The implication was awful, monstrous, and yet--there it was. Since, as
Janet said, she put the chain on, and since it had been found still on
by Charlotte in the morning, certainly no one could have entered the
apartment during the night by that door. And as the apartment was the
duplicate of our own, I knew there was no other door. There was no rear
entrance, and the dumb-waiter closed with a snap lock on the kitchen
side.
The inspector stated that the windows had evidently been securely
fastened through the night. Those in the sleeping-rooms, which were
partly opened for ventilation, were secured by a burglar-proof device,
which fastened them at any desired point, leaving ample room for air,
but far too small a space for a human being to pass through. Thus the
possibility of an intruder was eliminated, and, granting that, who had
killed Mr. Pembroke?
Logically speaking, it must have been some one already in the apartment,
and the other occupants numbered but two. It didn't seem that it could
have been Charlotte; and my mind refused even a hint of a thought of
Janet in that connection; and yet--who?
As I sat stunned, I vaguely saw that some one had raised Miss Pembroke,
and that Laura had once more taken her in charge.
I looked at the hard, impassive face of the coroner, and, like a flash,
I realized that he believed Janet guilty, and that was why he had
questioned her along the line he did.
He meant to prove first motive and then exclusive opportunity! I, as a
lawyer, followed the workings of his mind, and understood at last his
rigorous catechism of the poor girl.
Janet guilty! Why, it was simply a contradiction of terms. That girl was
no more capable of---- Then I remembered her manner that had so puzzled
me. But that she could explain, of course. As to exclusive opportunity,
that was mere foolishness. I remembered the chained door, but of course
there must have been other ways of ingress to a professional burglar. I
hastily thought over the windows of our own apartment. There were three
large front ones on Sixty-second Street, and the others were all on
air-shafts or a fire-escape.
Ah, that was it--the fire-escape!
Then I remembered the inspector's statement. Had there been a possible
way to get in that house that night, surely he would have found it. That
would not require very clever detective work.
Suddenly a thought struck me, which turned my heart to ice. It was I who
had first testified that the chain was on the door when Charlotte opened
it that morning! If I had not mentioned it, perhaps no one would have
thought of it, and it would have been assumed that the criminal forced
his way in at the front door.
That would have left a loophole for doubt. Now they said there was none.
Oh, how could I have been so stupid as to tell of that chain? I who
desired only to serve and assist the woman I loved--I had done the one
thing, said the one word, that gave those men reason to say she had
"exclusive opportunity"!
That, then, was why Doctor Masterson had looked so perturbed at my
testimony. That was why he was worried and nervous at Charlotte's
mention of the chain. That was why he looked relieved when Laura
completed her account without referring to that awful bit of evidence.
And why didn't Laura refer to it? Perhaps she thought it would be a
point which couldn't be explained, which was as inexplicable to her as
to me, but which no more proved Miss Pembroke guilty than it proved the
angels in heaven to be criminals.
Janet had regained consciousness, but still lay on the couch, with
closed eyes, and the inexorable coroner called George Lawrence.
The young man seemed to be controlling himself by a mighty effort.
"I see your implication," he said to the coroner, "and I want you to
retract it. My cousin, Miss Pembroke, is incapable of such a thing as
you hint, and the mere fact of a chained front door does not preclude
other modes of housebreaking. I am by no means sure the windows were all
securely fastened last night. Indeed, I am forced to believe they were
not, since somebody came in and killed my uncle, and it was not my
cousin Janet."
"There has been no accusation," said the coroner coldly. "Will you now
give us your testimony?"
"I can tell you nothing to throw any light on the mystery," said George
Lawrence, who was, apparently, holding himself well in hand. "I called
here yesterday afternoon between five and six. My uncle was very cross
and grumpy, and gave me no pleasant word while I was here. He was not
at that time definitely angry, but merely testy and irritable. I talked
for a time with Janet, and went away about six.
"Where did you go then?"
"I went back to my own apartment in Washington Square."
"And then?"
"I dressed, and went to dine with some friends in Sixtieth street. Of
course this can be verified."
Lawrence spoke with an air of superciliousness, almost contempt, at this
detailed questioning, but the Coroner looked at him impassively.
"We are not doubting your word," he said; "you spent the evening at the
house where you dined?"
"Yes; I left there at eleven o'clock, and then I went directly home. I
reached my apartment at eleven twenty-five."
"How do you know the time so exactly?"
"I happen to be sure of the hour, because the hall boy told me the time
by the office clock. He then took me up in the elevator, and I went at
once to my rooms. I slept all night, and had not yet left my bedroom
when my cousin telephoned for me this morning. That is my story, and, as
I said, it throws no light on the case. But light shall be thrown on
the case, if I have to move heaven and earth to have it thrown. This
mystery shall be solved and my cousin freed from the slightest taint of
this absurd suspicion!"
I had liked George Lawrence from the first, and this outburst of loyalty
to his cousin quite won my heart. It was no more than he ought to have
felt, but his spontaneous enthusiasm charmed me. I determined to add my
efforts to his own, and it would go hard if between us we did not bring
the evil-doer to justice.
I admired the appearance of the young man. Of an athletic type, though
perhaps not specially trained, he was well set up, and had that assured
air that belongs to so many young New York men.
He especially exhibited self-possession and self-control, and though
perhaps he gave more the effect of physical force than of mental
strength, yet to my mind he showed bravery and courage both in manner
and speech.
Though in no way conspicuous, his clothes were correct, and hung well on
his rather graceful figure. Although I had heard he was an artist, he
showed no trace of Bohemianism in his make-up. He was rather, it seemed
to me, of the type that frequents our best clubs or restaurants.
But what I liked best about the man was his very evident affection and
loyalty toward his cousin. As the coroner had said, there had been no
definite accusation, and yet it was plain to be seen that as the
evidence seemed to point toward either the guilt or the complicity of
Janet Pembroke, the jurymen were being influenced by it.
The coroner asked George more questions.
"You carry a latch-key to this apartment?" he asked.
"Yes. I lived here until a few months ago, and I've still kept the key.
I go in and out as I like. The chain is never put on in the daytime."
"Is it always on at night?"
"Yes. When I lived here I was usually the last one in at night, and I
put on the chain. Since I left, my cousin has told me that she always
puts it on when she retires at night."
"You did not get on well with your uncle?"
"I did not. It was because of his bad temper that I went away to live by
myself. I hoped, too, that if I were not here to anger him, which I
often did, he might be more gentle to Janet."
"Did it turn out that way?"
"I fear not, to any considerable extent. I think he could not control
his temper, even if he tried, and it was his custom to vent his wrath on
whomever happened to be nearest."
"You also knew of the conditions of your uncle's will?"
"Yes. It was no secret. He had always told us we two were his sole
heirs, but, though he seemed willing to leave us his money, he was not
generous with it while alive."
"What is your business, Mr. Lawrence?"
"I am an artist--or, at least, an illustrator. I make pictures for books
and magazines."
"You find it lucrative?"
"Sufficiently so. My tastes are not extravagant, and I earn enough by my
work to gratify my simple ambitions. I trust I shall make a worthy use
of my inheritance, but I had hoped not to come into it for many years
yet."
This last remark jarred on me. I didn't want to think the young man
hypocritical, and yet that attitude as to his inheritance seemed to me
not quite ingenuous.
"Did Robert Pembroke have any enemy that you know of?"
"Not that I know of definitely, and none that I would suspect of crime.
But I know very little of my uncle's business affairs or his
acquaintances. He was not at all communicative, and I was not curious
about such matters."
"He had callers occasionally?"
"Yes."
"Of what sort?"
"Business men, his lawyer, various agents who transacted business for
him, and sometimes strangers who came to ask contributions for
charitable purposes, or perhaps to interest him in financial schemes."
"He always saw these visitors?"
"Yes; Mr. Pembroke was always ready to see any one who called. I
suppose, as he never went out, it provided diversion and entertainment
for him."
"He always treated them politely?"
"Perhaps not that, but he was decent to them. However, he frequently
used them as targets for his ill temper."
"They resented this?"
"That depended on their errand. If they were asking favors, they were
naturally more patient than if they were there to transact my uncle's
business."
"Your uncle also vented his ill-temper on his servants, I understand?"
"He certainly did. No servant ever staid very long in his employ."
"Can you think of any servant who has lived with him who might be
implicated in this crime?"
George Lawrence paused, and seemed to be thinking over the line of
servants who had come and gone. At last he shook his head; "Not
definitely," he said. "I don't remember them individually. But there
were several who were so badly treated by my uncle that it would not be
surprising if they had held revengeful thoughts toward him. However, I
could not go so far as to accuse any one of them."
"And you can't throw any light on these various articles collected from
Mr. Pembroke's bedroom, and which we hope will prove to be clues to the
discovery of the criminal."
Although the Coroner's words were straightforward enough, the glance he
cast on the various articles I had laid before him, proved that he had
little serious hope of assistance from them.
George Lawrence was even more plainly of an opinion that they were
valueless. He glanced at them with an air of utter indifference, saying:
"I really know nothing of them, I assure you."
"You have no idea who is the J. S. who signed his initials to this
telegram?"
To my surprise, and I doubt not, also to the surprise of all present,
George Lawrence turned to his cousin and smiled. It was a flashing
smile, as if caused by a humorous thought, and it seemed so out of key
with the proceedings, that it jarred on my sense of the fitness of
things.
But I was even more surprised when Miss Pembroke flashed back an
answering smile, showing entire comprehension of her cousin's meaning.
"You know something of the matter," affirmed the coroner, looking a
little annoyed at the attitude of his witness.
"I am not sure that I do," said Lawrence, "but I will tell you what is
in my mind. For many years my uncle lived in fear of a personage whom he
called J. S. Though rarely in humorous mood, my uncle would sometimes
make jesting references to this J. S., as if he were in fear of him.
When we asked him what name the initials stood for, he told us John
Strong, but told us in such a way that he gave us clearly to understand
that was not the real name of J. S. And so we came to look upon John
Strong as a sort of mythical personage, and as the only one of whom my
uncle was afraid. He has sometimes said to us, 'J. S. will catch me yet,
if I'm not careful,' or, 'J. S. must never know of this.' It is our
opinion, though uncorroborated by any known facts, that this man was
once a partner of my uncle in business."
"A long time ago?"
"Yes; many years ago. These matters should be explained to you by my
uncle's lawyer, but since he is not here, I will tell you what I know of
this thing, though it is not much. As nearly as I could piece it
together from the few hints my uncle let fall, I gathered that he and
this J. S. bought a cotton plantation together, many years ago. At first
the investment was unsuccessful. Then my uncle bought out John Strong's
share, and after that the property became exceedingly valuable. I am
perfectly sure my uncle dealt justly by his partner so far as the
legality of the transaction was concerned. But John Strong seemed to
think that my uncle was under a sort of moral obligation to give him a
portion of the later profits. Now this is all I know about it, and I am
not sure that these details are quite accurate. But I do know that the
partner's name was not really John Strong, and that my uncle used that
name because the man had a strong hold over him in some way."
"But you think the partner's initials were J. S.?"
"I think so, yes; but I am not sure."
"You have never seen the man?"
"Not to my knowledge. My uncle often had callers who were strangers to
my cousin and myself."
"This matter seems to me to be important," said the Coroner, looking
again at the telegram which was signed J. S.; "This message is dated
yesterday and advised Mr. Pembroke to 'expect J. S. tonight,' that is,
last evening. It certainly must be looked into."
"It certainly should," agreed George Lawrence. "When you have as
evidence a telegram from a man known to be an enemy, it seems as if it
ought to be investigated."
"But, on the other hand," went on the Coroner, looking very serious, "we
know that this J. S. did not come last evening, in accordance with his
announcement. We have Miss Pembroke's evidence, in addition to that of
the servant, that there was no caller here last evening. Then after Miss
Pembroke put the night-chain on the door and retired, there was no
possibility of the entrance of an intruder. Therefore, we are bound to
conclude that J. S. did not keep his engagement with Mr. Pembroke,--if
indeed this is a genuine message from him."
At this remark of the Coroner's I looked aghast. He had practically cast
a doubt on the genuineness of the telegram, and this implied that it was
manufactured evidence, and so pointed to deeper and more complicated
villainy than the crime itself. Moreover Mr. Ross's face expressed
incredulity at the whole story of the mythical John Strong.
I was indignant at this, for the very frankness with which Lawrence told
the story, the unmistakable approval and agreement of Janet in all that
he said, and the slightly amused air of both of them all seemed to me to
prove that the John Strong episode, whether important or not, whether
for or against the cause I had espoused, was at least a true story, and
honestly set forth.
But there was no doubt that the Coroner, the Inspector, and the Jurymen,
took views entirely opposite to my own.
"I have heard your story, Mr. Lawrence," Mr. Ross said, calmly, "and the
jurors have heard it It is recommended to their thoughtful
consideration. The telegram signed J. S., may or may not be from this
person whom you call John Strong, but whose name you say is something
different. However as this person did not call last evening before Miss
Pembroke put the chain on the front door, and as he could not have
entered this apartment afterward, I cannot feel that we should attach
great importance to this message. The evidence given goes to prove that
the crime must have been committed after eleven o'clock last night, and,
in the opinion of the doctors, by or before midnight. This narrows the
time down to a very definite hour, and we see that the deed must have
taken place shortly after Miss Pembroke had retired for the night."
George Lawrence was then excused from the witness stand, the inquest was
closed, and the jurors dismissed to consider their verdict.
X