jackman cut him off.

“Mr. Royall, get Anderson and Caggia. We’ll put our friend Logan away

below stairs. The responsibility is mine. And while I’m at the Whiskey

Bottle, you make the rounds of the house, Royall, and make sure all the

men have ammunition enough.”

It never would do to let Jackman see any sign of weakness in him, for

the man subsisted on others’ dread, and was most merciless, Logan

guessed, when they were most piteous. Deliberately Logan gathered up

the Table-Men and set them in their casket. “I thought you had a taste

for sherry, Jackman,” he said, “but you seem to have whiskey in mind

for me.” Jackman answered nothing. Then Anderson and Ferd entered.

Anderson’s jaw was bound up in a bloody handkerchief, and the man

looked murder at Logan.

In silence, Jackman and Anderson and Ferd Caggia took Logan down the

worn stair in the thickness of the wall. They took him to the ground

floor of the old tower, where first he had met Mary MacAskival only

yesterday about this hour, though it seemed an age ago. And they shoved

him toward one corner of that great vaulted empty room. In that corner,

flush with the flagstones, a small stair twisted downward, below the

level of the rock on which the Old House stood. Anderson thrust him

forward with a curse, so that Logan staggered down the short flight,

the three men behind him.

The place below was wholly dark. Caggia carried a petrol lantern, and

he lit it and swung it round. This crypt, hollowed from the rock,

apparently contained nothing but what looked like a broken windlass in

a far corner, and what seemed to be a coil or heap of rope in a near

corner. And in the middle of the floor was a circular lid or cover of

stone, with an iron ring set into it. Caggia and Anderson commenced to

drag back this lid.

This being, perhaps, his last appearance above ground, Logan thought

he ought to improve the shining hour. “I do hope, Anderson,” he said,

“that your jaw doesn’t pain you.” Anderson responded with an obscenity.

“I am acquainted with your brother Jock in the Gallowgate,” Logan went

on. “A lively man, Jock. He kicked me in the jaw not long ago.”

“Gude for Jock,” growled Anderson. “I’ll soon gie ye anither.”

“But we caught him, Davie Anderson,” Logan continued, “and put him

where he’ll kick no more. We caught Jim Dowie and his wife Jeanie,

too, and the others. And now all the world knows of the criminals of

Carnglass.”

“Enough of that, Logan,” Jackman put in. Anderson and Ferd were

standing by the open mouth of a pit or cistern, staring attentively at

Logan. Jackman pressed the muzzle of the little pistol into Logan’s

back and urged him toward the gulf. This must be the pit, for dead

herring or dead men, described in Balmullo’s account of the Old House.

“Dr. Jackman,” Logan said in some haste, “I do trust that when,

tomorrow or the next day, you decide in despair to blow up the Old

House, yourself, and everyone round about, you will allow these two

fine fellows to join me in this well of yours. It will probably be the

safest place for some miles round. I doubt whether Anderson and Caggia

are so ready to die as you are.”

Ferd Caggia’s perpetual grin diminished. He glanced appraisingly at Dr.

Jackman. “Ferd,” said Logan, “presumably you will be brought to trial

for treason, at the least, even if you escape Dr. Jackman’s gelignite.

They tell me that you are an excellent shot. If I were you, I should

endeavor to persuade Dr. Jackman to remain a comfortable distance from

the crypt where he keeps the explosives.”

“Logan,” Jackman muttered in his ear, “do you want a bullet in your

spine?”

“By no means, Dr. Jackman. And try not to forget that there will be

people asking after me, very soon.” Would they try to throw him into

the pit that stood open right by his feet?

“Kneel down,” Jackman told him, “and you may have a glimpse of the

Whiskey Bottle. Do you know the Mamertine prison in Rome? This is very

like, Logan, but deeper.”

Caggia had tied a long cord to the lantern, which now he lowered into

the hole and swung in a circle, slowly, so as to show the interior of

the place. Kneeling reluctantly, Logan made out an immense dry depth.

The pit was shaped roughly like a bottle, narrow at the mouth and

gradually widening, and going down, down. It was irregular, however,

with bulges and depressions here and there in its sides, as if more

the work of nature than of man. From the mouth, one could not get a

clear view of the whole interior. The lantern sank lower and lower

into the abyss, and still Logan could not perceive the bottom; then

Caggia hauled it up. In this place, according to Balmullo’s history of

Carnglass, had been found the deformed skeleton that the crofters had

called the Firgower. If ever the pit had been filled with salt herring,

it must have enabled the Old House to withstand a siege of months,

supposing there was fresh water enough to drink.

Logan stood firm upon the lip of the Whiskey Bottle. Nothing but

audacity, he felt, would discourage Jackman from indulging in a new

atrocity at this moment. “Look sharp that our friend Dr. Jackman

doesn’t put you, too, down this well, Caggia,” he remarked. “It must

tell on one’s nerves to have a lunatic bent upon self-destruction for

an employer.”

“There you’ll stay, Logan, until you feel inclined to talk with us,”

Jackman said, rolling the words thickly. “If I don’t forget you. You’ll

not eat or drink until we let you out--if we do. I won’t say when we’ll

come back to inquire after you: it may be hours, or it may be days. A

man does not stay sane very long in the Whiskey Bottle. If you come out

in time, there’s no harm done. Scream when you wish to come out, and

perhaps we will hear you. Better men than you have gone down and not

come up alive. Down with you, now.”

Anderson had dragged from the corner a long rope ladder. He made it

fast to two iron rings sunk in the floor of the crypt, and let the rope

fall into the pit. “There you go,” said Jackman. “Goodnight to you, Mr.

Logan.”

“I think I’ll not go,” Logan told them. They scarcely could carry him

down the swaying rope ladder.

“In that event,” Jackman remarked--and Anderson sniggered--“we would

have to pitch you in, and it’s nearly fifty feet to the bottom, so you

would be broken. Or we would have to lower you in at a rope’s end, head

first, with risk to your skull. I advise you to choose the ladder.”

There was nothing else for it. Logan set his feet and hands on the

swaying ladder, and began to descend. As he went down, the feet of the

three men disappeared from view, and presently he was in blackness.

After what seemed eternity, swinging and twisting about on the ropes,

he felt no rung-slat under his foot, and halted, twirling back and

forth like a top in space. Did they mean him to fall and break his legs

or back? “It doesn’t reach,” he called up. The echo was melancholy.

“Jump for it,” Jackman’s voice sounded ever so faintly above.

“I’ll be damned if I do,” Logan roared back.

“You’ll be damned if you don’t,” called Jackman, “for we’ll loose the

ladder at this end, and you’ll fall anyhow, and there’ll be no way

back.”

Waiting was no comfort. Logan relinquished his hold on the ladder,

expecting his end. But he fell only six or seven feet, bruising his

back on the jagged stone floor, which was quite dry. He could hear

the rustle of the ladder being hauled up. The light of the lantern

glimmered at the top of the Bottle, and a head was thrust over the

mouth of the shaft, silhouetted against the petrol glare.

“Should auld acquaintance be forgot,” Jackman said, “shriek when you

care for our company.” He laughed. Then he said something else, more

faintly; but Logan thought it was, “Once you put me here, Askival.”

There came a scraping sound from above, and the lid was dragged back

over the Bottle’s mouth, cutting off Logan from the world. He was shut

into the tomb now, as in his dream on the second night in Carnglass.

As if the stone cover had not been coffin-lid enough, an iron door had

stood ajar, Logan remembered, at the entrance to the crypt, a big key

in the lock. No doubt they would turn the key. Goodbye, Mary MacAskival.

12

In the Whiskey Bottle, it would not do to brood more than a man might

help, for that way lay despair: especially when one thought of what

might be done to Mary MacAskival, high above. So Logan busied himself,

at first, in creeping round the circumference of the Bottle’s floor,

feeling everywhere. There was nothing to feel but lumpy naked rock,

everywhere gouged by ancient chisels.

The batter of the circular sides made it impossible for him even to

think of climbing, fly-like, toward the mouth. These pleasures soon

were exhausted. His watch had not worked well since he splashed ashore

in Carnglass, and perhaps that was to the good. Already he was hungry

and thirsty; but this last must be chiefly a psychological oppression,

as the damp air of Carnglass made it unnecessary for a man to drink

much water a day.

Although he had been in the place but a quarter of an hour, probably,

the problem of fresh air began to worry Logan. It was silly to think

about it so soon, of course: the immense cubic capacity of the Bottle

would give him oxygen enough for a long time, and conceivably enough to

support life leaked beneath the rude stone at the mouth, anyway. But

one thought about such things in the Bottle, for lack of aught else to

do.

In all that dead island, the Whiskey Bottle was the deadest place. Not

even an insect could live here; and the place was so dry that, perhaps,

not even a lichen could cling to the sloping walls. One could think

only of dead things: of the deformed skeleton found on this floor, and

the presences that drifted through Jackman’s guilty brain. It wouldn’t

do for a man to think such thoughts: not for a man who meant to keep

his wits about him. If ever they let him out of the Bottle, he would

need all the wits and all the strength he could muster. The best thing

to do, then, was to sleep. Luckily, Logan was very tired from the

strain of the past several days, and from having had so little sleep

last night, what with his colloquy with Mary MacAskival. And sleep

never had come hard to him, in the worst of times and places. He groped

about the rough floor until he found a tolerable area upon which to

stretch himself, and there he lay down, his head on his arm, and soon

drifted off. Dreams came, hideous dreams; but afterward they were all a

blur to him. Now and then he tossed and woke imperfectly; then, like a

sick man, he sank back into the sanctuary of the unconscious.

How many hours later it was that a noise woke him, he could not say.

What could make a noise in the Bottle? Nothing living. It was a faint

dragging noise. Then high overhead, he could perceive the faintest

half-moon of light. Someone was dragging back the stone lid of the

Bottle, slowly.

Would Jackman and Royall pull him out and put him to more direct

torture? If they had tormented the truth about him out of Mary

MacAskival, the odds were that they would put him into the sea, as a

man who knew too much of them, and whose death might be explained with

tolerable ease. It might be easier for him to refuse to come up, and

hope that aid might come from the mainland in time. They could descend,

of course, and tie him, and haul him to the top; but that would mean a

fight. If they shot him, that would be evidence of foul play, supposing

his body ever were washed up.

Now something scraped and rustled, and barely brushed the top of his

head: it must be the rope ladder. Reaching up, he grasped the thin

strip of wood that was the bottom rung. Still Jackman, if he were

above, said nothing. But a light probed downward toward Logan; someone

up there held an electric torch. He had might as well take this

dubious chance. Although it had been long since Logan had gone in for

gymnastics, he had strong arms, and so contrived to pull his chin up to

the level of the bottom rung, get a fresh grip, and bring up his legs.

And then he commenced the swaying climb toward the Bottle’s mouth.

As he neared the top, the torch dazzled him. Then a hand caught his,

helping him over the edge to the floor of the crypt. No sooner had

Logan got to his feet than a pair of arms was flung around his neck,

and a small body hung for a moment upon his, in fright and delight.

“They’ve broken no bone of you, Hugh?” said Mary MacAskival. Before he

could reply, she kissed him, and then flashed the electric torch the

length of his body, as if to be sure he were all there. “Don’t speak

above a wee whisper,” she murmured in his ear, “and come over here, for

we must be off.” Taking his hand, she led him through the dark toward a

corner of the crypt.

“One glimpse of you, anyway,” said Hugh. Taking the torch, he sent the

beam over and behind her. She was barefoot, but with a pair of little

walking-shoes slung round her neck. On her back she had Logan’s own

rucksack, looking as if it were crammed with things. Her back was to

what seemed to be the low circular coping of a well, with a derelict

windlass above it.

“We daren’t talk now,” the girl said, “for we’ll have but a quarter

of an hour, at best, before Niven gives the alarm. He’s sentry at the

garden door on the floor above. I told him I was taking you food and

water, which you’re not supposed to have, and he let me pass, for he

knows I am a red-haired witch. Jackman will thrash the poor fellow

within an inch of his life when he finds we’re gone. Niven never

thought I could get out with you, of course. If he’d known that, even I

couldn’t have seduced him.”

“Seduced him?”

She chuckled. “Oh, don’t be silly. Has Dr. Jackman been telling you

more lies about me? I mean, subverted his loyalty to Jackman. I gave

Niven five pounds and nearly a full bottle of rum. All right now, Hugh:

take off your trousers.”

He was bemused. “Whatever for?”

“Why, silly, we’re going down the cistern, and there’s water in it, and

you might catch your death of cold outside, with wet trousers. I think

you may keep your shirt on; we sha’n’t go so deep, I hope. Here, take

the pack, and carry it, and stuff your trousers in it. I can kilt up my

skirt once we’re at the level of the water, but you could hardly slip

off your trousers in the middle of the shaft. You’d best take off your

shoes and stockings, and sling them round your neck, the way I have,

too. You needn’t be shy: I’ll go down first, and I’ll point the torch

the other way.”

Logan stared into the cistern. In the beam of the torch, he could see

rusted iron rungs set into the masonry, leading downward; but they

ended in still water. “If we’re to drown, Mary,” he said, “it had might

as well be in the sea.”

“What with the gutters of the tower being half clogged,” she went on,

“the water level down there is very low nowadays--twelve or fifteen

feet, at best--and I feared they might find the arch, but they haven’t.

It’s perfectly feasible: Malcolm Mor and I did it four years ago,

like a bomb. Why, it’s a lark, Hugh; come along. The last one down

is an old maid.” Hiking her skirt halfway up her white thighs, Mary

MacAskival stepped over the well-coping, swung round, and began to

descend the slimy iron rungs. “I locked the crypt door on the inside,

for I have keys, you know,” she whispered up, “but Niven may be

pounding on it any second, so be quick with you.”

There was nothing for it but to obey this madcap. Down Logan went into

the cistern; he hoped the old rungs would hold. Once his foot caught

the girl’s fingers, and she suppressed a cry. He heard a faint splash

of water below, and turned the torch downward, looking between his

bare legs. Mary MacAskival, her skirt held up almost to her shoulders,

was more than waist-high in the black water. “There is nothing in the

world,” she volunteered, “quite like a cold tub. Now do as I do, and

mind your head, for from floor to ceiling is scarcely more than four

feet.” She vanished.

Dismayed, Hugh Logan descended to his waist in the cold water. Then,

on his left, he saw the arch of which Mary had spoken: a round-headed

masonry arch, very old. The cistern water came to within two feet of

the crown of it. Gingerly, Logan stretched out a leg, found the floor

of a passage under the arch, gripped Mary’s outstretched hand thrust

back from the passage, and swung himself from the iron rungs to a low

tunnel nearly filled with water; he had to stoop so that his face

cleared the surface by only a few inches, and his little pack, strapped

to his back, scraped against the roof.

Squeezing his hand, Mary MacAskival pulled him along the black passage,

the torch-beam gleaming on the water. She had her skirt twisted round

her neck. “One thing’s certain,” she panted, “they’ll not hear us here.

In the old days, this place was flooded altogether, except when The

MacAskival let water out of the cistern so that men could enter the

passage. Malcolm Mor--he was the old gardener, remember?--told me

that his father’s father’s father’s uncle knew of this place, though

no living man had seen it for a hundred years and more. Malcolm and I

found it out together. We had grand larks.”

After six yards or so, the floor began to slope upward, fairly sharply;

and after a dozen yards, they were free of the water. “No trousers

for you yet, modest Hugh,” Mary said, though she had let her skirt

fall into place. “There is water still to come.” A moment later, they

entered a small square rock chamber, beyond which loomed another narrow

passage. “The Picts made this, as they made the Whiskey Bottle, Hugh.

Look there.” She pointed the torch toward one wall, and by it Hugh

made out a faint band of carving on the wall: little hooded and caped

figures, faceless, some riding on queer little ponies. “This was a

chapel, I think, or a tomb; but we haven’t a moment to spare just now.”

She led the way into the further passage, the floor of which sloped

downward again. “We’re far beyond the Old House now, Hugh.”

The passage shot abruptly downward, and then ended in a solid barrier

of living rock. Did the girl mean them to crouch here indefinitely, on

the chance that help might come from the mainland before they starved?

“I think the Picts dug all this for a temple,” she was saying, “or a

king’s tomb; but the MacAskivals used it as a sortie-port in time of

siege, or a way of escape if worst came to worst. Oh, I’m not strong

enough. Tug at it, Hugh!” She was kneeling on the rough floor. Handing

the torch back to her, Hugh Logan felt under his hands a thick stone

slab, roughly rectangular. He tugged. It could be slid to one side, far

enough to allow them to squeeze through to whatever lay beneath. And

beneath was more water. But this water splashed and sucked, and the

strong stench of seaweed came up from it; and from beyond came the roar

of the wild Carnglass tide.

“We’re to go into that, Mary?” But Mary MacAskival already had swung

her handsome bare legs through the gap. The water just below snarled

and surged in the cave, as if full of murderous desire. “It’s past

midnight, Hugh, and the tide has ebbed.” She jumped down.

After all, Logan found when he followed her, the water came only

to their knees. At high tide, the passage would be impossible. He

scratched a foot on some sharp submerged stone. Roof and floor of the

cave now angled downward, and the water deepened; but by the time they

reached the entrance, it was no higher than their waists. “In the old

days,” Mary said, “little coracles came into this at low tide. There

is another cave like this on the northern shore, but larger, and far

harder to reach from the land.” She plucked a bit of seaweed from a

rock. “This is the carrageen. In a better time, I will make you a

pudding of it.” Then she ducked through the low mouth of the cave, Hugh

Logan behind her, and they were in the night, by the ocean, a cliff at

their backs, a splendid moon overhead.

For the first time in many days, the mist and drizzle had lifted from

Carnglass altogether; and for these islands, the sea was calm. But the

clear beauty of the night was small comfort to these two fugitives:

Jackman and his gang might hunt them down by that round moon. Mary

splashed through a rock pool toward the relatively low cliff of gray

stone that met the ocean at this point. “I think, Hugh, that by this

time they will have searched the Old House for us, and Jackman will

know we have got out. But they will not know the way that we have gone,

and perhaps Jackman cannot make the men follow him out of the house

this night, for they are afraid of every shadow now. Here we’re too

close to the Old House for safety. We’ll pass between Cailleach and the

sea-cliffs, and so up to St. Merin’s Chapel; that’s best.” When the two

of them had got to the foot of a faint path that seemed to wind up the

cliff, Mary put on shoes and stockings. “Now, Mr. Barrister Logan, you

pillar of respectability, you may wear trousers again.”

They climbed; they scrambled; they trotted; when they could, they

ran. From the cliffs they descended into the glen that twisted

round the hill of Cailleach, and hurried through heaps of stones

along a forgotten trail; here, once, had been a village, and Duncan

MacAskival’s people had lived under the thatch of one of these ruins.

The girl was agile as a deer; it was all Logan could do to keep up with

her, for his rucksack was curiously heavy. The moonlight helped them

to make speed, but also it would leave them naked unto their enemies,

should Jackman and the rest come this way. For more than an hour they

hurried, until they had crossed a valley and saw before them the steep

way up to the highest point of Carnglass, the headland on which stood

St. Merin’s Chapel, with the graveyard round it. Then Mary flung

herself exhausted on the heather, and Logan sank down panting beside

her. Two or three strange white shapes scurried away from them; Logan

started. “Are those things deer or goats?”

The tired girl laughed at him. “Carnglass sheep, like no other sheep

on earth. Long legs and long necks, and great leapers, and altogether

wild.” Everything in this forgotten island, it seemed, defied the tooth

of time.

But it was no hour for philosophical observations. So soon as they had

got a little strength back, they must be away to the top of the island.

And what they could hope for there, aside from a brief respite, was

more than Logan could see. Unarmed, they would be much easier game

than Donley had been. Jackman and the rest would have their blood

up. This girl, it might be, had destroyed herself by trying to save

him. “Here, Hugh,” Mary said, “you’ll want this.” She took from the

rucksack a paper in which were wrapped some scraps of meat, two boiled

potatoes, and a piece of bread, all this salvaged furtively from Lady

MacAskival’s dinner-tray. Logan, indeed, was ravenous, and he ate the

lot, Mary insisting that she had got down a late supper. As he ate, she

told him what had passed since he went down the Whiskey Bottle.

When Jackman and Royall had taken Logan to the study at gun-point, Mary

MacAskival had run to her room and locked herself in. It was only much

later in the day, when Jackman and most of the men were searching for

Carruthers, that she had bullied out of Niven the fact that Logan was

shut in the Whiskey Bottle. In her room, she had taken out of a chest

the only weapon she had, the ancient dirk that was said to have been

Askival’s, and had sat with it in her lap, expecting all the time to

have Jackman and Royall turn upon her next. But Jackman had only tried

her door; and, not being able to enter, had called out that he would

deal with her later. And then he had gone out to comb the island for

Carruthers, whom they did not find; nor did they find anyone else. The

men returned after sunset, Jackman and Royall going back to the study,

where they sat talking for hours. The girl had crept to the study door

and had caught fragments of their argument.

No, they had not found Carruthers; but they had turned up something

else. When Donley’s body was searched in the cellar, one of the men

discovered in a pocket a water-soaked note. It was nearly illegible;

but they could make out Logan’s signature, and that it was addressed to

the police. On this evidence, Jackman and Royall abandoned their notion

that Logan was an agent of Vlanarov; they now took him for a detective.

The question remained as to what they ought to do with the man in the

Whiskey Bottle. Royall thought it best to hold him there until they

could get some boat, and then to run for it, abandoning their whole

project. But Jackman was for death: Logan knew too much, and must go

over the cliff. The two exhausted fanatics still were debating when the

girl slipped away, but she believed they would dispose of Logan in the

morning, if not sooner.

So she took Logan’s pack, with what food she could get her hands upon,

and a pint bottle of paraffin, and Askival’s dirk; and she bullied

and wheedled Niven, on guard in the old tower; and to her immense

satisfaction, she had got Logan clean away. Jackman and his people had

no notion of the existence of that passage out of the cistern; Lady

MacAskival herself had not known of it. When she ran, Mary knew that

she left her aunt in danger, but Jackman’s fanatic voice behind the

study door convinced her she dared not delay; Jackman would act before

his time ran out altogether. And here she was, lying beside Hugh Logan

on the heather.

Behind them hulked the northern heights where St. Merin’s Chapel stood.

They could hear a little waterfall tumbling, in that still night, from

the cliff-tops. The burn ran through the heather and bracken close

by them, lower down joining a stream that entered the sea by Askival

harbor. Now they must climb to their last forlorn refuge. First they

drank from the peaty burn; then Logan shouldered the rucksack, and up

they started. They hardly spoke in the course of that hard nocturnal

climb.

From the summit, nearly an hour later, most of Carnglass was dimly

visible to them in the moonlight. They could make out specks of light

away to the southwest: lamps burning in the Old House. “Hugh,” Mary

said, laying a hand on his arm, “Carnglass is the oldest place in the

world, and the loveliest. Do you hate it? You’ve seen only fright and

death here. But it was Dr. Jackman that brought the terror. If--if we

live, Hugh, I’ll show you Carnglass as you ought to see it. Can you

forgive me for having drawn you into this terror?”

“One crowded hour of glorious life,” Logan told her, “really is worth

an age without a name. And if I’d not come, I’d never have met Miss

Mary MacAskival, would I?”

“No,” she said, with a little sob, “no. But we can’t loiter here.” She

took Askival’s dirk from the rucksack. “Hugh, take this, and cut some

branches off the trees around the chapel, as quickly as you can; and

I’ll scrape together some dead sticks and bits of dry heather; I made

a little pile of them here weeks ago, on the chance that I might need

to light them one day. We can burn the rucksack, too, and my jacket.

They’ll make no grand beacon, but we can do no more. The paraffin I

brought will start them blazing.”

Logan stared at her. “Who’d see the fire, except Jackman’s boys?”

“There’s a chance, Hugh. The night is clear. Besides, what other scheme

is there? And my people will come. They may not come soon enough, but

they will come.”

“Your people?” The girl must be sunk in a Carnglass fantasy.

“Hurry, Hugh,” was all she said. “It won’t be long before dawn.”

They built their poor futile beacon, with what fuel they had on that

hilltop, and they poured the paraffin upon it, and they set it alight

with one of Logan’s matches, and they added to it the rucksack and

Mary’s tweed jacket and Hugh’s coat. It flared somewhat better than

Hugh had expected. But what possibility existed of this being seen by

any vessel passing in the night, or of being acted upon? And it was

almost certain that it would guide Jackman.

“We’re only targets here,” Logan said. “At the chapel, we’d have some

shelter.” They climbed still higher on that cliff-plateau, until

they came to a low drystone dyke. Beyond it were tombstones, white

in the moonlight. This was Carnglass graveyard; and in the middle

of the graveyard stood a long, low medieval building, St. Merin’s

Chapel, battered by five centuries. Away to their right, a tall ruin,

infinitely older than the chapel, round, nearly forty feet high,

windowless and roofless, loomed at the brink of the cliff.

On its rough stones flickered the light of their little impromptu

beacon. “They call that the Pict’s House,” said Mary, “or sometimes

the Firgower’s House.” The tower’s circular wall slanted slightly

inward, all round, for some twenty feet of its height; then it shot

perpendicularly to its summit. It was what was called a broch, a strong

place, Pictish work beyond question. “I do not think that really

the Pictish chief lived here,” Mary went on, “for that room and the

passages under the Old House have the look of his palace. The Picts

lived underground, you know. This was a watchtower, and a place of

refuge.”

She turned toward the chapel. The firelight was reflected, between them

and the medieval building, upon a great Celtic cross, perhaps fifteen

feet high, carved with grotesques and convoluted interlacing bands;

and it leant heavily to one side. This was the Cross of Carnglass,

set up by the missionaries of St. Columba in the dim Irish age, St.

Merin’s Cross. Mary led Logan toward it; and, as they came close up,

she pulled from one of the stunted rowan trees which brooded over that

windswept graveyard a little twig, on which the first leaves of spring

had opened. She thrust it into the topmost buttonhole of Logan’s shirt.

“The rowan keeps off wraiths and evil spirits, Hugh,” she said, “and

St. Merin’s kirkyard is famous for them. Niven thinks I am the chief of

them. Look at me: am I a witch?”

Mary MacAskival stood before the Cross of Carnglass, her red hair

brushing the white stone, her haughty nose and firm chin marking her as

the last of an old, old, fierce line: perhaps, truly, the descendant

of the Merin whose bones lay beneath one of these grass-grown grave

mounds. “If anyone could call spirits from the vasty deep, you could,

Mary,” Hugh told her.

She smiled queerly. “It may be I will do just that, Hugh Logan.

But here, I’ll show you the chapel.” She took him through a Gothic

doorway--the wooden door, ajar, sagged on its hinges--and flashed

the torch-beam over the tombs within. A grotesque stone face, rudely

carved, stared at them from a niche. Directly before them stood up an

ornate modern tomb of marble. “Sir Alastair is beneath that. And here’s

his postbox.” She pointed to a slot in the marble, surrounded by a

carved funerary wreath; and she slid her hand into the opening. “Oh,

there’s nothing within now!” she said, as if really disappointed. “For

years, you know, my aunt used to send letters by the butler or footman

to Sir Alastair in his tomb. And I used to post my letters here, too,

when I wasn’t watched.”

Post her letters there! Mary must have read the amazement on his face,

for she added, as if to reassure him of her sanity, “Oh, yes. The

letter I sent Duncan MacAskival, that brought you here, was posted

here in Sir Alastair’s postbox.” Was this some macabre witticism of

the uncanny little beauty, or a delusion grown out of dreams and

isolation? “But we daren’t linger here, Hugh. If Dr. Jackman sees our

fire, he’ll come up the cliff straight away.” She pointed to the old

dirk, which Hugh Logan had thrust into his belt. “That was Askival’s.

You must be my Askival, Hugh. I am Merin, you know: Merin of Carnglass,

who’s haunted this place since time began.” She was half playful, half

in earnest. The dirk, Logan thought, might be small use against the

guns of Jackman’s men, but it was some comfort. Then he followed Mary

MacAskival out of the silent chapel, and toward the towering broch by

the precipice. Their fire still leaped against the night sky of lonely

Carnglass, but in a few minutes only embers would remain.

“The Pict’s House,” Mary was saying, “is the best place we can hide.

By the sea, away below these cliffs, is a great cave; but even I could

not lead you down the path to it in darkness; and besides, the tide is

coming in now, and the cave will be full almost to the top. It must be

the Pict’s House for us. One still can climb the stair to the top of

it.” She was quite calm, as if, having done all that she could do, she

abandoned herself to fate and fortune. “And from the Pict’s House, we

can see nearly all of Carnglass, once the sun is up.”

They entered the tower through a square doorway ten feet above the

ground; a worn timber, sea-drift, propped against the wall just below

the door, made this scramble possible. The doorway was capped, by way

of lintel, by a great stone slab; the Picts had not known the arch.

Empty and roofless, the round interior cavern of the broch was before

them, but Mary turned into the wall itself: a circling stair led

upward, its steps vast rude slabs. By it they came to the crumbling

summit of the broch, and Logan observed, while they climbed, that no

mortar lay between the cunningly-placed stones of the tower; this was

the work of men in the dawn of history, and beside it the Old House

across the island was a thing of yesterday.

Round the top of the broch ran a stone platform. “Stoop down behind

the parapet, Hugh,” the girl told him, “so Jackman won’t see us, if he

comes this way.” The earliest hint of a spring dawn glimmered in the

east; a corncrake fluttered up from the parapet. Right below them, the

tremendous cliffs, the cliffs over which Lagg had gone, fell sheer away

to the ocean. From this point, the last Pict chieftain may have watched

the long ships of the Vikings as they swept inexorably out of the

sea-mist to the north. On that sea, nothing was visible this morning

but whitecaps breaking on a submerged reef.

“No, there’s nothing, no sail,” Mary MacAskival said anxiously, almost

as if she had expected one. “Do you know the tale of the fairy boat,

Hugh, that sails through the mists? If a girl glimpses it, she vanishes

before nightfall. I wish one could carry me off--and you. Now you see

my Carnglass, Hugh Logan.”

He looked landward. Far to the west-southwest, beyond Cailleach, the

Old House stood grim on its rock; lower down, the New House, among its

plantations. Between them and the Old House stretched glen and hill,

heather and bracken, boulder and peat-bog, waterfall and burn. On this

lovely morning, the mists were quite gone, and there was revealed

to him the unearthly beauty of the forgotten island. The girl took

his arm. “Hugh, were it yours, would you live here always--or almost

always?”

“That I would, Mary MacAskival.” Carnglass, for good or evil, set its

mark on men.

She faced him squarely, putting her hands on his shoulders. “We may be

under that sea tonight, Hugh Logan. But if we are not, why shouldn’t

Carnglass be yours? I’ve known you but thirty-six hours, Hugh. You’re

all the man I need to know. Do you fear me? Some men do, though I’m so

little.” She kissed him then, and said, “Hugh Logan, I have kissed you

more times than I have kissed all other men in all my life. Do you mean

to ask me to marry you?”

Torn between love and doubt, in that high place, Logan looked long

into her green eyes. “They would say, Mary, that I took advantage of a

lonely girl who had barely met me, for the sake of her money.”

She tossed her bright hair at that. “Don’t be so canny, Hugh! Do you

know the MacAskival motto, over the door of the old tower? ‘They have

said and they will say; let them be saying.’ The MacAskivals, man or

woman, have no concern for what they say in Glasgow or Edinburgh or

London or all the wide world.” Then a look of fright came into her

flashing eyes. “Is it that you are married already, Hugh?”

“No,” he said, “but I will be, if we get alive out of this.” And as the

sun rose, he took her in his arms. Rash, proud, and strange that girl

was, perhaps a little mad; but in that moment he loved her more than

all the kingdoms of the earth.

She clung to him, sobbing and laughing softly in her moment of triumph

and surrender. But abruptly he thrust her back, and pulled her below

the level of the parapet. “Mary, Mary! They’ve come!” For three armed

men were climbing the slope toward the chapel, and Jackman was the

first of them. Logan thought that they two had not been seen. No shots

were fired, at least.

His arm around the girl’s waist, he ventured a second glance between

two heavy stones that teetered precariously on the parapet’s brink.

Yes, Jackman and Anderson and Powert. The men got over a low wall that

ran round the graveyard, close by the remnants of the burned-out futile

beacon. Then they entered the chapel.

“Mary, girl,” he whispered, “they’ll be on us in three or four minutes,

I think.” She did not cry, but kissed him once more, and then composed

her young face, as if the MacAskival ought to meet enemies without

flinching.

“Hugh,” she said, “every second we can delay may help us.” He did not

see why, but she gave him no time to dissent. “Back down the stair,

Hugh, and if they try to come in, we’ll cast down the timber by the

door.” Yes, they could do that, though without guns they could do no

more than delay Jackman briefly. Back down the stair they went, and

crouched by the empty archaic doorway. It wouldn’t do to push away the

timber-gangplank that led up from the ground unless they must, for the

noise of its fall would bring Jackman and his men.

Now they heard Jackman’s voice; he was coming right round the broch

from the chapel. Anderson’s sullen Gallowgate mutter replied to

Jackman. And in a moment the hunters stood just below the broch’s door,

though Logan dared not look out. “All right, Powert,” Jackman said,

“up with you.” At that, Logan and Mary MacAskival shoved against

the timber with all their strength. It slid sideways and fell to the

ground. They showed themselves for an instant as they pushed, and

someone fired, but the bullet passed over their heads into the broch.

“Ah, well,” came Jackman’s voice from below, “you _did_ lead us a

chase, didn’t you? Anderson, Powert, take hold there.” The timber was

heaved back into place; Logan could not risk rising again to push it

off, for Jackman would have a gun trained on the doorway. “Powert, Mr.

Logan is not armed,” said Jackman. “Quick, now!” A man sprang up the

timber and through the door.

Thrusting at him with the dirk, Logan got home to Powert’s upper arm,

and the man cried out and grappled with him. Before he could slash

Powert again, Jackman was up, and poked the little pistol Meg right

into Logan’s face. “Gallant, Logan, very gallant; but drop that.” Logan

flung down the dirk. Mary MacAskival was struggling in Anderson’s arms.

“A pleasant morning, eh, Logan?” Jackman said. “You’ll not see another.”

13

They took Hugh Logan and Mary MacAskival out of the Pict’s House.

Anderson tied Logan’s wrists together, behind his back, with a length

of heavy cord, pulling the knots savagely tight. Jackman held the

girl by the arm meanwhile; and when Anderson had finished with Logan,

under Jackman’s instructions he tied a cord to Mary’s right wrist, and

retained the other end of the cord in his hand while Jackman removed

Powert’s jacket and bandaged the flesh-wound with a strip torn from the

tail of Powert’s shirt. This done, Jackman had Anderson tie the other

end of Mary’s cord to Jackman’s own left wrist.

“There!” Jackman said, contentedly, “a brisk morning’s run, and no harm

done. Anderson, Powert and I will take this charming couple to the Old

House while you trot down the brae and call back Ferd and Niven; I

think they should be near the sheiling this side of Cailleach.”

Anderson glowered at Logan. “Ye said I wud hae the thrashin’ o’ that

clot, Doctor.”

“That you shall, Anderson, my man, that you shall--once we’re at the

Old House. I do believe Anderson will learn all we need to know from

you, Logan, in short order. Our treatment of you, Miss MacAskival, will

need to be rather more laborious: the washing of the brain, as our

Chinese friends say. But it will all come out in the wash, won’t it?

And Powert, too, will be given his fair turn at you, Logan: fair shares

for all, eh?” Jackman ran his tongue over his thin lips. “In one thing,

at least, you seem to have told me the truth, Logan: you’ve no people

in Carnglass, for you’d not have been cowering in that ruin if there

were any. There’s Carruthers to be accounted for; but I suppose he may

have missed his footing in the dark and have gone over the cliffs. I

must confess that my estimate of your abilities has diminished, Logan.

Whatever possessed you to light that fire here by the chapel? You might

have eluded us four or five hours longer if you hadn’t done that. Well,

drive him along, Powert.”

With his unwounded arm, Powert gave Logan a fierce shove in the back,

setting him stumbling in the direction of the Old House; and Jackman

tugged on Mary’s cord, pulling her with him behind Logan and Powert.

The girl’s face was quite drained of color, but very haughty. “My

dear,” Jackman said to her, casually, “how changed you are going to be

within a few days! How very changed!”

Then, from somewhere below in the nearer valley, there came to them the

crack of a rifle-shot. It was answered by another, apparently from a

different gun. Next was a burst of firing, and then a faint cry.

Jackman’s satisfied smile altered horribly; he was Rumpelstiltskin

again. “Logan,” he muttered, “is there a man of yours in Carnglass,

after all? Or is that only Niven’s or Caggia’s nerves playing them

tricks? Anderson, you and I must go down to see. Powert, we’ll leave

you with Logan; he can’t do you harm. The girl will come with me. We’ll

send back a man to help you get Logan to the Old House, Powert.”

Powert most obviously did not relish the plan. “Coom, Dr. Jackman, I’ve

a bad arm, and this cove’s a queer one.”

“Nonsense,” Jackman said, “we’ll bind his feet, too, until we send

Anderson or someone else for you.” Away below, there was only silence,

but Jackman ran his hand across his forehead uneasily. “Here: we’ll put

him inside the chapel with you, and you can watch the door, with your

back to the wall: that’s safe enough.” Powert scowled, but shoved Logan

toward the door of St. Merin’s Chapel. Jackman herded the four of them

inside.

Now that the dawn came through the broken tracery of the chapel’s

pointed windows, Logan could see that the single room contained seven

or eight tombs raised above the floor, some of them very old; and a

number of the flagstones, deeply incised by some rude stonecarver,

apparently covered other graves. “Wha’ in hell’s yon!” cried Anderson,

abruptly, pointing.

Near the northeast corner of the room, one of the flagstones had

been raised, and now was leant against the wall. Where it had lain,

a little mound of earth, freshly dug, protruded above the floor; and

in the earth was thrust a curiously primitive wooden spade. The mound

was about six feet long. They all crowded close to it. An earthenware

dish had been set atop the mound, and the dish was filled with, of all

things, nails and what looked like salt. Across the dish lay a branch

from a rowan tree. “That,” Mary MacAskival said softly to Dr. Jackman,

“is how the spirits of the newly dead are laid in these islands.”

“Wha’ fule’s been diggin’ graves?” Anderson growled, looking back over

his shoulder toward the empty doorway.

Jackman stood rigid; then, “I think Carruthers must be under that clay.

Anderson, take the spade and uncover him.” Mary MacAskival shivered

slightly.

Anderson cursed, but under Jackman’s hard eye he began to shovel. The

grave was very shallow. In a minute or two, a heavy shape could be made

out, wrapped in a big piece of tarred canvas. “That will be the head

at the far end,” Jackman whispered. “Powert, draw the canvas from the

face.”

Mary had turned away, but Logan, dreadfully fascinated, saw clearly

the smashed and fallen face of a man he never had looked upon before.

And Jackman screamed: he screamed twice, and so terribly that his men

shook, for the screams were worse than the ruined face in the grave.

“Lagg! It’s Lagg!”

Quivering, Anderson dropped the spade. “Aye,” he said, “Tam Lagg, that

we pit ower the cliff into the sea. For the love o’ God, Powert, cover

his mug.”

Powert, his teeth chattering, let the canvas drop back over the corpse.

“Logan,” shrieked Jackman, turning a frantic face on him, “Logan, what

are you? What are you? Do you make dead men rise from the sea? Was

it you that put this thing here?” He had the pistol in his hand, and

thrust it against Logan’s middle.

He will fire now, Logan thought, for he’s quite out of his head.

There was the sound of a shot. But I’m not hit, Logan realized; I

feel nothing. Jackman sprang away and looked out the doorway; the

shot, after all, had come from outside, though in his tension Logan

had thought, for an instant, that Jackman had pulled the trigger. Yet

surely a gun had gone off fairly close at hand.

“Anderson, watch this door,” Jackman ordered; he had a measure of

control over himself. “Powert, give me that rope.” He forced Logan

to sit, and tied his ankles together. “We’ll return for you in a few

minutes, Powert.”

“Me? I’ll not sit here by the dead man.” Powert scarcely could hold his

rifle.

Jackman sent him a deadly look from those glowering black eyes of his.

“You’ll be another dead man yourself, Powert, if I hear another word

from you. Now, Anderson, we’ll look into this. Miss MacAskival, if you

cry out, I’ll be forced to put a bullet through your head.” He shoved

her through the doorway.

“Hugh,” Mary called back, reckless of Jackman, “Hugh, I love you!” Then

she and Jackman and Anderson were out of sight.

Powert, left with Logan and the corpse, still shook; and he cursed

Logan and Jackman and Carnglass while he made his preparations as if

for siege. He pushed the helpless Logan roughly against Sir Alastair’s

tomb, facing away from the doorway, and parallel with the open grave

and the awful thing under the canvas. Then he pulled shut the sagging

door of the chapel, so that some force would be required to budge

it; and he himself leaned against a tombstone that came up to his

shoulders, with his face toward the door, and his rifle in his hands,

the barrel resting upon the head of another tombstone. So situated,

Powert could watch the door, keep an eye on Logan and the sheeted

thing, and have the comforting feel of stone at his back.

Logan himself, after the repeated shocks of that fair morning, was in

little better state than Powert. Silent, he lay motionless against

the tomb of Sir Alastair MacAskival, his brain dull, dull, dull.

There were no more shots outside: only the rustle of a breeze in the

rowan trees. The stillness was a trying thing. Powert was mumbling to

himself: obscenities, blasphemies, scraps of nearly-forgotten prayer.

The sunlight was pouring into the chapel through the unglazed Gothic

windows. Five or six minutes passed thus.

Then a faint sound came. Was something stirring in the high graveyard

grass, just outside the closed door? Did the door itself creak, as if

very gently tried? “Anderson,” Powert cried out, choking, “is it you,

man? Dr. Jackman?” Nothing answered. Did the door creak again, ever

so slightly, or was it the breeze? “Sing out,” Powert shouted, glaring

wild-eyed at the flimsy door, “or I’ll shoot!”

High in the wall behind Powert was one of the pointed windows, its

stone tracery for the most part broken away. It must be at least eight

feet above the level of the graveyard. Though Logan could see this

window, Powert, intent on the doorway, could not. And as something rose

cautiously above the windowsill, from outside, Logan bit his lip to

keep back a cry.

It was a man’s head that cut off the morning light: a lean man,

keen-eyed; and there was a long white beard on his chin; and there was

a little black knife between his teeth. His eyes took in the room.

Steadying himself by clutching the broken tracery with his left hand,

stealthily he rose until his shoulders came above the window-ledge. In

his brown right hand he held a large stone.

As if someone had thrust tentatively against it, the rotten door

creaked shrilly. “Damn you,” Powert was crying, “speak up, or I’ll

shoot.” The white-bearded man outside the window drew back his arm and

flung the stone with great force, as if letting fly at a rabbit. The

rock caught Powert at the back of his head; he fell to his knees, the

rifle clattering on the flagstones. At that the door burst open, and

two men tumbled into the room, and were upon Powert before he could

recover. A boy followed them, and, kneeling by Logan, looked shyly into

his face. These were the two men and the boy, MacAskivals from Daldour,

that Logan had seen in Loch Boisdale, four days before.

Then there strode through the doorway a very tall old man, erect and

vigorous and bearded to his chest, with a shotgun in his hand. He

was worth looking at; but another man, hard on his heels, was still

stranger. This was a burly, broad-shouldered fellow, with a heavy,

jolly face, and mild eyes that were exceedingly odd, though it would

have been difficult to say why. Something in the look of his face was

queer enough. Yet it was his clothing that made him conspicuous. The

other men wore the caps and canvas cloaks and rough homespun tweeds

of the crofters and fishermen in the remoter Isles. This burly man,

in strong contrast, was dressed in what seemed to be the garments

of a laird or prosperous farmer: green tweed jacket, green corduroy

breeches and long stockings, good heavy shoes. Under the open jacket

was a soiled yellow waistcoat; and on his head was a battered porkpie

hat. These clothes were in wretched repair, with dark stains here and

there upon them. The breeches, seemingly split at the seams, were

held together by pins. One sleeve of the jacket was ripped open from

shoulder to wrist. And although the clothes had been got on, they did

not fit the man who wore them.

Resting a hand on the boy’s shoulder, the tall old man bent over Logan

and spoke in Gaelic. Logan shook his head: “I know only English.”

Frowning, the old man muttered through his splendid beard to the boy

beside him.

The boy stammered a little, as if overwhelmed with shyness; but there

was no fear in him. He spoke to Logan in good, if careful, English.

“Malcolm Mor MacAskival of Daldour asks what is your name, and what do

you do in Carnglass.” The pirate-like old man looked hard at Logan.

These, then, were Mary MacAskival’s people! She had not been

woolgathering when she spoke of them. How she had summoned them, Hugh

Logan did not know; but the five of them--two had gagged Powert, and

were sitting on the man--were staring at Logan intently. This was no

time for long explanations. “Untie me,” Logan said. “I am Hugh Logan,

and I am to marry Miss Mary MacAskival.”

There was a murmur from the men, and all five MacAskivals of Daldour

took off their caps deferentially, and then put them back on again.

With a fisherman’s deftness, old Malcolm Mor undid the cords about

Logan’s wrists and ankles, and the two men who looked like twins

promptly bound Powert with them. As he released Logan, Malcolm Mor

said, in decent English, “Then I am your man, sir, and so are my sons

and my grandson, and my nephew Angus, and my nephew Kenneth who is not

here. We saw the man with the third eye lead the lady away. Will we

go after her?” Malcolm Mor tapped his shotgun. Malcolm Mor’s two sons

had old rifles; the boy and Angus, the queer burly man in the queerer

clothes, were unarmed. One of the sons, almost bowing, handed Powert’s

rifle to Logan as he stood up and tried to get the blood to circulate

in his tingling wrists and ankles.

Hugh Logan surveyed his little army. “Yes, we will,” he said, “if they

don’t come after us first. Just now they’re down in the valley hunting

someone; but some of them will come back to the chapel.” These men,

he thought, would be good shots; and to live in Daldour, they must be

hardy and probably courageous, though he doubted whether they had much

experience at man-killing.

“It is my nephew Kenneth that they are hunting,” Malcolm Mor observed.

“I sent him to watch them from the bracken. It was Kenneth who shot his

gun to lead them away from the chapel. They will not find him. We have

watched them for a week, but we did not understand what they did, and

there was no gentleman to lead us. We would have shot the man with the

third eye when he took the lady away, but we were afraid that she might

be hurt. Is it so that they are robbers and murderers?”

“That they are,” Logan said, emphatically.

“Then,” Malcolm Mor went on, in the slow, gentle Island English, “it

would be lawful for us to hunt them?” Logan suspected that the people

of Daldour were extremely shy of the law.

“It would,” Logan told him. “I am a lawyer, and I give you my

authority.”

Malcolm Mor MacAskival’s old eyes lit up, and he smiled as some Norse

rover might have smiled. “Then, sir,” he said, “we will go after the

lady, and take the Old House of Fear.” He seemed to have no doubt

whatsoever of the success of this undertaking by five or six men and a

boy. “There are three more able-bodied men in Daldour, but we have no

time to fetch them. Kenneth, my nephew, will come to us soon. Will we

go down into the valley now, Mr. Logan?”

“Let’s have a look about,” Logan said. The men followed him through the

chapel doorway. When Logan had thrown his rucksack on the fire, he had

stuffed his binoculars into a trouser-pocket; and now he pulled them

out and stared through them in the direction of the Old House; but,

what with hills, rocks, and clumps of trees and thickets of bracken, he

could see no one moving.

Then, a hundred yards away, and ascending toward the chapel, Anderson

came into view. Logan dropped the binoculars and snatched up his rifle,

but Anderson had seen them before he could get the gun to his shoulder.

For a second, Anderson stared aghast; then, flinging himself around,

he leaped downhill, vanishing into bracken, reappearing on a knoll,

slipping, almost rolling down a talus-slope, merging with the blur of

gray rock and purple heather and green bracken. Logan fired twice, but

could not have hit him. At that, Malcolm Mor and his two sons brought

up their guns and fired also. They did not really take aim, and Logan

thought they meant to frighten, rather than to wound; but also he

thought that they could be brought to shoot to kill if they must.

“We can catch him,” Malcolm Mor said, like a dog eager for the word

from his master. “He is a town man, and we are faster.”

“No,” Logan decided, shaking his head, “no, there’ll be three others

down there, and they have Miss MacAskival with them, on a rope. We’ll

go down and after them, but together; and no one must shoot if the lady

might be hurt.” This deliberation was agony to Logan himself, but he

had been an officer, and he knew something of tactics.

The MacAskivals nodded. “My nephew Kenneth will be watching them from

the bracken,” Malcolm Mor said. “We will go down, and he will join us;

and if they take the lady to the Old House, then we will follow them

into the house.”

Malcolm Mor’s nephew Angus, the burly man in the dirty yellow

waistcoat, was nodding and smiling at every word his old uncle uttered.

“Do you have a gun?” Logan said to him. The man opened his mouth, but

words did not come out: only mouthed grunts, rather horrid. Malcolm Mor

seemed somewhat embarrassed.

“He can not speak,” the boy--Malcolm Gille was his name--said

apologetically. “He is called”--here the boy seemed to seek the English

equivalent of a Gaelic term, and emerged triumphantly--“he is called

Dumb Angus.” Dumb Angus nodded enthusiastically at the mention of his

name. “And,” the boy went on, “he is simple. Dumb Angus is simple, and

does not have a gun, but he is very strong, and he is honest, and he

makes many jokes.” Dumb Angus bowed and smiled, and tapped himself on

the head to prove that he knew he was simple. “He cannot speak,” the

boy said, “but he makes jokes in other ways.”

Logan checked Powert’s rifle, and reloaded; one of Malcolm’s

sons--their names, it turned out, were John and Robert--brought him

a cartridge-pouch that Powert had worn. What ought they to do with

Powert? Malcolm Mor, now assured that the majesty of the law sheltered

the persecuted sept of MacAskival, speculatively fingered the little

black knife in his belt. “No,” said Logan, “we’ll bring them all to

trial, if we can.”

“There is one already taken and locked away,” Malcolm Mor offered. “His

name, I think, is Carruthers. We took him the night before last night,

and carried him to Daldour, and locked him in a byre, and he is afraid,

for he thinks that we will eat him. Dumb Angus made him think so; that

is one of the jokes of Dumb Angus. It is pleasant to have Dumb Angus

in Daldour. We could carry this man, too, to Daldour, but there is not

time.”

Dumb Angus was gesturing and beckoning, and pointing upward. At the

east end of the chapel, behind the altar, ran a kind of low loft or

gallery, of wood, probably built when the chapel was re-roofed by Sir

Alastair MacAskival. “Yes,” said Logan, “that will do. Put Powert

there, at the back, and no one is likely to notice him until we need

him.” The sons of Malcolm carried Powert up the short flight of wooden

steps, and tightened the cords and his gag. Dumb Angus might be simple,

but he had eyes in his head.

And now they could start in pursuit of Jackman, for Mary MacAskival’s

sake. Anderson probably would have warned Jackman and the others by

this time; but the warning might do no mischief, for those four guns

going off at his heels must have sounded to Anderson as if half the

constabulary of Scotland were after him. They could not catch Jackman

and the rest before they reached the Old House, the odds were, nor

would it have been safe to fire at the retreating gang with Mary

MacAskival in their midst. But by night, Logan was resolved, he and

the Daldour people would make their try. “Well, gentlemen,” he said to

Malcolm Mor and the others, “if you’re ready, I am.” And they started

down the brae.

As they trotted and scrambled toward the valley, the boy running by

Logan’s side, Logan said to Malcolm Gille, “Why does Dumb Angus wear

such clothes?”

“Those clothes were not his.” The boy smiled broadly. “It is one of the

jokes of Dumb Angus. They are the clothes of Mr. Lagg, the factor, that

we found broken below the cliffs and buried in the chapel of St. Merin.

For Dumb Angus, it is always Hallowe’en.”

The humor of Daldour, Logan took it, had its grisly side. Dumb Angus it

must have been that Rab had encountered two nights before. If even the

simpletons of Daldour--and the whole band of Daldour MacAskivals was

a remarkably odd-looking lot--were this resourceful, it might be just

possible for Logan to get Mary alive out of the Old House.

14

On the flank of Cailleach, a little ferret-like man rose out of the

heather to join Logan and the MacAskivals: Kenneth MacAskival. Like the

rest of his family, he really understood English, when he chose, and

could speak it tolerably well when he had to. On learning from Malcolm

Mor that this gentleman was the betrothed of The MacAskival, Kenneth

gave Logan his report.

After firing twice that morning to draw Jackman away from the chapel,

Kenneth MacAskival had contented himself with creeping through the

bracken and spying on the retreating party. The lady, Kenneth said,

never spoke, so far as he could hear; though the men thrust her roughly

along when, led on a cord as she was, she stumbled. They would be at

the Old House within a few minutes, the man with the third eye and the

rest, and could not be intercepted.

Logan and his men did not move toward the Old House so fast as they

could have. For Jackman might have laid an ambush, which had to be

watched for among the rocks and dens of rugged Carnglass. Once, through

his binoculars, Logan caught a glimpse of a hurrying figure, very close

to the Old House; then it was hidden again by a low intervening ridge.

Either of two courses he might take, Logan thought. He might send

the MacAskivals in their lobster boat to Loch Boisdale or whatever

other port they could reach that had a police station, and ask for

prompt help. But this would take hours, many hours, and meanwhile

Jackman would have Mary MacAskival in the Old House. And Jackman would

be thinking of the ruin of his scheme, and of the gelignite in the

cellars. Besides, would any police constable believe such a story, from

such a crew as the MacAskivals, without telegraphing to Glasgow or

Edinburgh for orders, which would mean delays? No, that plan wouldn’t

do.

So there remained to Logan only the storming of the Old House. Briefly,

he thought of trying to enter through the passage in the rock by which

Mary and he had escaped; but that was no go, since one of Jackman’s

riflemen at the cistern-mouth could kill anyone who tried to ascend.

They would have to rush the place from outside.

The thing could not be tried until evening, for Jackman had more men

within the Old House than Logan had without, and Jackman’s men were

desperate, well armed, and probably experienced in killing. By day,

it would have been mad. The oldest tower, with its little windows and

iron bars, would have been impossible to take even if defended by only

one or two riflemen, unless the attackers had mortars. The Renaissance

block was nearly as strong. But the Victorian addition was another

matter. The gate was stout, and the ground-floor windows were small,

covered by iron grills, and shuttered within. The plate-glass windows

of the first floor, however, were immense and undefended, and could be

reached with a long ladder--after dark. Even supposing Logan and his

men got inside the Old House, they still would be outnumbered. Their

hope was that before they should make their rush, they might be able

to demolish the morale of Jackman’s people, already badly shaken.

To help Mary, Logan would have taken any risk: if getting himself shot

would have saved her, he would have rushed the Old House that hour.

But the best chance for saving her, it seemed to him, lay in keeping

Jackman’s people very much on edge, and busy--and in praying that

Jackman himself might not go mad altogether. And this meant that some

eight hours, eight intolerable hours for Logan, must pass before he

could act.

But meanwhile he could prepare. Giving the Old House a wide berth, he

led the MacAskivals to the farm steading nearest the castle. Before

the troubles had begun, Simmons had kept the steading in some order,

though there were only two animals about the place: two shaggy and

ill-tempered little Barra horses, grazing in a small field. Having

caught the horses, the MacAskivals harnessed them to a farm cart.

This they loaded with straw, and with what loose lumber they could

find; also they put two gallon tins of paraffin, discovered in the

farmhouse, into the cart. In a shed they came upon a long ladder, which

they piled atop straw and lumber. Then, keeping out of range of fire

from the Old House, Dumb Angus and Malcolm Gille took the horses and

cart circuitously round to the wooded policies of the New House, which

was as close to the Victorian wing of the Old House as they could get

without being fired upon.

While this operation was going forward, Logan sent Kenneth and John

MacAskival to the rocky and bracken-covered hillsides that were barely

within extreme firing range of the Old House. And there the two

veteran poachers commenced a desultory fire against the windows of the

Old House. Logan gave Powert’s rifle to Kenneth, as the best weapon

available, taking Kenneth’s shotgun for himself. Concealed as they were

by dense bracken, and shifting position after every shot, there was

little danger of the MacAskivals being hit by retaliatory fire from

the Old House. For their part, the MacAskivals were instructed not

really to attempt to hit anyone, but to spend their time shattering

panes and nerves. The windows of Mary’s room in the old tower they

left untouched. Lady MacAskival’s room was on the seaward side of the

Old House, and so safe. For that matter, the whole garrison of the Old

House could retreat to the seaward rooms and temporary security, except

for what luckless sentinels Dr. Jackman might leave to guard against a

sudden rush. By early afternoon, every pane on the eastern side of the

Old House had been shattered, except those in Mary MacAskival’s windows.

For the first hour of this, three or four marksmen replied from the

Old House. But they could have seen almost nothing to shoot at, and

their risk of being struck by flying windowglass, if not by bullets,

was considerable. The return fire slackened perceptibly in the second

hour, and after that there came only infrequent shots from a single

rifle on the second floor, as if to demonstrate that the defenders were

still awake. Another rifleman on the roof of the old tower was driven

below early in the game. What all this did to the nerves of Jackman’s

men--this sniping by an unknown body of enemies, who had not even made

a formal demand for the surrender of the Old House--Logan could only

surmise. The loss of Powert, too, coming on the heels of Carruthers’

disappearance and the discovery of Lagg’s body, must have made an

impression.

Logan sent Robert MacAskival round to keep an eye on the back of the

old tower, to make sure no one slipped out by the garden gate; the

man hid himself behind an outcrop of rock and bided his time, leaving

the shooting to the others. Accompanied by Malcolm Mor, Logan himself

watched the main entrance from the plantation that stretched from the

New House nearly to the rock of the Old House. And from Malcolm Mor, as

they lay on their bellies under cover, that warm and fatal spring day,

Logan pieced together a good deal more of the history of the recent

troubles in Carnglass.

* * * * *

Poaching in Carnglass the shy twilight folk of Daldour took for a

natural right. The older people of the Daldour MacAskivals, like

Malcolm Mor, had been born in Carnglass and looked upon it as Eden;

several of them, from time to time, right down to the coming of Dr.

Jackman as Lady MacAskivals guest and master, had been servants at the

Old House or on the two farms. Life in that windswept peat-bog Daldour

was precarious at best, and the dwindling race of the MacAskival

crofters and fisherfolk had considered the killing of a sheep or a

deer in Carnglass as no more than getting back a bit of their lost

patrimony. That the sheep and the deer nominally belonged to old Lady

MacAskival was little to them: she was a mere Lowlander, a MacAskival

only by marriage--a bad marriage at that--and their enemy.

So whenever they dared--especially in the early morning or the evening,

when the gamekeepers might be in their cottages--the Daldour men, for

years, had landed in Carnglass under cover of darkness or fog, most

commonly mooring their lobster-boats in a great cave under the headland

on which St. Merin’s Chapel stood. The cave was known to very few;

and though the ascent was precarious even for MacAskivals, still the

descent was so risky as to daunt even the boldest hired gamekeeper,

most of the time.

And it seemed that the taking ways of the Daldour MacAskivals, in

recent years, had been winked at by The MacAskival herself, Miss Mary.

For she had been a little girl on a barren island croft, and knew the

rigors of the Daldour life. Besides, she was adored by, and adored, old

Malcolm Mor, the chief man in Daldour, who for some years turned from

fishing and poaching to being the gardener at the Old House, until Lagg

gave him the sack. Malcolm Mor told her tales of the vanished glories

of the MacAskivals, and of the witcheries of Carnglass, and showed the

schoolgirl, during her Carnglass summers, the secrets of the Old House

and of the Carnglass caves. What Malcolm Mor’s kith and kin did, Mary

MacAskival overlooked when overlooking was discreet. Now and again,

on lonely rambles to the further reaches of the deserted island, Mary

would meet with the furtive deer-stalkers and sheep-stealers from

Daldour, who blended with gorse and heather and bracken when anyone

else showed his face; and they would tip their caps, and offer the girl

strange things washed up from the sea, such as “Mary’s Nut,” a Molucca

bean, come by the Gulf Stream all the way from the Caribbean--for it

brought good fortune, if worn on a chain round the neck.

As for Malcolm Mor, even after canny and tight-fisted Tam Lagg

discharged the old pirate, Mary MacAskival kept in touch with him by a

sepulchral line of communications. Their system was this: on her walks,

Mary would slip a note into the receptacle in Sir Alastair’s tomb at

the chapel, and Malcolm would pick it up when next he climbed over the

cliff-head from his boat moored in the cave far below. Malcolm Mor,

though he was ashamed of the accomplishment as a decadent concession

to modern civilization, could write a primitive English, and he

would scrawl in his crabbed hand brief and respectful replies to The

MacAskival’s communications, giving news of his family to the lonely

girl, and of how the fishing had gone. So long as she was permitted to

ramble at will in Carnglass, Mary MacAskival could send letters to the

outer world through this tomb postbox, for old Duncan would post them

in Loch Boisdale on the few occasions when the lobster boat crossed the

rough waters to South Uist. Thus she had contrived to send her last

message, the unsigned note, crumpled and water-stained, which reached

Duncan MacAskival in Michigan. After that she had been too closely

watched by Jackman and his men to make the attempt, and toward the end

she had not been able to leave the Old House at all.

Before the coming of Jackman, and while Lady MacAskival retained some

vigor and Lagg had the management of the island in his hands, two or

three reasonably zealous gamekeepers made the poaching by the Daldour

men a career of danger and daring, which they dared not attempt more

than once a month, at best. The keepers’ shotguns had wounded two or

three of old Malcolm’s sons and grandsons, and once the keepers almost

had seized the boat moored in the cave.

But after Jackman’s men replaced the old servants, the people at

the Old House scarcely visited the hinterland of Carnglass. Donley,

nominally the new keeper, ordinarily stuck fairly close to his cottage

near the Old House, and the regions round Dalcruach and St. Merin’s

Chapel, especially, became safe ground for the poachers. More and

more of the queer, long-legged, long-necked, soft-fleeced sheep of

Carnglass, and now and then a deer, were borne off triumphantly in the

lobster boat to hungry Daldour.

Only one aspect of the new regime in Carnglass troubled the Daldour

MacAskivals: Dr. Jackman and his ways. They spied upon him from the

bracken, and sometimes crept close enough to perceive the curious

spot in his forehead--which, among these misty folk who told legends

over their peat fires and never saw the penny press and never heard

a wireless, was at once recognized as the supernatural Third Eye of

a Carnglass warlock. They saw the rough crew of town toughs he had

gathered round him, too, and their suspicions grew. And Mary MacAskival

rarely came forth from the Old House; at last she did not come at all,

though they could glimpse her sometimes at the summit of the tower

or in the little walled garden. For the people of Daldour, Miss Mary

MacAskival was the symbol of their identity, and the hope of their

salvation: for she had told old Malcolm, more than once that, when she

was mistress in the island, she would bring back the MacAskivals to

the farms and the crofts from which her aunt had expelled the last of

them in 1914. The man with the third eye, they told one another, meant

Mary MacAskival no good. They continued to watch. None of them were

cowards, but they were shy of the law, for the law had expelled them

from Carnglass; and besides, they were poachers, and in Daldour secret

distillers of whiskey on which they paid no duty.

There were not many of them in Daldour, and few of the men were

young. Of the men who should have been in their thirties, several had

died during the war as naval or merchant seamen; and nearly all the

rest, acquiring new tastes during their military service or unable to

find places for themselves in the island, had gone off to Glasgow or

America. The old and middle-aged MacAskival men in Daldour, for lack of

young blood, withdrew more and more from the modern world, so far as

modernity ever had touched them at all. They were shy of the law, shy

of people from the mainland, shy of townsfolk, shy even of crofters and

fishermen from the other islands.

A week ago, four MacAskivals, Malcolm Mor leading them, had put out in

their boat, cloaked by fog and the setting of the sun, to land again at

the foot of the cliffs below St. Merin’s Chapel. Only the MacAskivals

of Daldour could sail those treacherous waters in such weather. As

they had been about to moor the boat in the cave under the cliff, Dumb

Angus had taken Malcolm by the shoulder and pointed excitedly. Caught

between two rocks near the cave’s mouth, and awash in the ebbing tide,

was the body of a man. They drew the corpse into their boat. It was Tam

Lagg, who had been factor of Carnglass, and his corpse was terribly

battered; he must have fallen from the cliffs. His hat they found a

little later, lodged in a clump of ferns a few yards up the cliff.

“The sea casts its dead upon Carnglass,” a proverb of the Islands runs.

Many men have drowned on the reefs in those waters, or have been caught

in the currents and hurled against the cliffs in their boats; but it

is a strange truth that the whirlpools and eddies in that merciless

sea seem to bring up drowned men from miles round, and lodge what is

left of them among the rocks or on the narrow beaches of the island

called the Heap of Stones. The four men in the Daldour lobster boat

had looked often upon drowned corpses; and they never failed to give

those derelicts decent burial, that they themselves might one day need

in their turn. The graveyard round the chapel in Carnglass, and the

smaller graveyard by the bare beach in Daldour, were dotted with little

wooden crosses marking the graves of seamen and soldiers from torpedoed

transports that had gone down between Uist and Carnglass.

Bury Tam Lagg, then, the MacAskivals must. But they were afraid of

the man with the third eye, at the Old House of Fear, who might lay

the blame of this strange death upon them, since they had enjoyed an

old vendetta with the factor of Carnglass; so they made no attempt to

report the discovery of the body to the people in the Old House. They

thought it best not to bury Lagg in Daldour, lest the body be found by

strangers there and the MacAskivals be accused of foul play. So they

wrapped Lagg in an old piece of canvas and, with great difficulty, got

the body to the top of the cliffs, where they buried it in St. Merin’s

Chapel. On the grave they left a saucer of salt and nails, with a

rowan twig atop it, to keep Lagg’s wraith from wandering, should it be

restless; for they thought it strange that a man so long familiar with

Carnglass should fall to his death.

They were not sorry that Lagg was dead: they had detested him. And Dumb

Angus, who dug the grave, took Lagg’s clothes by way of compensation,

and put them on, so that he looked for all the world like a stout

scarecrow in those torn and stained garments. Malcolm Mor feared that

this act might bring ill luck, but did not interfere, for they were

accustomed to let poor Angus have his way in all reasonable things. And

besides, Angus looked wonderfully comic in Lagg’s clothes, and made the

MacAskivals laugh, and so was happy. Many of the jokes of Dumb Angus

were no stranger than this.

Logan learned these matters from Malcolm Mor there on the edge of the

New House plantation of firs and aspens, while every ten minutes or

so a rifle went off on the landward side of the Old House; Kenneth

and John firing at the windows. Logan’s men had no great supply of

ammunition, but it was necessary to keep Jackman’s people in constant

uneasiness, so that the final rush on the Old House might have some

chance for success. As Logan and Malcolm lay talking, Dumb Angus

crawled up to join them, having finished his work of loading the farm

cart and getting it into the New House plantations.

“Dumb Angus is simple,” Malcolm Mor said, smiling at the burly man,

“but also he is clever. He made the joke better by a doing all his own.

Show Mr. Logan what it was you made, Angus.”

Very cheerfully, Angus took off the injured green porkpie hat he had

inherited from Thomas Lagg. Then he reached into a little leather bag

that hung suspended from one of his shoulders, and drew out a thing

seemingly shapeless. He pulled the thing all the way over his head,

as if it had been a rubber mask, and clapped his hat back on. Then,

gobbling unintelligibly, he looked Logan full in the face.

The effect was the more horrid because at first Logan could not

recognize the origin of this dreadful mask Dumb Angus had assumed. It

was not human, and yet had a semblance of humanity. It hung loosely on

the head. It had nostrils, but no true nose, and a drooping dreadful

mouth, and holes where its eye-sockets should be, with Dumb Angus’s

eyes glowing behind them. Angus wriggled with happiness at the effect

he produced upon Logan. It was the face of one of the peculiar sheep of

Carnglass, painstakingly skinned from the whole skull of the beast and

made a loathsome mask by Angus MacAskival.

If this was what Rab had seen in the gloaming, with the dead Lagg’s

clothing on the heavy body below it, it was no wonder that dull-witted

Rab had gone frantic with dread. “Poor Angus makes this on every

Hallowe’en,” Malcolm Mor was saying, “but this time he made it in the

spring, because he had taken Mr. Lagg’s clothes, and wished to make us

laugh.”

On the same evening that the MacAskivals buried Lagg, they had caught

a glimpse of Donley skulking among boulders near Dalcruach, and they

had hurried back to their boat and returned to Daldour, thinking that

Donley might have seen them as well. But they had found they could

not restrain their curiosity, and so sailed to Carnglass early the

following morning, and from the bracken had seen Donley pursued by

men from the Old House. They had debated among themselves whether

they ought to reveal themselves to Donley and carry him off safely to

Daldour; but they did not know the right and wrong of the feud between

Donley and his pursuers, and also they had an ancient grudge against

all gamekeepers; so they let the chase continue, only watching it from

a fairly safe distance. Two or three times both Donley and the men

from the Old House seemed to suspect that they were being tracked and

watched, and to be correspondingly nervous. This tickled the fancy

of the MacAskivals, especially Dumb Angus, and, without showing

themselves distinctly, they dogged the Carnglass men like bogles.

These MacAskivals had seen Donley and Logan together on the shore, the

night Donley had taken the dinghy. They had watched Logan for a part

of the way as he followed the line of cliffs to the Old House. They

had lingered near the searching parties that went out of the Old House

in pursuit of Donley while Logan had been inside. And on one of these

occasions, three of the MacAskivals--Robert, John, and Dumb Angus--had

been imprudent. Carruthers and Rab, cautiously poking through the

bracken near the ruined farmhouse where Lagg had been caught, had

stumbled upon the Daldour men. Carruthers, in the lead a few yards,

had found himself right in the midst of the three MacAskivals, and

had shouted in astonishment to Rab. Instantly, Malcolm’s two sons had

dragged him down and begun to bind him, snatching away his gun; they

were old hands at such fights with keepers. Rab had come running up,

and Dumb Angus, wearing his sheep-mask and Lagg’s clothes, had risen

out of the bracken to confront him. Turning tail, the shocked and

screaming Rab had run all the way back to the Old House, now and then

firing into the bracken, but never hitting the delighted Angus, who had

followed at a prudent distance. Logan knew the rest.

By this time, Malcolm Mor had become convinced that something was

gravely wrong at the Old House, and was bent on helping Mary MacAskival

if only he could determine what to do. He and the others took

Carruthers back to Daldour in their boat, at the risk of a prosecution

for kidnapping, and locked him in a byre, where they fed him well and

asked him questions quite civilly; but the man was so terror-stricken

that they could get nothing sensible from him. The day after the

capture, the MacAskivals spent in Daldour asking these fruitless

questions of their prisoner. Three hours before dawn on the present

day, they had sailed once more toward Carnglass, with the intention of

going straight up to the Old House, if necessary, and demanding to see

Miss MacAskival.

Then, when almost under the northern headland of Carnglass, the

MacAskivals had seen flaming against the night sky the fire which Logan

and the girl had kindled. That beacon must be close by St. Merin’s

Chapel; and at the chapel Malcolm Mor had collected Mary MacAskival’s

letters, and the Cross of Carnglass had been the point of rendezvous

when Malcolm, now and then, had met with the girl face to face. The

odds were that this fire was a sign from Mary herself. Mooring the

boat, the MacAskivals went warily up the cliff, reaching the summit

just after dawn.

All the time, then, Logan realized, the girl must have entertained hope

of the MacAskivals’ coming. Why she had given him only hints, never

speaking out, he could not say. In part, perhaps, she had hesitated to

speak because she feared that, after all, nothing would come of this.

And in part, likely enough, her pride as The MacAskival had prompted

her to make the decision herself, without consulting even the man she

loved. But most of all, Logan suspected, a certain lingering schoolgirl

love of secrets had been at work. From the time Carruthers was missed

and Rab ran shrieking into the Old House, Mary MacAskival must have

been sure that the MacAskivals of Daldour were in the island. Her only

chance of finding them hurriedly if they were in the island the next

night, or of attracting their attention away in Daldour or out at sea,

was to light the beacon, whatever the risk of attracting Jackman’s

notice. That act had saved Logan, but not yet Mary herself.

Well, Malcolm Mor and the others had got their heads over the summit

of the sea-cliff just as Logan had been fighting with Jackman and his

men at the door of the broch. The men of Daldour had crouched behind

the tumbling drystone wall at the brink of the cliff, unnoticed by

Jackman’s gang during the scuffle. In that moment, Malcolm had sent

his nephew Kenneth scurrying stealthily round the kirkyard wall and

down the brae, to create a diversion. And Kenneth, seeing two more of

Jackman’s men in the valley below, had fired on them to draw Jackman’s

party off at the time Logan and Mary MacAskival were held prisoners

in the graveyard and the chapel. When Malcolm had watched the girl

led away on a rope, he was ready to fight, law or no law. So he and

the others had surrounded St. Merin’s Chapel, stunned Powert, and

discovered, to their astonishment, the betrothed of Mary MacAskival.

“Mr. Logan,” said old Malcolm Mor, apparently quite confident of the

issue of the fight that was coming, “when Carnglass is the lady’s and

yours to do with as you will, Dumb Angus would be a good gardener for

you. It is a keeper that I myself would rather be. Dumb Angus is wise

with animals and plants”--here he patted Angus approvingly on a burly

shoulder--“and he would keep you always laughing.”

Dumb Angus had put the animal-mask back into his bag. He also had

slung over his shoulder, on a strap, the wooden spade that Logan had

seen thrust into the earth in the chapel; Angus had forgotten it there

when he dug Lagg’s grave, but now had retrieved it as the only weapon

ready to his hand. The wearing of such masks, Malcolm had remarked,

was common among the few remaining MacAskival children, in Daldour and

formerly in Carnglass, about Hallowe’en. Covered by that dead animal

face, Angus had looked mightily like the picture of the Firgower on the

ceiling of Jackman’s study in the old tower. Whether this custom was

some dim survival of a practice older than the Christian rites at the

Cross of Carnglass, Logan could not tell. It might have been that the

dead Pictish chiefs of Carnglass had worn such masks in heathen times,

at ceremonies in the chamber within the rock beneath the Old House, or

by the great broch on the cliff, the Pict’s House. Be this as it might,

the horrid false face that was Angus’s delight, like so much else in

Carnglass and Daldour, came as the last faint echo of an old Gaelic

song.

* * * * *

All that long afternoon Logan lay in wait hidden by the fir trees,

outwardly calm to hearten the MacAskivals, inwardly in torment at Mary

MacAskival’s danger within the Old House. As the sun began to set, he

dispatched the boy to Kenneth and John, still sniping on the landward

side of the Old House, with the word that they were to join him under

the trees close to the gate of the Victorian block, the moment it was

fairly dark.

When the light was almost gone, Malcolm and Angus harnessed the

Barra horses--which had been tethered behind the New House--to the

straw-loaded farm cart. The long ladder was carried to the edge of the

plantation; the run with it to the first-story windows of the Victorian

wing would be very risky, even if Logan’s whole plan went smoothly, but

the thing was possible. Climbing up the straw, the boy poured the tins

of paraffin over the loaded cart. Angus crept under the cart, to urge

on the horses so far as they dared use them. Kenneth, John, and Robert

were to be stationed behind the cart. When the cart had been drawn to

the edge of the trees, the horses must be cut out of their harness, and

the men, keeping their heads down, must push the cart the remaining

distance across naked rock to the gate of the Old House.

Malcolm Mor, Malcolm Gille, and Logan himself took position at the

edge of the trees, prone, with guns ready to fire into the windows

above the gate. These movements seem to have attracted attention from

whomever was on duty at those windows, for one shot was fired from the

Old House. But Logan’s men did not reply, and as the dark descended,

the great gray bulk of the castle of the MacAskivals lay still and

ominous, with not one light showing. Now, Mary, Hugh Logan thought,

I’ll go to you. The MacAskivals beside him knew what they had to do,

and none of them had shown much sign of fear.

The cart would be set afire against the gate, and Logan and the two

Malcolms would blaze away at the adjacent windows, as if the assault

were to come there. That was, after all, a venerable Highland and

Island military device, especially beloved by Rob Roy; and though if

the cart burned well it might char through the gate, there was no

danger of the great house, which was all stone, catching fire. But

Logan did not intend really to rush the gate. The true attack would be

on the flank, around the corner: while the attention of the defenders

was concentrated on the gate, Logan and his men would carry the ladder

to the windows of the landward side and break in, if they could. And

then, presumably, there would be shooting within the house; and the

odds were not in Logan’s favor. But this was the best he could do. It

was all he could do for Mary MacAskival, and it might be too late.

Now the cart had been pulled by the horses to the edge of the trees.

Someone inside the house must have heard the jingle of harness and the

whinnying of horses, for a shot fired at a venture passed through the

branches above their heads. “Now, Kenneth MacAskival, Angus!” Logan

said. They cut the horses out of the harness, and four men commenced,

shoving with all their strength, to run with the cart across the little

plateau of rock to the door of the Old House. As yet, the straw was not

alight, for they would need the advantage of darkness so long as they

could keep it.

Into the quiet night came a hoarse shout of alarm from the house:

Royall’s voice, Logan thought in that instant. Two rifles fired at the

cart, and then a third. Logan and his companions fired as fast as they

could into the windows above the gate, and Logan heard a man scream.

Still the cart ran on, and then crashed into the gate itself. The

riflemen in the house were firing straight down into the cart now, and

three of the MacAskivals ran out from behind it, leaping and rolling

for the shelter of the trees; Logan and the Malcolms covered them with

the best barrage they could contrive. That left Dumb Angus under the

cart.

Logan had given Angus careful instructions, through Malcolm Mor. Angus

had been handed a length of charred rope, and a supply of matches.

Crouching under the cart, he was to light the frayed rope, throw it

into the straw, and run for it. For Angus was very quick of body. Now

Logan saw a tiny flame spring up beneath the cart; it grew; still Angus

lingered. Next a flaming coil was flung upon the dry straw, which

caught. Two or three minutes passed, the firing from the house--were

there only two rifles now?--sporadic. Then a mass of flame roared up

from the cart, kindling the lumber among the straw also, and the light

from it shown fiercely across the empty windows of the façade. Angus

scooted from under the cart and down across the rock, Logan and the

others firing to cover him; but there was no answer from the windows by

the gate.

Now for the worst part. John MacAskival was useless, shot in one arm,

and dazed with shock; Logan flung his gun to the boy, telling him to

fire at will, for three minutes, into the windows by the gate; the boy

was utterly delighted. The rest of them, seizing the ladder, swung out

of the plantation toward the right, veered round the corner of the

Victorian block, and set the ladder against a first-story window,

Angus holding it firm at the bottom. Someone fired a shot from above

them, but no one seemed to be hit.

Logan leaped up, the others behind him, and in two seconds was smashing

out of the window-frame the shattered remnants of the plate glass,

using his gun-butt, and expecting any moment to get a bullet in his

chest. But the room within was silent. He flung himself into that room,

and the four MacAskivals were at his heels. And now, indeed, there were

gunshots; but they came from deep within the house, and no one opposed

Logan as they burst into the corridor.

15

Someone yelled in the corridor as Logan entered. But it was only a

little paper-white man, dragging a rifle feebly as if it were a ball

and chain: Tompkins. At sight of Logan, the butler dropped the rifle

altogether, falling to his knees, and cried, “O Gawd! Mr. Logan, sir,

don’t ’urt me, don’t! I’m your slaive, Mr. Logan! O Gawd, Jackman’s

mad, and they’re murderin’ heach hother below stairs.”

Clutching at Logan’s legs, Tompkins babbled on as to how he was only

an honest butler and part-time burglar, unaccustomed to killing. Logan

jerked him to his feet and forced him in the direction of the gunfire

within the house. “In the billiard room, Mr. Logan, sir!”

Urging Tompkins before them, Logan and the MacAskivals ran to the end

of the passage, rounded the corner to the left, and came to the door

of the billiard room. Dead or dying, Royall lay face down across the

threshold. Reckless, Logan strode over him. The big room, with its

long windows looking toward the harbor, had three more men in it. One

was Anderson, shot through the belly, writhing with his back against a

leg of the billiard table. One was Rab, sprawled in the middle of the

red Victorian carpet, a bullet hole between his eyes. The third was a

man Logan had not seen before, lying on a sofa, his eyes bandaged,

sightless, moaning in fear--Till, of course, the burned boatman. Where

was Jackman? Two or three more shots, in quick succession, sounded

within the house, somewhere below.

“Tompkins, tell me where Jackman’s gone, or I’ll finish you,” Logan

said. The butler, stammering and choking, could only point toward the

cellars below. Malcolm Mor ran in.

“In the room above the gate,” Malcolm said--he slipped here into

Gaelic, and with difficulty found his English again--“there is a

man with long hair, like a gypsy, and he has been shot through the

shoulder, and can do no harm.” That would be Niven; and that left

Jackman and Simmons and Ferd Caggia. And Mary, Mary.

“Tompkins,” Logan said, taking the man by the throat, “show me where

the crypt with the explosives is.” The butler reeled in Logan’s grip

along the passage, and down a flight of stairs, and then pointed to an

open doorway, from which stone steps led into shadows. Angus was behind

Logan; the other MacAskivals were poking into the rooms.

Releasing Tompkins, Logan went down those steps to a little landing,

and started to turn to the remaining flight that would take him to the

crypt. A rifle cracked, and the bullet ricocheted from the wall. Logan

flung himself back, nearly upsetting Angus.

“Jackman,” Logan called down, “drop your gun and come up, and I’ll

promise you a trial. Otherwise we’ll promise nothing.”

But it was not Jackman that answered from the crypt. “Ah! Meester

Logan, that is you?” The voice was rather faint.

“Who’s there?”

“Fernando Caggia, your fren’. Meester Logan, you owe me a pardon for

what I do.”

“Drop your gun, Caggia, and come up.”

A rifle was flung to the foot of the stairs. “Meester Logan, I can not

come up, for Dr. Jackman, he shoot me twice. But I save you.”

Logan leaped down those stairs. A barricade of boxes and chairs stood

before a little iron door, and between door and barricade lay Caggia,

covered with blood. “In this room,” Caggia said, trying to grin, “is

the gelignite. Dr. Jackman, he try to reach it, but I, Fernando Caggia,

do not let him. He shoot, I shoot, he shoot. I hit him once.”

“Where is he?”

Caggia gave a weak shrug. “One minute ago, he runs.”

Leaving Angus to watch the iron door, Logan dashed back up the stairs,

and at the top Malcolm met him. “We can not find that man,” Malcolm

said. “Will he be in the old tower?”

“Mary?”

“The door of the room of Lady MacAskival is locked, but there are

people inside.”

Now the boy had joined them, and as they ran into the Renaissance

building, Kenneth and Robert came out of a passage and followed. They

were at the door of the room which was hung with Spanish leather. Logan

tried the knob fiercely; it would not turn. He smashed at the door with

his rifle-butt, using all the strength that was in him, and it burst

inward. Someone leaped for him. “Hugh, Hugh!” Before them all, Mary

MacAskival covered him with kisses.

* * * * *

Later, from Mary and Tompkins and Till, Logan got an understanding of

what had passed within the Old House since morning. Wild with fury and

bewilderment, Jackman had dragged her back to the Old House from the

chapel, the three men with him as much afraid of their master as of the

shadowy armed men whom Anderson had seen before the chapel. According

to Anderson, there were twelve or fifteen of them, armed to the teeth.

At the moment of his triumph, of his taking of Logan, suddenly Jackman

had been undone. There was no way out.

Like a man in the grip of nightmare, Jackman scarcely could speak.

For a few moments, just after they had got back within the shelter

of the Old House, a flash of his old power returned to him. Seeing

Jackman bemused, Anderson and Rab and Caggia and Simmons made for the

girl: they would beat out of her the truth about those armed men by

the chapel. But turning on them, “like Rumpelstiltskin again,” Jackman

broke that mutiny, and hurried Mary MacAskival through the passages to

her aunt’s room. Thrusting her inside, he gave her a long look. “Well,”

Jackman said, passing his hand across his forehead, “I wish I had known

you long ago. Now you are going to die. We all are about to die.” He

went out, locking the door behind him.

All that day, Mary knelt praying in the room hung with Spanish leather.

Lady MacAskival, wasted beyond belief, lay motionless in her big bed,

not seeming to hear the bullets striking the walls in the rooms across

the gallery. Old Agnes sobbed in a corner. From the windows of this

room, Mary could see only the harbor, with the burned yacht, and the

empty sea beyond. And she prayed for Hugh Logan and for Carnglass.

It was Tompkins who told Logan much of what followed. Jackman,

uncertain in movements and speech, as if half paralyzed, stationed

Anderson, Rab, and Caggia in rooms on the landward side of the Old

House, to reply to the sniping from the bracken. Simmons he put into

the study, guarding the door of the old tower. He ordered Niven and

Tompkins to duty in the rooms above the gate. For a time he went

himself to the roof of the old tower and fired at the riflemen slinking

among the distant rocks and heather and bracken; but all this was

done as if he were sleep-walking. Then he went down to the billiard

room, which was safe from gunfire, and sat at a table with his head

in his hands. Royall tried to talk with him, but Jackman would not

reply. Thereafter Royall conducted the defense, so far as there was any

organized resistance.

Caggia, who had gone below stairs to get the men food, did not

reappear. Rab and Anderson, driven from the landward rooms by the

sniping, got at the rum. They drank it in the billiard room where

Jackman sat, and cursed at Jackman, and Jackman did not answer. And the

hours passed.

Royall, left alone in the landward rooms, had his cheek laid open by

a splinter of glass, but he kept on firing. When the sniping ceased

on that side, he went to the billiard room and again tried to rouse

Jackman. At gun-point, Royall ordered Rab up to the room over the

gate, to reinforce Niven and Tompkins. Anderson went below stairs,

and Tompkins heard him crying defiantly to Royall--something about

explosives.

When the attack on the gate came, and the cart was burning under the

windows, Niven was hit by a bullet. In panic, Rab fled to the billiard

room, screaming out, “The hoose! They’re burnin’ a’ the hoose!” Royall

and Anderson hurried in. This was told to Logan by the blinded boatman

Till, who had lain helpless during the billiard-room fight.

“O aye, we’re done!” Anderson roared. “Gie it ower, Jackman, we’ve had

it!”

Then Jackman rose from his chair. “Royall,” Jackman said, “keep the men

here.”

“Gude God,” Till heard Anderson say, “the auld de’il’s for the

explosives! Jackman, damn ye, dinna open that door.”

“Rab,” cried Royall, “drop your gun.” Shooting began then, Till

cowering on the sofa. There must have been four or five shots, and

after them running steps. Till could hear Anderson groaning and

cursing. After that, Logan and his men came.

Edmund Jackman had made for the cellars and the gelignite. Down there,

Ferd Caggia crouched behind a little barricade in front of the iron

door; for Ferd had remembered Logan’s words about Jackman’s madness,

and he, cat-like, had been watching Jackman. “Dr. Jackman,” Caggia had

said, “you don’ blow me to hell.” Jackman had fired at him promptly,

and had hit him, but Caggia had fired back. After a minute’s exchange

of shots, the Maltese, wounded, still gripped his rifle behind the

boxes and chairs. Jackman had leaped back up the stairs and was gone

through the passages. Even his try for annihilation had failed.

* * * * *

Simmons they found still in the study in the old tower, and took him

without difficulty. But Dr. Edmund Jackman they did not find. The door

to the garden was open, and Simmons said that from the window he had

seen Jackman go over the garden wall, favoring one side as if he were

slightly wounded.

“I think, Mr. Logan,” Malcolm Mor said, “that because he is a clever

man, he will have gone to look for our boat below the chapel.”

Yes, he would have, Logan thought. In the course of the fight, Jackman

must have recognized some of the attackers, perhaps old Malcolm; and,

having seen them that morning near the chapel, he would guess that the

boat was below those cliffs. That the wounded man could find his way

down, Logan doubted. Yet so long as Jackman was at large, no one in

Carnglass could be safe. The hound had become the fox now.

“Mary,” Hugh Logan said, “I must be after him.” She had an arm around

him.

“I know the island best,” she told him, “and from this night I am going

to stay with you always, Hugh.”

He looked down at her. “And who would guard the Old House, then, and do

something for the men who’ve been shot, and put out the embers at the

gate, and give the MacAskivals something to eat?”

Knowing that this was no moment for argument if Jackman were bound

for the boat, Mary MacAskival looked proudly into Logan’s eyes. “Then

take Malcolm Mor,” she said, “for he will know where to search, and I

will send other men so soon as I can.” The MacAskivals, having locked

Simmons and Tompkins in a cellar, crowded round her deferentially for

instructions. “Dr. Jackman shot my dog, Hugh, to hurt me. But do you

come back to me, forever.”

One last kiss, and then he left her in her strength and beauty, as the

tears were starting down her cheeks. “Before sunrise, Mary girl, I’ll

be with you.” Logan and Malcolm Mor went through the garden--for the

great gate still was a charred and smoking hulk--and over the garden

dyke below the old tower, the way that Jackman had gone, and they

strode toward St. Merin’s Chapel. Now and then Logan stumbled: he had

been without sleep for twenty-four hours.

“If he can go down the cliffs,” Malcolm Mor panted, “then the man with

the third eye is more than man.” Malcolm was a wonder: he had been on

his feet nearly as long as Logan, and he was past seventy.

Beyond Cailleach, they flung themselves down for a brief rest. Their

rifles seemed immensely heavy. Carnglass, in its nocturnal beauty, was

at peace. The bleating of sheep, disturbed by the men, echoed from the

heights where the chapel stood. “Malcolm Mor,” Logan said, “I believe

you think Jackman really is something not human.”

“It would be well to have silver bullets for our guns.” The old man

muttered something in Gaelic. “But devil or not, he will have climbed

up there.” Malcolm Mor gestured toward the headland. They took up their

guns again, and in less than an hour made out the shape of St. Merin’s

Chapel, and of the Pict’s House, the Firgower’s House, beyond it.

“If he has tried the path here,” Malcolm said very low, “he will

not reach the shore alive, not knowing the way, and having a bullet

in him.” Both Logan and Malcolm Mor moved slowly now; Logan doubted

whether even Malcolm, while so weary, could descend this precipice, and

he was certain that he himself could not. They climbed over the ruinous

drystone wall close by the broch; from the dyke to the crumbling

cliff-edge was less than a yard. A thousand feet and more below, the

ocean heaved northward to the pole.

Then something rose from behind the dyke. Malcolm Mor tried to bring

up his rifle, but a bullet struck the stock and sent the gun spinning

from his hand. Logan had his rifle over his shoulder. He pulled at it

desperately. And Jackman shot Hugh Logan.

Logan fell backward, and his head struck nothing at all, for he lay

right on the cliff’s edge, with only infinite space at the back of his

head. There was a fierce pain in his right thigh, where the bullet

from the little pistol had caught him. Edmund Jackman stepped over

the broken dyke and stood only seven or eight feet distant from them,

his left arm pressed hard against his side. The moonlight was full on

Jackman’s face, and the eyes were slits, and the face was that of a man

lost in a nightmare. Malcolm Mor stood fixed by the spot where Logan

lay.

“Young Askival and Old Askival,” Jackman said. “I have the two of you.”

He pointed the pistol at Malcolm. “Put him over the edge, Old Askival.”

Malcolm Mor bent slowly over Logan. He took Logan by the shoulders, and

drew him back from that terrible cliff-lip, and propped him against

a stone fallen from the dyke. Silent, Malcolm stared at Jackman. I am

done, Logan thought, but if I can catch his ankle, Jackman may go over

the edge with me, and Mary will be safe.

“Both of you at once, then,” Jackman said dismally. “Old Askival and

Young Askival.” He took aim at Malcolm. Hugh Logan tried to hurl

himself forward, but his smashed thighbone failed him.

There came, at that instant, a kind of gurgling cry, and a sound

of running, of something hurrying right along the cliff’s edge, at

Jackman’s back. Edmund Jackman turned his head. Malcolm and Logan and

Jackman saw all at once the thing that was coming.

It was a burly man in tattered corduroy breeches, a long green jacket,

and a yellow waistcoat, with a porkpie hat on his head, his arms

flapping as he ran. He mouthed as he came, but what noise he uttered

was not speech. And his face was a dead mask, and not human. The thing

made straight for Jackman.

Mary had sent Angus after Logan. And, with the heroism of children and

simpletons, Angus sought to put his body between Logan and his enemy.

But what Edmund Jackman saw in that dreadful masked figure, Logan knew:

the shape of his victim, and the face of his nightmare horror. With a

moan, Jackman turned to run. He took one bound in that high place, and

upon the brink the heather gave beneath him; and where Lagg had gone

down, there Jackman fell.

Though they say that the ocean yields up all its dead upon the skerries

of Carnglass, no man found Jackman after. As from the cliff-head at

Gadara, the unclean spirit was cast into the sea. And Logan, with

Malcolm Mor kneeling beside him and Dumb Angus shivering with fright

against the dyke, heard no sound from below but the suck of the tide

upon the weary stones.

TRANSCRIBER’S NOTES:

Italicized text is surrounded by underscores: _italics_.

Perceived typographical errors have been corrected.

Inconsistencies in hyphenation have been standardized.

Archaic or variant spelling has been retained.

New original cover art included with this eBook is granted to the

public domain.

Extensive research did not uncover any evidence that the U.S.

copyright on this publication was renewed.

Old House of Fear · 第 18 / 18 章