OF THE INFLUENCE OF THE DEATH OF THE HEART AS TO THE PRODUCTION OF
GENERAL DEATH.
Whenever the heart ceases to act, general death is produced in
the following manner:--1st. For want of excitement the cerebral
actions are annihilated, and consequently an end is immediately put
to all sensation, locomotion, and utterance. Besides, for want of
excitement on the part of the blood, the organs of these functions
would cease to act, even supposing that the brain were to remain
unaffected, and exert upon them its accustomed influence. Thus the
whole of the animal life is suddenly suspended, and at the instant
of the death of the heart, the individual is dead to what surrounds
him.
The interruption of the organic life, which has commenced by the
death of the heart, is produced at the same time by that of the
lungs. The brain being dead, the mechanical functions of the lungs
must cease: the chemical functions of the lungs must cease also,
for want of the materials on which they are exerted: the latter are
directly interrupted, the former through the medium of the brain.
After this the progress of death is gradual. The secretions, the
exhalations, the nutritive actions are put an end to. The latter
are first arrested in those organs which receive the more immediate
impulse of the blood, because in these, such impulse is necessary
to the performance of the functions. The paler organs are less
dependent on the influence of the heart, and consequently must be
less affected by the cessation of its action.[73]
In the successive termination of the latter phenomena of the
internal life, the vital powers continue to subsist for some time
after the loss of the functions: thus, the organic sensibility, and
the sensible and insensible contractilities survive the phenomena
of digestion, secretion, and nutrition.[74]
The vital powers continue to subsist in the internal life, even
when the corresponding powers of the animal life, have suddenly
become extinct: the reason is plain: the power of perceiving and
moving organically does not suppose the existence of a common
centre; for the animal perceptions and motions, the action of the
brain is requisite.
The phenomena of death are concatenated in the above order in all
aneurismal ruptures, in all wounds of the heart or larger vessels,
in all cases of polypi formed in the cardiac cavities,[75] of
ligature artificially applied, of compression exercised on the
parietes of the heart by humours, abscesses, &c. &c.
It is in this manner also that we die from sudden affections of the
mind. The news of a very joyful, or a very melancholy event, the
sight of a fearful object, of a detested enemy, of a successful
rival, are all of them causes capable of producing death. Now in
all these instances, it is the heart, which is the first to die,
the heart, whose death successively produces that of all the other
organs, the heart, on which the passion is exerted.
And hence we are led to some considerations on syncope, an
affection exemplifying in a less degree the same phenomena, which
in a greater one, is offered us in cases of sudden death.
The causes of syncope are referred by Cullen to two general heads:
Of these there is one set which according to him affect the brain,
another set which affect the heart. Among the first, he places the
more violent impulses on the mind, and various evacuations, but
it is easy to prove, that the brain is only secondarily affected
in syncope produced by passion, and that it is the heart, whose
functions in all these cases are the first to be interrupted. The
following considerations, if I am not mistaken, will leave but
little doubt on this head.
1st.--I have proved, in speaking of the passions, that they never
affect the brain in the first place; that the action of this
organ, in consequence of their development, is only secondary, and
that every thing relating to our moral affections has its seat
exclusively in the organic life.
2dly.--The phenomena of syncope when produced by lively emotion,
are similar in every respect to those of syncope, the effect
of polypi or dropsy of the pericardium, but in the latter,
the affection of the heart is the primary one, and should in
consequence be the same in the former sort of syncope.
3dly.--At the moment when syncope takes place, we feel the attack
at the heart, and not in the brain.
4thly.--In consequence of lively passions, which may have
occasioned syncope, we find that the heart and not the brain
becomes diseased, nothing is more common than organic affections
of the former from sorrow, &c. The different sorts of madness,
which are produced by the same cause, for the most part have
their principal seat in some of the viscera of the epigastrium,
and in such case, the irregularity of the cerebral action is the
sympathetic effect of the profound affection of the internal
organ.[76]
5thly.--I shall prove hereafter, that the cerebral system does not
exert any direct influence over that of the circulation; that there
is no reciprocity between the two, and that the changes of the
first are not followed by similar changes in the second, however
much the changes of the second may modify the first. Destroy all
nervous communication between the brain and the heart, and the
circulation will go on as usual; but if the vascular communications
be intercepted, the cerebral action vanishes at once.
6thly.--Palpitations and other irregular movements of the heart are
often the effect of the same causes, which in some individuals are
the occasion of syncope. In such cases, it is easy to discover the
seat of the affection, and such smaller effects of the passions on
the heart, are very well calculated to throw light upon the nature
of the greater.[77]
From these many considerations, we may conclude that the primitive
seat of the attack in syncope, is the heart, which does not cease
to act, because the action of the brain has been interrupted, but
because it is the nature of some of the passions in such way to
affect it, the brain at the same time, suffering a temporary death,
because it no longer receives the fluid, which is necessary to its
excitement. The nature of syncope is well enough illustrated, by
the vulgar expression of being sick at heart.
It is of no importance to our present purpose, whether syncope
depend on polypi, on aneurism, or be the result of some violent
emotion. The successive affection of the organs is always the same.
They die for the moment in the same way, as they really perish when
the heart is wounded, or a ligature put upon the aorta. In the same
manner also are those sorts of syncope produced, which succeed
after any great evacuation of blood, pus or water. The heart is
affected from sympathy, the brain for want of its excitant.[78]
Those cases of syncope which are occasioned by peculiar odours,
by antipathies, &c. appear also to be attended with the same
progression of symptoms, though their character be much less easily
understood. There is a great difference between syncope, asphyxia,
and apoplexy, in the first it is by the heart, in the second by the
lungs, in the third by the brain that begins the general death of
the body.
Death, as it happens in consequence of disease, in general
exemplifies a concatenation of these different symptoms. The
circulation, respiration, or cerebral action cease, the other
functions are afterwards interrupted of necessity, but in these
sorts of death, it rarely happens that the heart is the first to
die. This however is sometimes the case. After long continued
suffering, great suppuration, and sometimes, in dropsy, certain
fevers, and gangrenes, one fit of syncope comes on after another,
at last a longer one succeeds, and the patient dies, but whatever
be the part affected, whatever the diseased viscus or organ,
whenever the phenomena of death commence by the heart, they succeed
each other as we have described them to do in sudden death, from
lesion of that organ. In other cases, the heart is the last to act,
is the ultimum moriens.
In general, in morbid affections, we much more commonly observe the
ingress of death to be made by the lungs, than either by the heart,
or the brain.
Whenever disease is terminated by syncope, the lungs are found to
be almost empty, and if not affected by any organic disease, are
collapsed, occupy a part only of the cavity of the thorax, and are
of their natural colour.
The reason of this anatomical fact is simple. The circulation
which has been suddenly interrupted, has not had time to fill the
vessels of the lungs, as happens when death begins, by affecting
the lungs or the brain. The truth of this fact I can vouch for,
having frequently ascertained it by dissection, and in general, as
often as death commences by the heart, or the larger vessels, such
vacuity of the lungs may be considered as universal.
I have remarked it in the bodies of persons who have died from
great hemorrhage from wounds or aneurismal rupture and violent
passion, as well as in those who have suffered by the guillotine.
The same phenomenon may be seen, by inspecting the lungs of any
animal, which is killed in our butcheries.
In killing the animal slowly by the lungs, that organ might be
filled with blood. Its taste would then be different from that
which it naturally possesses, and resemble that of the spleen. Our
cooks know well how to take advantage of that state of infiltration
in which the latter viscus is generally found.
FOOTNOTES:
[73] Life is so obscure in the tendons, ligaments, &c. that it is
impossible to fix the moment when it ceases in these parts. How
then has Bichat been able to compare the quickness of their death
with that of the other organs? Upon what data has he been able to
determine that it takes place more slowly?
[74] The secretion of mucus, the growth of the nails, the beard and
the hair often continue on the dead body long after the last traces
of irritability have disappeared in the muscles of locomotion, in
the fleshy coats of the intestines, &c.
[75] Since more care has been taken in examining the lesions of
different organs in post mortem examinations, there is no longer
found those fatty polypi, which were formerly considered as
causes of death. It is probable that those yellowish concretions
of albuminous matter which are found between the pillars of the
auricle, and which seem to be fixed there, were mistaken for
polypi. There is sometimes found in individuals formerly affected
with the venereal disease, vegetations near the valves; but these
productions are commonly too trifling to oppose the expulsion of
the blood contained in the cavity.
[76] The singular idea of placing the seat of madness in the
viscera of the abdomen, arose at a period when a certain number
of mystical ideas formed the basis of all physiology. The four
sorts of humours performed in the human body (_microcosm_)
a part as important as the four elements did in the whole
universe (_macrocosm_). The bile, the blood, the pituitary and
atrabiliary fluids determined, by their predominance the different
temperaments, and produced the different diseases. The atrabiliary
humour was, as is well known, thought to be the cause of melancholy
and mania; now this humour was said to be secreted by the
supra-renal capsules, and the position of these organs no doubt
gave the name of hypochondria, which is given to a certain degree
of mental alienation.
After a great number of ages, the mysterious properties of numbers
are almost entirely out of favour. We still speak of the four
temperaments, but attach no importance to the four ages of man or
to the four parts of the day. We recognize in the human body more
than four kinds of fluids, but among them all we do not find the
atrabiliary fluid. The cause of madness then cannot be attributed
to this humour, and yet we dare not drive this disease from the
seat it has so long held. In order to find reasons for keeping
it there, they seek in the viscera for disorders which are not
often found there even in the most striking cases, and which most
often still exist without the least alteration in the intellectual
functions.
[77] We should be often exposed to commit great mistakes, if we
always judged by this rule. The sensation is a very uncertain
means of determining the organ that is primarily affected; this
can be proved by numerous examples, we shall cite one only which
relates to the brain. Nausea and vomiting are often, as is well
known, among the first symptoms of cerebral affections; should we
from this believe that the seat of the disease is in the stomach?
Undoubtedly not: now, in syncope produced by a strong affection of
the mind, there is no reason to suppose that the heart is affected
before the brain, since the intellectual phenomena have necessarily
preceded the sensation of joy or of sorrow which has produced the
syncope. But to say that the brain was primarily affected, is not
saying that its action ceased before that of the heart; and every
thing, on the contrary, leads to the belief that the loss of the
senses is a consequence of the suspension of the circulation.
[78] The syncope is produced in this case, from the sudden change
in the circulation of the brain. But this change varies according
to the seat of the effusion. If it be in the peritoneal cavity,
the pressure that it makes interrupts the circulation in all the
organs contained in the abdomen; the descending aorta is found
compressed, and the blood, forced back towards the superior parts,
accumulates in the sinuses and vessels of the brain. If the fluid
be evacuated by puncture, the equilibrium is re-established in the
different parts of the vascular system, the blood enters vessels
which were before closed to it, it abandons in part those of the
brain, and it is this sudden change in the circulation of the organ
which produces syncope. If, on the contrary, the effusion be formed
between the two layers of the arachnoides, and we can, as in spina
bifida, evacuate the fluid by puncture, the vessels of the brain
are immediately relieved of the pressure to which they had been
subjected, and the blood, which before was forced back, towards the
inferior parts, is driven forcibly into them; the change is, as
must be perceived, the reverse of the preceding; but the result is
the same, and syncope is produced in this case as in the other.