THE END OF THE CASE
A profound silence had fallen on the room and its occupants. Mr.
Jellicoe sat with his eyes fixed on the table as if deep in thought,
the unlighted cigarette in one hand, the other grasping the tumbler of
water. Presently Inspector Badger coughed impatiently and he looked
up. "I beg your pardon, gentleman," he said. "I am keeping you
waiting."
He took a sip from the tumbler, opened a match-box and took out a
match, but apparently altering his mind, laid it down and commenced:
"The unfortunate affair which has brought you here to-night, had its
origin ten years ago. At that time my friend Hurst became suddenly
involved in financial difficulties--am I speaking too fast for you, Mr.
Badger?"
"No, not at all," replied Badger. "I am taking it down in shorthand."
"Thank you," said Mr. Jellicoe. "He became involved in serious
difficulties and came to me for assistance. He wished to borrow five
thousand pounds to enable him to meet his engagements. I had a certain
amount of money at my disposal, but I did not consider Hurst's security
satisfactory; accordingly I felt compelled to refuse. But on the very
next day, John Bellingham called on me with a draft of his will which
he wished me to look over before it was executed.
"It was an absurd will, and I nearly told him so; but then an idea
occurred to me in connection with Hurst. It was obvious to me, as soon
as I glanced through the will, that, if the burial clause was left as
the testator had drafted it, Hurst had a very good chance of inheriting
the property; and, as I was named as the executor I should be able to
give full effect to that clause. Accordingly, I asked for a few days
to consider the will, and then I called upon Hurst and made a proposal
to him; which was this: That I should advance him five thousand pounds
without security; that I should ask for no repayment, but that he
should assign to me any interest that he might have or acquire in the
estate of John Bellingham up to ten thousand pounds, or two-thirds of
any sum that he might inherit if over that amount. He asked if John
had yet made any will, and I replied, quite correctly, that he had not.
He inquired if I knew what testamentary arrangements John intended to
make, and again I answered, quite correctly, that I believed John
proposed to devise the bulk of his property to his brother, Godfrey.
"Thereupon, Hurst accepted my proposal; I made him the advance and he
executed the assignment. After a few days' delay, I passed the will as
satisfactory. The actual document was written from the draft by the
testator himself; and a fortnight after Hurst had executed the
assignment, John signed the will in my office. By the provisions of
that will I stood an excellent chance of becoming virtually the
principal beneficiary, unless Godfrey should contest Hurst's claim and
the Court should override the conditions of clause two.
"You will now understand the motives which governed my subsequent
actions. You will also see, Doctor Thorndyke, how very near to the
truth your reasoning carried you; and you will understand, as I wish
you to do, that Mr. Hurst was no party to any of these proceedings
which I am about to describe.
"Coming now to the interview in Queen Square in October, nineteen
hundred and two, you are aware of the general circumstances from my
evidence in Court, which was literally correct up to a certain point.
The interview took place in a room on the third floor, in which were
stored the cases which John had brought with him from Egypt. The mummy
was unpacked, as were some other objects that he was not offering to
the Museum, but several cases were still unopened. At the conclusion
of the interview I accompanied Doctor Norbury down to the street door,
and we stood on the doorstep conversing for perhaps a quarter of an
hour. Then Doctor Norbury went away and I returned upstairs.
"Now the house in Queen Square is virtually a museum. The upper part
is separated from the lower by a massive door which opens from the hall
and gives access to the staircase and which is fitted with a Chubb
night-latch. There are two latch-keys, of which John used to keep one
and I the other. You will find them both in the safe behind me. The
caretaker had no key and no access to the upper part of the house
unless admitted by one of us.
"At the time when I came in, after Doctor Norbury had left, the
caretaker was in the cellar, where I could hear him breaking coke for
the hot-water furnace. I had left John on the third floor opening some
of the packing-cases by the light of a lamp with a tool somewhat like a
plasterer's hammer; that is, a hammer with a small axe-blade at the
reverse of the head. As I stood talking to Doctor Norbury, I could
hear him knocking out the nails and wrenching up the lids; and when I
entered the doorway leading to the stairs, I could still hear him.
Just as I closed the staircase door behind me, I heard a rumbling noise
from above; then all was still.
"I went up the stairs to the second floor, where, as the staircase was
all in darkness, I stopped to light the gas. As I turned to ascend the
next flight, I saw a hand projecting over the edge of the half-way
landing. I ran up the stairs, and there, on the landing, I saw John
lying huddled up in a heap at the foot of the top flight. There was a
wound at the side of his forehead from which a little blood was
trickling. The case-opener lay on the floor close by him and there was
blood on the axe-blade. When I looked up the stairs I saw a rag of
torn matting over the top stair.
"It was quite easy to see what had happened. He had walked quickly out
on the landing with the case-opener in his hand. His foot had caught
in the torn matting and he had pitched head foremost down the stairs
still holding the case-opener. He had fallen so that his head had come
down on the upturned edge of the axe-blade; he had then rolled over and
the case-opener had dropped from his hand.
"I lit a wax match and stooped down to look at him. His head was in a
very peculiar position, which made me suspect that his neck was broken.
There was extremely little bleeding from the wound; he was perfectly
motionless; I could detect no sign of breathing; and I felt no doubt
that he was dead.
"It was an exceedingly regrettable affair, and it placed me, as I
perceived at once, in an extremely awkward position. My first impulse
was to send the caretaker for a doctor and a policeman; but a moment's
reflection convinced me that there were serious objections to this
course.
"There was nothing to show that I had not, myself, knocked him down
with the case-opener. Of course, there was nothing to show that I had;
but we were alone in the house with the exception of the caretaker, who
was down in the basement out of earshot.
"There would be an inquest. At the inquest inquiries would be made as
to the will which was known to exist. But as soon as the will was
produced, Hurst would become suspicious. He would probably make a
statement to the coroner and I should be charged with the murder. Or,
even if I were not charged, Hurst would suspect me and would probably
repudiate the assignment; and, under the circumstances, it would be
practically impossible for me to enforce it. He would refuse to pay
and I could not take my claim into Court.
"I sat down on the stairs just above poor John's body and considered
the matter in detail. At the worst, I stood a fair chance of hanging;
at the best, I stood to lose close upon fifty thousand pounds. These
were not pleasant alternatives.
"Supposing, on the other hand, I concealed the body and gave out that
John had gone to Paris. There was, of course, the risk of discovery,
in which case I should certainly be convicted of the murder. But if no
discovery occurred, I was not only safe from suspicion, but I secured
the fifty thousand pounds. In either case there was considerable risk,
but in one there was the certainty of loss, whereas in the other there
was a material advantage to justify the risk. The question was whether
it would be possible to conceal the body. If it were, then the
contingent profit was worth the slight additional risk. But a human
body is a very difficult thing to dispose of, especially by a person of
so little scientific culture as myself.
"It is curious that I considered this question for a quite considerable
time before the obvious solution presented itself. I turned over at
least a dozen methods of disposing of the body, and rejected them all
as impracticable. Then, suddenly, I remembered the mummy upstairs.
"At first it only occurred to me as a fantastic possibility that I
could conceal the body in the mummy-case. But as I turned over the
idea I began to see that it was really practicable; and not only
practicable but easy; and not only easy but eminently safe. If once
the mummy-case was in the Museum, I was rid of it for ever.
"The circumstances were, as you, sir, have justly observed, singularly
favorable. There would be no hue and cry, no hurry, no anxiety; but
ample time for all the necessary preparations. Then the mummy-case
itself was curiously suitable. Its length was ample, as I knew from
having measured it. It was a cartonnage of rather flexible material
and had an opening behind, secured with a lacing so that it could be
opened without injury. Nothing need be cut but the lacing, which could
be replaced. A little damage might be done in extracting the mummy and
in introducing the deceased; but such cracks as might occur would be of
no importance. For here again Fortune favored me. The whole of the
back of the mummy-case was coated with bitumen, and it would be easy
when once the deceased was safely inside to apply a fresh coat, which
would cover up not only the cracks but also the new lacing.
"After careful consideration, I decided to adopt the plan. I went
downstairs and sent the caretaker on an errand to the Law Courts. Then
I returned and carried the deceased up to one of the third-floor rooms,
where I removed his clothes and laid him out on a long packing-case in
the position in which he would lie in the mummy-case. I folded his
clothes neatly and packed them, with the exception of his boots, in a
suit-case that he had been taking to Paris and which contained nothing
but his nightclothes, toilet articles, and a change of linen. By the
time I had done this and thoroughly washed the oilcloth on the stairs
and landing, the caretaker had returned. I informed him that Mr.
Bellingham had started for Paris and then I went home. The upper part
of the house was, of course, secured by the Chubb lock, but I had
also--_ex abundantia cautelae_--locked the door of the room in which I
had deposited the deceased.
"I had, of course, some knowledge of the methods of embalming, but
principally of those employed by the ancients. Hence, on the following
day, I went to the British Museum library and consulted the most recent
works on the subject; and exceedingly interesting they were, as showing
the remarkable improvements that modern knowledge has effected in this
ancient art. I need not trouble you with details that are familiar to
you. The process that I selected as the simplest for a beginner was
that of formalin injection, and I went straight from the Museum to
purchase the necessary materials. I did not, however, buy an embalming
syringe: the book stated that an ordinary anatomical injecting syringe
would answer the same purpose, and I thought it a more discreet
purchase.
"I fear that I bungled the injection terribly, although I had carefully
studied the plates in a treatise on anatomy--Gray's, I think. However,
if my methods were clumsy, they were quite effectual. I carried out
the process on the evening of the third day; and when I locked up the
house that night, I had the satisfaction of knowing that poor John's
remains were secure from corruption and decay.
"But this was not enough. The great weight of a fresh body as compared
with that of a mummy would be immediately noticed by those who had the
handling of the mummy-case. Moreover, the damp from the body would
quickly ruin the cartonnage and would cause a steamy film on the inside
of the glass case in which it would be exhibited. And this would
probably lead to an examination. Clearly, then, it was necessary that
the remains of the deceased should be thoroughly dried before they were
enclosed in the cartonnage.
"Here my unfortunate deficiency in scientific knowledge was a great
drawback. I had no idea how this result would be achieved and, in the
end, was compelled to consult a taxidermist, to whom I represented that
I wished to collect some small animals and reptiles and rapidly dry
them for convenience of transport. By this person I was advised to
immerse the dead animals in a jar of methylated spirit for a week and
then expose them in a current of warm, dry air.
"But the plan of immersing the remains of the deceased in a jar of
methylated spirit was obviously impracticable. However, I bethought me
that we had in our collection a porphyry sarcophagus, the cavity of
which had been shaped to receive a small mummy in its case. I tried
the deceased in the sarcophagus and found that he just fitted the
cavity loosely. I obtained a few gallons of methylated spirit, which I
poured into the cavity, just covering the body, and then I put on the
lid and luted it down air-tight with putty. I trust I do not weary you
with these particulars?"
"I'll ask you to cut it as short as you can, Mr. Jellicoe," said
Badger. "It has been a long yarn and time is running on."
"For my part," said Thorndyke, "I find these details deeply interesting
and instructive. They fill in the outline that I had drawn by
inference."
"Precisely," said Mr. Jellicoe, "then I will proceed."
"I left the deceased soaking in the spirit for a fortnight and then
took him out, wiped him dry, and laid him on four cane-bottomed chairs
just over the hot-water pipes, and I let a free current of air pass
through the room. The result interested me exceedingly. By the end of
the third day the hands and feet had become quite dry and shriveled and
horny--so that the ring actually dropped off the shrunken finger--the
nose looked like a fold of parchment; and the skin of the body was so
dry and smooth that you could have engrossed a lease on it. For the
first day or two I turned the deceased at intervals so that he should
dry evenly, and then I proceeded to get the case ready. I divided the
lacing and extracted the mummy with great care--with great care as to
the case, I mean; for the mummy suffered some injury in the extraction.
It was very badly embalmed, and so brittle that it broke in several
places while I was getting it out; and when I unrolled it the head
separated and both the arms came off.
"On the sixth day after the removal from the sarcophagus, I took the
bandages that I had removed from Sebek-hotep and very carefully wrapped
the deceased in them, sprinkling powdered myrrh and gum benzoin freely
on the body and between the folds of the wrappings to disguise the
faint odor of the spirit and the formalin that still lingered about the
body. When the wrappings had been applied, the deceased really had a
most workmanlike appearance; he would have looked quite well in a glass
case even without the cartonnage, and I felt almost regretful at having
to put him out of sight for ever.
"It was a difficult business getting him into the case without
assistance, and I cracked the cartonnage badly in several places before
he was safely enclosed. But I got him in at last, and then, when I had
closed up the case with a new lacing, I applied a fresh layer of
bitumen which effectually covered up the cracks and the new cord. A
dusty cloth dabbed over the bitumen when it was dry disguised its
newness, and the cartonnage with its tenant was ready for delivery. I
notified Doctor Norbury of the fact, and five days later he came and
removed it to the Museum.
"Now that the main difficulty was disposed of, I began to consider the
further difficulty to which you, sir, have alluded with such admirable
perspicuity. It was necessary that John Bellingham should make one
more appearance in public before sinking into final oblivion.
"Accordingly, I devised the visit to Hurst's house, which was
calculated to serve two purposes. It created a satisfactory date for
the disappearance, eliminating me from any connection with it, and by
throwing some suspicion on Hurst it would make him more amenable--less
likely to dispute my claim when he learned the provisions of the will.
"The affair was quite simple. I knew that Hurst had changed his
servants since I was last at his house, and I knew his habits. On that
day I took the suitcase to Charing Cross and deposited it in the
cloakroom, called at Hurst's office to make sure that he was there, and
went from thence direct to Cannon Street and caught the train to
Eltham. On arriving at the house, I took the precaution to remove my
spectacles--the only distinctive feature of my exterior--and was duly
shown into the study at my request. As soon as the housemaid had left
the room I quietly let myself out by the French window, which I closed
behind me but could not fasten, went out at the side gate and closed
that also behind me, holding the bolt of the latch back with my
pocket-knife so that I need not slam the gate to shut it.
"The other events of that day, including the dropping of the scarab, I
need not describe, as they are known to you. But I may fitly make a
few remarks on the unfortunate tactical error into which I fell in
respect of the bones. That error arose, as you have doubtless
perceived, from the lawyer's incurable habit of underestimating the
scientific expert. I had no idea mere bones were capable of furnishing
so much information to a man of science.
"The way in which the affair came about was this: the damaged mummy of
Sebek-hotep, perishing gradually by exposure to the air, was not only
an eyesore to me: it was a definite danger. It was the only remaining
link between me and the disappearance. I resolved to be rid of it and
cast about for some means of destroying it. And then, in an evil
moment, the idea of utilizing it occurred to me.
"There was an undoubted danger that the Court might refuse to presume
death after so short an interval; and if the permission should be
postponed, the will might never be administered during my lifetime.
Hence, if these bones of Sebek-hotep could be made to simulate the
remains of the deceased testator, a definite good would be achieved.
But I knew that the entire skeleton could never be mistaken for his.
The deceased had broken his knee-caps and damaged his ankle, injuries
which I assumed would leave some permanent trace. But if a judicious
selection of the bones were deposited in a suitable place, together
with some object clearly identifiable as appertaining to the deceased,
it seemed to me that the difficulty would be met. I need not trouble
you with details. The course which I adopted is known to you with the
attendant circumstances, even the accidental detachment of the right
hand--which broke off as I was packing the arm in my handbag.
Erroneous as that course was, it would have been successful but for the
unforeseen contingency of your being retained in the case.
"Thus, for nearly two years, I remained in complete security. From
time to time I dropped in at the Museum to see if the deceased was
keeping in good condition; and on those occasions I used to reflect
with satisfaction on the gratifying circumstance--accidental though it
was--that his wishes, as expressed (very imperfectly) in clause two,
had been fully complied with, and that without prejudice to my
interests.
"The awakening came on that evening when I saw you at the Temple gate
talking with Doctor Berkeley. I suspected immediately that something
was gone amiss and that it was too late to take any useful action.
Since then, I have waited here in hourly expectation of this visit.
And now the time has come. You have made the winning move and it
remains only for me to pay my debts like an honest gambler."
He paused and quietly lit his cigarette. Inspector Badger yawned and
put away his notebook.
"Have you done, Mr. Jellicoe?" the inspector asked. "I want to carry
out my contract to the letter, you know, though it's getting devilish
late."
Mr. Jellicoe took his cigarette from his mouth and drank a glass of
water.
"I forgot to ask," he said, "whether you unrolled the mummy--if I may
apply the term to the imperfectly treated remains of my deceased
client."
"I did not open the mummy-case," replied Thorndyke.
"You did not!" exclaimed Mr. Jellicoe. "Then how did you verify your
suspicions?"
"I took an X-ray photograph."
"Ah! Indeed!" Mr. Jellicoe pondered for some moments. "Astonishing!"
he murmured; "and most ingenious. The resources of science at the
present day are truly wonderful."
"Is there anything more that you want to say?" asked Badger; "because
if you don't, time's up."
"Anything more?" Mr. Jellicoe repeated slowly; "anything more?
No--I--think--think--the time--is--up. Yes--the--the--time----"
He broke off and sat with a strange look fixed on Thorndyke.
His face had suddenly undergone a curious change. It looked shrunken
and cadaverous and his lips had assumed a peculiar cherry-red color.
"Is anything the matter, Mr. Jellicoe?" Badger asked uneasily. "Are
you not feeling well, sir?"
Mr. Jellicoe did not appear to have heard the question, for he returned
no answer, but sat motionless, leaning back in his chair, with his
hands spread out on the table and his strangely intent gaze bent on
Thorndyke.
Suddenly his head dropped on his breast and his body seemed to
collapse; and as with one accord we sprang to our feet, he slid forward
off his chair and disappeared under the table.
"Good Lord! The man's fainted!" exclaimed Badger. In a moment he was
down on his hands and knees, trembling with excitement, groping under
the table. He dragged the unconscious lawyer out into the light and
knelt over him, staring into his face.
"What's the matter with him, Doctor?" he asked, looking up at
Thorndyke. "Is it apoplexy? Or is it a heart attack, think you?"
Thorndyke shook his head, though he stooped and put his fingers on the
unconscious man's wrist.
"Prussic acid or potassium cyanide is what the appearances suggest," he
replied.
"But can't you do anything?" demanded the inspector.
Thorndyke dropped the arm, which fell limply to the floor.
"You can't do much for a dead man," he said.
"Dead! Then he has slipped through our fingers after all!"
"He has anticipated the sentence. That is all." Thorndyke spoke in an
even, impassive tone which struck me as rather strange, considering the
suddenness of the tragedy, as did also the complete absence of surprize
in his manner. He seemed to treat the occurrence as a perfectly
natural one.
Not so Inspector Badger; who rose to his feet and stood with his hands
thrust into his pockets scowling sullenly down at the dead lawyer.
"I was an infernal fool to agree to his blasted conditions," he growled
savagely.
"Nonsense," said Thorndyke. "If you had broken in you would have found
a dead man. As it was you found a live man and obtained an important
statement. You acted quite properly."
"How do you suppose he managed it?" asked Badger.
Thorndyke held out his hand.
"Let us look at his cigarette case," said he.
Badger extracted the little silver case from the dead man's pocket and
opened it. There were five cigarettes in it, two of which were plain,
while the other three were gold-tipped. Thorndyke took out one of each
kind and gently pinched their ends. The gold-tipped one he returned;
the plain one he tore through, about a quarter of an inch from the end;
when two little black tabloids dropped out on to the table. Badger
eagerly picked one up and was about to smell it when Thorndyke grasped
his wrist. "Be careful," said he; and when he had cautiously sniffed
at the tabloid--held at a safe distance from his nose--he added: "Yes,
potassium cyanide. I thought so when his lips turned that queer color.
It was in that last cigarette; you can see that he has bitten the end
off."
For some time we stood silently looking down at the still form
stretched on the floor. Presently Badger looked up.
"As you pass the porter's lodge on your way out," said he, "you might
just drop in and tell him to send a constable to me."
"Very well," said Thorndyke. "And by the way, Badger, you had better
tip that sherry back into the decanter and put it under lock and key,
or else pour it out of the window."
"Gad, yes!" exclaimed the inspector. "I'm glad you mentioned it. We
might have had an inquest on a constable as well as a lawyer.
Good-night, gentlemen, if you are off."
We went out and left him with his prisoner--passive enough, indeed,
according to his ambiguously worded promise. As we passed through the
gateway Thorndyke gave the inspector's message, curtly and without
comment, to the gaping porter, and then we issued forth into Chancery
Lane.
We were all silent and very grave, and I thought that Thorndyke seemed
somewhat moved. Perhaps Mr. Jellicoe's last intent look--which I
suspect he knew to be the look of a dying man--lingered in his memory
as it did in mine. Half-way down Chancery Lane he spoke for the first
time; and then it was only to ejaculate, "Poor devil!"
Jervis took him up. "He was a consummate villain, Thorndyke."
"Hardly that," was the reply. "I should rather say that he was
non-moral. He acted without malice and without scruple or remorse.
His conduct exhibited a passionateless expediency which was dreadful
because utterly unhuman. But he was a strong man--a courageous,
self-contained man, and I had been better pleased if it could have been
ordained that some other hand than mine should let the axe fall."
Thorndyke's compunction may appear strange and inconsistent, but yet
his feeling was also my own. Great as was the misery and suffering
that this inscrutable man had brought into the lives of those I loved,
I forgave him; and in his downfall forgot the callous relentlessness
with which he had pursued his evil purpose. For it was he who had
brought Ruth into my life; who had opened for me the Paradise of Love
into which I had just entered. And so my thoughts turned away from the
still shape that lay on the floor of the stately old room in Lincoln's
Inn, away to the sunny vista of the future, where I should walk hand in
hand with Ruth until my time, too, should come; until I, too, like the
grim lawyer, should hear the solemn evening bell bidding me put out
into the darkness of the silent sea.