Eve's grief at last burst forth in that cry of protest. She

Produced by Dagny, and David Widger. HTML version by Al Haines.

THE THREE CITIES

PARIS

BY

EMILE ZOLA

TRANSLATED BY ERNEST A. VIZETELLY

BOOK III

I

THE RIVALS

ON the Wednesday preceding the mid-Lent Thursday, a great charity bazaar

was held at the Duvillard mansion, for the benefit of the Asylum of the

Invalids of Labour. The ground-floor reception rooms, three spacious

Louis Seize _salons_, whose windows overlooked the bare and solemn

courtyard, were given up to the swarm of purchasers, five thousand

admission cards having been distributed among all sections of Parisian

society. And the opening of the bombarded mansion in this wise to

thousands of visitors was regarded as quite an event, a real

manifestation, although some people whispered that the Rue

Godot-de-Mauroy and the adjacent streets were guarded by quite an army of

police agents.

The idea of the bazaar had come from Duvillard himself, and at his

bidding his wife had resigned herself to all this worry for the benefit

of the enterprise over which she presided with such distinguished

nonchalance. On the previous day the "Globe" newspaper, inspired by its

director Fonsegue, who was also the general manager of the asylum, had

published a very fine article, announcing the bazaar, and pointing out

how noble, and touching, and generous was the initiative of the Baroness,

who still gave her time, her money, and even her home to charity, in

spite of the abominable crime which had almost reduced that home to

ashes. Was not this the magnanimous answer of the spheres above to the

hateful passions of the spheres below? And was it not also a peremptory

answer to those who accused the capitalists of doing nothing for the

wage-earners, the disabled and broken-down sons of toil?

The drawing-room doors were to be opened at two o'clock, and would only

close at seven, so that there would be five full hours for the sales. And

at noon, when nothing was as yet ready downstairs, when workmen and women

were still decorating the stalls, and sorting the goods amidst a final

scramble, there was, as usual, a little friendly _dejeuner_, to which a

few guests had been invited, in the private rooms on the first floor.

However, a scarcely expected incident had given a finishing touch to the

general excitement of the house: that very morning Sagnier had resumed

his campaign of denunciation in the matter of the African Railway Lines.

In a virulent article in the "Voix du Peuple," he had inquired if it were

the intention of the authorities to beguile the public much longer with

the story of that bomb and that Anarchist whom the police did not arrest.

And this time, while undertaking to publish the names of the thirty-two

corrupt senators and deputies in a very early issue, he had boldly named

Minister Barroux as one who had pocketed a sum of 200,000 francs. Mege

would therefore certainly revive his interpellation, which might become

dangerous, now that Paris had been thrown into such a distracted state by

terror of the Anarchists. At the same time it was said that Vignon and

his party had resolved to turn circumstances to account, with the object

of overthrowing the ministry. Thus a redoubtable crisis was inevitably at

hand. Fortunately, the Chamber did not meet that Wednesday; in fact, it

had adjourned until the Friday, with the view of making mid-Lent a

holiday. And so forty-eight hours were left one to prepare for the

onslaught.

Eve, that morning, seemed more gentle and languid than ever, rather pale

too, with an expression of sorrowful anxiety in the depths of her

beautiful eyes. She set it all down to the very great fatigue which the

preparations for the bazaar had entailed on her. But the truth was that

Gerard de Quinsac, after shunning any further assignation, had for five

days past avoided her in an embarrassed way. Still she was convinced that

she would see him that morning, and so she had again ventured to wear the

white silk gown which made her look so much younger than she really was.

At the same time, beautiful as she had remained, with her delicate skin,

superb figure and noble and charming countenance, her six and forty years

were asserting themselves in her blotchy complexion and the little

creases which were appearing about her lips, eyelids and temples.

Camille, for her part, though her position as daughter of the house made

it certain that she would attract much custom as a saleswoman, had

obstinately persisted in wearing one of her usual dresses, a dark

"carmelite" gown, an old woman's frock, as she herself called it with a

cutting laugh. However, her long and wicked-looking face beamed with some

secret delight; such an expression of wit and intelligence wreathing her

thin lips and shining in her big eyes that one lost sight of her

deformity and thought her almost pretty.

Eve experienced a first deception in the little blue and silver

sitting-room, where, accompanied by her daughter, she awaited the arrival

of her guests. General de Bozonnet, whom Gerard was to have brought with

him, came in alone, explaining that Madame de Quinsac had felt rather

poorly that morning, and that Gerard, like a good and dutiful son, had

wished to remain with her. Still he would come to the bazaar directly

after _dejeuner_. While the Baroness listened to the General, striving to

hide her disappointment and her fear that she would now be unable to

obtain any explanation from Gerard that day, Camille looked at her with

eager, devouring eyes. And a certain covert instinct of the misfortune

threatening her must at that moment have come to Eve, for in her turn she

glanced at her daughter and turned pale as if with anxiety.

Then Princess Rosemonde de Harn swept in like a whirlwind. She also was

to be one of the saleswomen at the stall chosen by the Baroness, who

liked her for her very turbulence, the sudden gaiety which she generally

brought with her. Gowned in fire-hued satin (red shot with yellow),

looking very eccentric with her curly hair and thin boyish figure, she

laughed and talked of an accident by which her carriage had almost been

cut in halves. Then, as Baron Duvillard and Hyacinthe came in from their

rooms, late as usual, she took possession of the young man and scolded

him, for on the previous evening she had vainly waited for him till ten

o'clock in the expectation that he would keep his promise to escort her

to a tavern at Montmartre, where some horrible things were said to occur.

Hyacinthe, looking very bored, quietly replied that he had been detained

at a seance given by some adepts in the New Magic, in the course of which

the soul of St. Theresa had descended from heaven to recite a love

sonnet.

However, Fonsegue was now coming in with his wife, a tall, thin, silent

and generally insignificant woman, whom he seldom took about with him. On

this occasion he had been obliged to bring her, as she was one of the

lady-patronesses of the asylum, and he himself was coming to lunch with

the Duvillards in his capacity as general manager. To the superficial

observer he looked quite as gay as usual; but he blinked nervously, and

his first glance was a questioning one in the direction of Duvillard, as

if he wished to know how the latter bore the fresh thrust directed at him

by Sagnier. And when he saw the banker looking perfectly composed, as

superb, as rubicund as usual, and chatting in a bantering way with

Rosemonde, he also put on an easy air, like a gamester who had never lost

but had always known how to compel good luck, even in hours of treachery.

And by way of showing his unconstraint of mind he at once addressed the

Baroness on managerial matters: "Have you now succeeded in seeing M.

l'Abbe Froment for the affair of that old man Laveuve, whom he so warmly

recommended to us? All the formalities have been gone through, you know,

and he can be brought to us at once, as we have had a bed vacant for

three days past."

"Yes, I know," replied Eve; "but I can't imagine what has become of Abbe

Froment, for he hasn't given us a sign of life for a month past. However,

I made up my mind to write to him yesterday, and beg him to come to the

bazaar to-day. In this manner I shall be able to acquaint him with the

good news myself."

"It was to leave you the pleasure of doing so," said Fonsegue, "that I

refrained from sending him any official communication. He's a charming

priest, is he not?"

"Oh! charming, we are very fond of him."

However, Duvillard now intervened to say that they need not wait for

Duthil, as he had received a telegram from him stating that he was

detained by sudden business. At this Fonsegue's anxiety returned, and he

once more questioned the Baron with his eyes. Duvillard smiled, however,

and reassured him in an undertone: "It's nothing serious. Merely a

commission for me, about which he'll only be able to bring me an answer

by-and-by." Then, taking Fonsegue on one side, he added: "By the way,

don't forget to insert the paragraph I told you of."

"What paragraph? Oh! yes, the one about that _soiree_ at which Silviane

recited a piece of verse. Well, I wanted to speak to you about it. It

worries me a little, on account of the excessive praise it contains."

Duvillard, but a moment before so full of serenity, with his lofty,

conquering, disdainful mien, now suddenly became pale and agitated. "But

I absolutely want it to be inserted, my dear fellow! You would place me

in the greatest embarrassment if it were not to appear, for I promised

Silviane that it should."

As he spoke his lips trembled, and a scared look came into his eyes,

plainly revealing his dismay.

"All right, all right," said Fonsegue, secretly amused, and well pleased

at this complicity. "As it's so serious the paragraph shall go in, I

promise you."

The whole company was now present, since neither Gerard nor Duthil was to

be expected. So they went into the dining-room amidst a final noise of

hammering in the sale-rooms below. The meal proved somewhat of a

scramble, and was on three occasions disturbed by female attendants, who

came to explain difficulties and ask for orders. Doors were constantly

slamming, and the very walls seemed to shake with the unusual bustle

which filled the house. And feverish as they all were in the dining-room,

they talked in desultory, haphazard fashion on all sorts of subjects,

passing from a ball given at the Ministry of the Interior on the previous

night, to the popular mid-Lent festival which would take place on the

morrow, and ever reverting to the bazaar, the prices that had been given

for the goods which would be on sale, the prices at which they might be

sold, and the probable figure of the full receipts, all this being

interspersed with strange anecdotes, witticisms and bursts of laughter.

On the General mentioning magistrate Amadieu, Eve declared that she no

longer dared to invite him to _dejeuner_, knowing how busy he was at the

Palace of Justice. Still, she certainly hoped that he would come to the

bazaar and contribute something. Then Fonsegue amused himself with

teasing Princess Rosemonde about her fire-hued gown, in which, said he,

she must already feel roasted by the flames of hell; a suggestion which

secretly delighted her, as Satanism had now become her momentary passion.

Meantime, Duvillard lavished the most gallant politeness on that silent

creature, Madame Fonsegue, while Hyacinthe, in order to astonish even the

Princess, explained in a few words how the New Magic could transform a

chaste young man into a real angel. And Camille, who seemed very happy

and very excited, from time to time darted a hot glance at her mother,

whose anxiety and sadness increased as she found the other more and more

aggressive, and apparently resolved upon open and merciless warfare.

At last, just as the dessert was coming to an end, the Baroness heard her

daughter exclaim in a piercing, defiant voice: "Oh! don't talk to me of

the old ladies who still seem to be playing with dolls, and paint

themselves, and dress as if they were about to be confirmed! All such

ogresses ought to retire from the scene! I hold them in horror!"

At this, Eve nervously rose from her seat, and exclaimed apologetically:

"You must forgive me for hurrying you like this. But I'm afraid that we

shan't have time to drink our coffee in peace."

The coffee was served in the little blue and silver sitting-room, where

bloomed some lovely yellow roses, testifying to the Baroness's keen

passion for flowers, which made the house an abode of perpetual spring.

Duvillard and Fonsegue, however, carrying their cups of steaming coffee

with them, at once went into the former's private room to smoke a cigar

there and chat in freedom. As the door remained wide open, one could

hear their gruff voices more or less distinctly. Meantime, General de

Bozonnet, delighted to find in Madame Fonsegue a serious, submissive

person, who listened without interrupting, began to tell her a very long

story of an officer's wife who had followed her husband through every

battle of the war of 1870. Then Hyacinthe, who took no

coffee--contemptuously declaring it to be a beverage only fit for

door-keepers--managed to rid himself of Rosemonde, who was sipping some

kummel, in order to come and whisper to his sister: "I say, it was very

stupid ofyou to taunt mamma in the way you did just now. I don't care

a rap about it myself. But it ends by being noticed, and, I warn you

candidly, it shows ill breeding."

Camille gazed at him fixedly with her black eyes. "Pray don't _you_

meddle with my affairs," said she.

At this he felt frightened, scented a storm, and decided to take

Rosemonde into the adjoining red drawing-room in order to show her a

picture which his father had just purchased. And the General, on being

called by him, likewise conducted Madame Fonsegue thither.

The mother and daughter then suddenly found themselves alone and face to

face. Eve was leaning on a pier-table, as if overcome; and indeed, the

least sorrow bore her down, so weak at heart she was, ever ready to weep

in her naive and perfect egotism. Why was it that her daughter thus hated

her, and did her utmost to disturb that last happy spell of love in which

her heart lingered? She looked at Camille, grieved rather than irritated;

and the unfortunate idea came to her of making a remark about her dress

at the very moment when the girl was on the point of following the others

into the larger drawing-room.

"It's quite wrong of you, my dear," said she, "to persist in dressing

like an old woman. It doesn't improve you a bit."

As Eve spoke, her soft eyes, those of a courted and worshipped handsome

woman, clearly expressed the compassion she felt for that ugly, deformed

girl, whom she had never been able to regard as a daughter. Was it

possible that she, with her sovereign beauty, that beauty which she

herself had ever adored and nursed, making it her one care, her one

religion--was it possible that she had given birth to such a graceless

creature, with a dark, goatish profile, one shoulder higher than the

other, and a pair of endless arms such as hunchbacks often have? All her

grief and all her shame at having had such a child became apparent in the

quivering of her voice.

Camille, however, had stopped short, as if struck in the face with a

whip. Then she came back to her mother and the horrible explanation began

with these simple words spoken in an undertone: "You consider that I

dress badly? Well, you ought to have paid some attention to me, have seen

that my gowns suited your taste, and have taught me your secret of

looking beautiful!"

Eve, with her dislike of all painful feeling, all quarrelling and bitter

words, was already regretting her attack. So she sought to make a

retreat, particularly as time was flying and they would soon be expected

downstairs: "Come, be quiet, and don't show your bad temper when all

those people can hear us. I have loved you--"

But with a quiet yet terrible laugh Camille interrupted her. "You've

loved me! Oh! my poor mamma, what a comical thing to say! Have you ever

loved _anybody_? You want others to love _you_, but that's another

matter. As for your child, any child, do you even know how it ought to be

loved? You have always neglected me, thrust me on one side, deeming me so

ugly, so unworthy of you! And besides, you have not had days and nights

enough to love yourself! Oh! don't deny it, my poor mamma; but even now

you're looking at me as if I were some loathsome monster that's in your

way."

From that moment the abominable scene was bound to continue to the end.

With their teeth set, their faces close together, the two women went on

speaking in feverish whispers.

"Be quiet, Camille, I tell you! I will not allow such language!"

"But I won't be quiet when you do all you can to wound me. If it's wrong

of me to dress like an old woman, perhaps another is rather ridiculous in

dressing like a girl, like a bride."

"Like a bride? I don't understand you."

"Oh! yes, you do. However, I would have you know that everybody doesn't

find me so ugly as you try to make them believe."

"If you look amiss, it is because you don't dress properly; that is all I

said."

"I dress as I please, and no doubt I do so well enough, since I'm loved

as I am."

"What, really! Does someone love you? Well, let him inform us of it and

marry you."

"Yes--certainly, certainly! It will be a good riddance, won't it? And

you'll have the pleasure of seeing me as a bride!"

Their voices were rising in spite of their efforts to restrain them.

However, Camille paused and drew breath before hissing out the words:

"Gerard is coming here to ask for my hand in a day or two."

Eve, livid, with wildly staring eyes, did not seem to understand.

"Gerard? why do you tell me that?"

"Why, because it's Gerard who loves me and who is going to marry me! You

drive me to extremities; you're for ever repeating that I'm ugly; you

treat me like a monster whom nobody will ever care for. So I'm forced to

defend myself and tell you the truth in order to prove to you that

everybody is not of your opinion."

Silence fell; the frightful thing which had risen between them seemed to

have arrested the quarrel. But there was neither mother nor daughter left

there. They were simply two suffering, defiant rivals. Eve in her turn

drew a long breath and glanced anxiously towards the adjoining room to

ascertain if anyone were coming in or listening to them. And then in a

tone of resolution she made answer:

"You cannot marry Gerard."

"Pray, why not?"

"Because I won't have it; because it's impossible."

"That isn't a reason; give me a reason."

"The reason is that the marriage is impossible that is all."

"No, no, I'll tell you the reason since you force me to it. The reason is

that Gerard is your lover! But what does that matter, since I know it and

am willing to take him all the same?"

And to this retort Camille's flaming eyes added the words: "And it is

particularly on that account that I want him." All the long torture born

of her infirmities, all her rage at having always seen her mother

beautiful, courted and adored, was now stirring her and seeking vengeance

in cruel triumph. At last then she was snatching from her rival the lover

of whom she had so long been jealous!

"You wretched girl!" stammered Eve, wounded in the heart and almost

sinking to the floor. "You don't know what you say or what you make me

suffer."

However, she again had to pause, draw herself erect and smile; for

Rosemonde hastened in from the adjoining room with the news that she was

wanted downstairs. The doors were about to be opened, and it was

necessary she should be at her stall. Yes, Eve answered, she would be

down in another moment. Still, even as she spoke she leant more heavily

on the pier-table behind her in order that she might not fall.

Hyacinthe had drawn near to his sister: "You know," said he, "it's simply

idiotic to quarrel like that. You would do much better to come

downstairs."

But Camille harshly dismissed him: "Just _you_ go off, and take the

others with you. It's quite as well that they shouldn't be about our

ears."

Hyacinthe glanced at his mother, like one who knew the truth and

considered the whole affair ridiculous. And then, vexed at seeing her so

deficient in energy in dealing with that little pest, his sister, he

shrugged his shoulders, and leaving them to their folly, conducted the

others away. One could hear Rosemonde laughing as she went off below,

while the General began to tell Madame Fonsegue another story as they

descended the stairs together. However, at the moment when the mother and

daughter at last fancied themselves alone once more, other voices reached

their ears, those of Duvillard and Fonsegue, who were still near at hand.

The Baron from his room might well overhear the dispute.

Eve felt that she ought to have gone off. But she had lacked the strength

to do so; it had been a sheer impossibility for her after those words

which had smote her like a buffet amidst her distress at the thought of

losing her lover.

"Gerard cannot marry you," she said; "he does not love you."

"He does."

"You fancy it because he has good-naturedly shown some kindness to you,

on seeing others pay you such little attention. But he does not love

you."

"He does. He loves me first because I'm not such a fool as many others

are, and particularly because I'm young."

This was a fresh wound for the Baroness; one inflicted with mocking

cruelty in which rang out all the daughter's triumphant delight at seeing

her mother's beauty at last ripening and waning. "Ah! my poor mamma, you

no longer know what it is to be young. If I'm not beautiful, at all

events I'm young; my eyes are clear and my lips are fresh. And my hair's

so long too, and I've so much of it that it would suffice to gown me if I

chose. You see, one's never ugly when one's young. Whereas, my poor

mamma, everything is ended when one gets old. It's all very well for a

woman to have been beautiful, and to strive to keep so, but in reality

there's only ruin left, and shame and disgust."

She spoke these words in such a sharp, ferocious voice that each of them

entered her mother's heart like a knife. Tears rose to the eyes of the

wretched woman, again stricken in her bleeding wound. Ah! it was true,

she remained without weapons against youth. And all her anguish came from

the consciousness that she was growing old, from the feeling that love

was departing from her now, that like a fruit she had ripened and fallen

from the tree.

"But Gerard's mother will never let him marry you," she said.

"He will prevail on her; that's his concern. I've a dowry of two

millions, and two millions can settle many things."

"Do you now want to libel him, and say that he's marrying you for your

money?"

"No, indeed! Gerard's a very nice and honest fellow. He loves me and he's

marrying me for myself. But, after all, he isn't rich; he still has no

assured position, although he's thirty-six; and there may well be some

advantage in a wife who brings you wealth as well as happiness. For, you

hear, mamma, it's happiness I'm bringing him, real happiness, love that's

shared and is certain of the future."

Once again their faces drew close together. The hateful scene,

interrupted by sounds around them, postponed, and then resumed, was

dragging on, becoming a perfect drama full of murderous violence,

although they never shouted, but still spoke on in low and gasping

voices. Neither gave way to the other, though at every moment they were

liable to some surprise; for not only were all the doors open, so that

the servants might come in, but the Baron's voice still rang out gaily,

close at hand.

"He loves you, he loves you"--continued Eve. "That's what you say. But

_he_ never told you so."

"He has told me so twenty times; he repeats it every time that we are

alone together!"

"Yes, just as one says it to a little girl by way of amusing her. But he

has never told you that he meant to marry you."

"He told it me the last time he came. And it's settled. I'm simply

waiting for him to get his mother's consent and make his formal offer."

"You lie, you lie, you wretched girl! You simply want to make me suffer,

and you lie, you lie!"

Eve's grief at last burst forth in that cry of protest. She no longer

knew that she was a mother, and was speaking to her daughter. The woman,

the _amorosa_, alone remained in her, outraged and exasperated by a

rival. And with a sob she confessed the truth: "It is I he loves! Only

the last time I spoke to him, he swore to me--you hear me?--he swore upon

his honour that he did not love you, and that he would never marry you!"

A faint, sharp laugh came from Camille. Then, with an air of derisive

compassion, she replied: "Ah! my poor mamma, you really make me sorry for

you! What a child you are! Yes, really, you are the child, not I. What!

you who ought to have so much experience, you still allow yourself to be

duped by a man's protests! That one really has no malice; and, indeed,

that's why he swears whatever you want him to swear, just to please and

quiet you, for at heart he's a bit of a coward."

"You lie, you lie!"

"But just think matters over. If he no longer comes here, if he didn't

come to _dejeuner_ this morning, it is simply because he's had enough of

you. He has left you for good; just have the courage to realise it. Of

course he's still polite and amiable, because he's a well-bred man, and

doesn't know how to break off. The fact is that he takes pity on you."

"You lie, you lie!"

"Well, question him then. Have a frank explanation with him. Ask him his

intentions in a friendly way. And then show some good nature yourself,

and realise that if you care for him you ought to give him me at once in

his own interest. Give him back his liberty, and you will soon see that

I'm the one he loves."

"You lie, you lie! You wretched child, you only want to torture and kill

me!"

Then, in her fury and distress, Eve remembered that she was the mother,

and that it was for her to chastise that unworthy daughter. There was no

stick near her, but from a basket of the yellow roses, whose powerful

scent intoxicated both of them, she plucked a handful of blooms, with

long and spiny stalks, and smote Camille across the face. A drop of blood

appeared on the girl's left temple, near her eyelid.

But she sprang forward, flushed and maddened by this correction, with her

hand raised and ready to strike back. "Take care, mother! I swear I'd

beat you like a gipsy! And now just put this into your head: I mean to

marry Gerard, and I will; and I'll take him from you, even if I have to

raise a scandal, should you refuse to give him to me with good grace."

Eve, after her one act of angry vigour, had sunk into an armchair,

overcome, distracted. And all the horror of quarrels, which sprang from

her egotistical desire to be happy, caressed, flattered and adored, was

returning to her. But Camille, still threatening, still unsatiated,

showed her heart as it really was, her stern, black, unforgiving heart,

intoxicated with cruelty. There came a moment of supreme silence, while

Duvillard's gay voice again rang out in the adjoining room.

The mother was gently weeping, when Hyacinthe, coming upstairs at a run,

swept into the little _salon_. He looked at the two women, and made a

gesture of indulgent contempt. "Ah! you're no doubt satisfied now! But

what did I tell you? It would have been much better for you to have come

downstairs at once! Everybody is asking for you. It's all idiotic. I've

come to fetch you."

Eve and Camille would not yet have followed him, perhaps, if Duvillard

and Fonsegue had not at that moment come out of the former's room. Having

finished their cigars they also spoke of going downstairs. And Eve had to

rise and smile and show dry eyes, while Camille, standing before a

looking-glass, arranged her hair, and stanched the little drop of blood

that had gathered on her temple.

There was already quite a number of people below, in the three huge

saloons adorned with tapestry and plants. The stalls had been draped with

red silk, which set a gay, bright glow around the goods. And no ordinary

bazaar could have put forth such a show, for there was something of

everything among the articles of a thousand different kinds, from

sketches by recognised masters, and the autographs of famous writers,

down to socks and slippers and combs. The haphazard way in which things

were laid out was in itself an attraction; and, in addition, there was a

buffet, where the whitest of beautiful hands poured out champagne, and

two lotteries, one for an organ and another for a pony-drawn village

cart, the tickets for which were sold by a bevy of charming girls, who

had scattered through the throng. As Duvillard had expected, however, the

great success of the bazaar lay in the delightful little shiver which the

beautiful ladies experienced as they passed through the entrance where

the bomb had exploded. The rougher repairing work was finished, the walls

and ceilings had been doctored, in part re-constructed. However, the

painters had not yet come, and here and there the whiter stone and

plaster work showed like fresh scars left by all the terrible gashes. It

was with mingled anxiety and rapture that pretty heads emerged from the

carriages which, arriving in a continuous stream, made the flagstones of

the court re-echo. And in the three saloons, beside the stalls, there was

no end to the lively chatter: "Ah! my dear, did you see all those marks?

How frightful, how frightful! The whole house was almost blown up. And to

think it might begin again while we are here! One really needs some

courage to come, but then, that asylum is such a deserving institution,

and money is badly wanted to build a new wing. And besides, those

monsters will see that we are not frightened, whatever they do."

When the Baroness at last came down to her stall with Camille she found

the saleswomen feverishly at work already under the direction of Princess

Rosemonde, who on occasions of this kind evinced the greatest cunning and

rapacity, robbing the customers in the most impudent fashion. "Ah! here

you are," she exclaimed. "Beware of a number of higglers who have come to

secure bargains. I know them! They watch for their opportunities, turn

everything topsy-turvy and wait for us to lose our heads and forget

prices, so as to pay even less than they would in a real shop. But I'll

get good prices from them, you shall see!"

At this, Eve, who for her own part was a most incapable saleswoman, had

to laugh with the others. And in a gentle voice she made a pretence of

addressing certain recommendations to Camille, who listened with a

smiling and most submissive air. In point of fact the wretched mother was

sinking with emotion, particularly at the thought that she would have to

remain there till seven o'clock, and suffer in secret before all those

people, without possibility of relief. And thus it was almost like a

respite when she suddenly perceived Abbe Froment sitting and waiting for

her on a settee, covered with red velvet, near her stall. Her legs were

failing her, so she took a place beside him.

"You received my letter then, Monsieur l'Abbe. I am glad that you have

come, for I have some good news to give you, and wished to leave you the

pleasure of imparting it to your _protege_, that man Laveuve, whom you so

warmly recommended to me. Every formality has now been fulfilled, and you

can bring him to the asylum to-morrow."

Pierre gazed at her in stupefaction. "Laveuve? Why, he is dead!"

In her turn she became astonished. "What, dead! But you never informed me

of it! If I told you of all the trouble that has been taken, of all that

had to be undone and done again, and the discussions and the papers and

the writing! Are you quite sure that he is dead?"

"Oh! yes, he is dead. He has been dead a month."

"Dead a month! Well, we could not know; you yourself gave us no sign of

life. Ah! _mon Dieu_! what a worry that he should be dead. We shall now

be obliged to undo everything again!"

"He is dead, madame. It is true that I ought to have informed you of it.

But that doesn't alter the fact--he is dead."

Dead! that word which kept on returning, the thought too, that for a

month past she had been busying herself for a corpse, quite froze her,

brought her to the very depths of despair, like an omen of the cold death

into which she herself must soon descend, in the shroud of her last

passion. And, meantime, Pierre, despite himself, smiled bitterly at the

atrocious irony of it all. Ah! that lame and halting Charity, which

proffers help when men are dead!

The priest still lingered on the settee when the Baroness rose. She had

seen magistrate Amadieu hurriedly enter like one who just wished to show

himself, purchase some trifle, and then return to the Palace of Justice.

However, he was also perceived by little Massot, the "Globe" reporter,

who was prowling round the stalls, and who at once bore down upon him,

eager for information. And he hemmed him in and forthwith interviewed him

respecting the affair of that mechanician Salvat, who was accused of

having deposited the bomb at the entrance of the house. Was this simply

an invention of the police, as some newspapers pretended? Or was it

really correct? And if so, would Salvat soon be arrested? In self-defence

Amadieu answered correctly enough that the affair did not as yet concern

him, and would only come within his attributions, if Salvat should be

arrested and the investigation placed in his hands. At the same time,

however, the magistrate's pompous and affectedly shrewd manner suggested

that he already knew everything to the smallest details, and that, had he

chosen, he could have promised some great events for the morrow. A circle

of ladies had gathered round him as he spoke, quite a number of pretty

women feverish with curiosity, who jostled one another in their eagerness

to hear that brigand tale which sent a little shiver coursing under their

skins. However, Amadieu managed to slip off after paying Rosemonde twenty

francs for a cigarette case, which was perhaps worth thirty sous.

Massot, on recognising Pierre, came up to shake hands with him. "Don't

you agree with me, Monsieur l'Abbe, that Salvat must be a long way off by

now if he's got good legs? Ah! the police will always make me laugh!"

However, Rosemonde brought Hyacinthe up to the journalist. "Monsieur

Massot," said she, "you who go everywhere, I want you to be judge. That

Chamber of Horrors at Montmartre, that tavern where Legras sings the

'Flowers of the Streets'--"

"Oh! a delightful spot, madame," interrupted Massot, "I wouldn't take

even a gendarme there."

"No, don't jest, Monsieur Massot, I'm talking seriously. Isn't it quite

allowable for a respectable woman to go there when she's accompanied by a

gentleman?" And, without allowing the journalist time to answer her, she

turned towards Hyacinthe: "There! you see that Monsieur Massot doesn't

say no! You've got to take me there this evening, it's sworn, it's

sworn."

Then she darted away to sell a packet of pins to an old lady, while the

young man contented himself with remarking, in the voice of one who has

no illusions left: "She's quite idiotic with her Chamber of Horrors!"

Massot philosophically shrugged his shoulders. It was only natural that a

woman should want to amuse herself. And when Hyacinthe had gone off,

passing with perverse contempt beside the lovely girls who were selling

lottery tickets, the journalist ventured to murmur: "All the same, it

would do that youngster good if a woman were to take him in hand."

Then, again addressing Pierre, he resumed: "Why, here comes Duthil! What

did Sagnier mean this morning by saying that Duthil would sleep at Mazas

to-night?"

In a great hurry apparently, and all smiles, Duthil was cutting his way

through the crowd in order to join Duvillard and Fonsegue, who still

stood talking near the Baroness's stall. And he waved his hand to them in

a victorious way, to imply that he had succeeded in the delicate mission

entrusted to him. This was nothing less than a bold manoeuvre to hasten

Silviane's admission to the Comedie Francaise. The idea had occurred to

her of making the Baron give a dinner at the Cafe Anglais in order that

she might meet at it an influential critic, who, according to her

statements, would compel the authorities to throw the doors wide open for

her as soon as he should know her. However, it did not seem easy to

secure the critic's presence, as he was noted for his sternness and

grumbling disposition. And, indeed, after a first repulse, Duthil had for

three days past been obliged to exert all his powers of diplomacy, and

bring even the remotest influence into play. But he was radiant now, for

he had conquered.

"It's for this evening, my dear Baron, at half-past seven," he exclaimed.

"Ah! dash it all, I've had more trouble than I should have had to secure

a concession vote!" Then he laughed with the pretty impudence of a man of

pleasure, whom political conscientiousness did not trouble. And, indeed,

his allusion to the fresh denunciations of the "Voix du Peuple" hugely

amused him.

"Don't jest," muttered Fonsegue, who for his part wished to amuse himself

by frightening the young deputy. "Things are going very badly!"

Duthil turned pale, and a vision of the police and Mazas rose before his

eyes. In this wise sheer funk came over him from time to time. However,

with his lack of all moral sense, he soon felt reassured and began to

laugh. "Bah!" he retorted gaily, winking towards Duvillard, "the

governor's there to pilot the barque!"

The Baron, who was extremely pleased, had pressed his hands, thanked him,

and called him an obliging fellow. And now turning towards Fonsegue, he

exclaimed: "I say, you must make one of us this evening. Oh! it's

necessary. I want something imposing round Silviane. Duthil will

represent the Chamber, you journalism, and I finance--" But he suddenly

paused on seeing Gerard, who, with a somewhat grave expression, was

leisurely picking his way through the sea of skirts. "Gerard, my friend,"

said the Baron, after beckoning to him, "I want you to do me a service."

And forthwith he told him what was in question; how the influential

critic had been prevailed upon to attend a dinner which would decide

Silviane's future; and how it was the duty of all her friends to rally

round her.

"But I can't," the young man answered in embarrassment. "I have to dine

at home with my mother, who was rather poorly this morning."

"Oh! a sensible woman like your mother will readily understand that there

are matters of exceptional importance. Go home and excuse yourself. Tell

her some story, tell her that a friend's happiness is in question." And

as Gerard began to weaken, Duvillard added: "The fact is, that I really

want you, my dear fellow; I must have a society man. Society, you know,

is a great force in theatrical matters; and if Silviane has society with

her, her triumph is certain."

Gerard promised, and then chatted for a moment with his uncle, General de

Bozonnet, who was quite enlivened by that throng of women, among whom he

had been carried hither and thither like an old rudderless ship. After

acknowledging the amiability with which Madame Fonsegue had listened to

his stories, by purchasing an autograph of Monseigneur Martha from her

for a hundred francs, he had quite lost himself amid the bevy of girls

who had passed him on, one to another. And now, on his return from them,

he had his hands full of lottery tickets: "Ah! my fine fellow," said he,

"I don't advise you to venture among all those young persons. You would

have to part with your last copper. But, just look! there's Mademoiselle

Camille beckoning to you!"

Camille, indeed, from the moment she had perceived Gerard, had been

smiling at him and awaiting his approach. And when their glances met he

was obliged to go to her, although, at the same moment, he felt that

Eve's despairing and entreating eyes were fixed upon him. The girl, who

fully realised that her mother was watching her, at once made a marked

display of amiability, profiting by the license which charitable fervour

authorised, to slip a variety of little articles into the young man's

pockets, and then place others in his hands, which she pressed within her

own, showing the while all the sparkle of youth, indulging in fresh,

merry laughter, which fairly tortured her rival.

So extreme was Eve's suffering, that she wished to intervene and part

them. But it so chanced that Pierre barred her way, for he wished to

submit an idea to her before leaving the bazaar. "Madame," said he,

"since that man Laveuve is dead, and you have taken so much trouble with

regard to the bed which you now have vacant, will you be so good as to

keep it vacant until I have seen our venerable friend, Abbe Rose? I am to

see him this evening, and he knows so many cases of want, and would be so

glad to relieve one of them, and bring you some poor _protege_ of his."

"Yes, certainly," stammered the Baroness, "I shall be very happy,--I will

wait a little, as you desire,--of course, of course, Monsieur l'Abbe."

She was trembling all over; she no longer knew what she was saying; and,

unable to conquer her passion, she turned aside from the priest, unaware

even that he was still there, when Gerard, yielding to the dolorous

entreaty of her eyes, at last managed to escape from Camille and join

her.

"What a stranger you are becoming, my friend!" she said aloud, with a

forced smile. "One never sees you now."

"Why, I have been poorly," he replied, in his amiable way. "Yes, I assure

you I have been ailing a little."

He, ailing! She looked at him with maternal anxiety, quite upset. And,

indeed, however proud and lofty his figure, his handsome regular face did

seem to her paler than usual. It was as if the nobility of the facade

had, in some degree, ceased to hide the irreparable dilapidation within.

And given his real good nature, it must be true that he

suffered--suffered by reason of his useless, wasted life, by reason of

all the money he cost his impoverished mother, and of the needs that were

at last driving him to marry that wealthy deformed girl, whom at first he

had simply pitied. And so weak did he seem to Eve, so like a piece of

wreckage tossed hither and thither by a tempest, that, at the risk of

being overheard by the throng, she let her heart flow forth in a low but

ardent, entreating murmur: "If you suffer, ah! what sufferings are

mine!--Gerard, we must see one another, I will have it so."

"No, I beg you, let us wait," he stammered in embarrassment.

"It must be, Gerard; Camille has told me your plans. You cannot refuse to

see me. I insist on it."

He made yet another attempt to escape the cruel explanation. "But it's

impossible at the usual place," he answered, quivering. "The address is

known."

"Then to-morrow, at four o'clock, at that little restaurant in the Bois

where we have met before."

He had to promise, and they parted. Camille had just turned her head and

was looking at them. Moreover, quite a number of women had besieged the

stall; and the Baroness began to attend to them with the air of a ripe

and nonchalant goddess, while Gerard rejoined Duvillard, Fonsegue and

Duthil, who were quite excited at the prospect of their dinner that

evening.

Pierre had heard a part of the conversation between Gerard and the

Baroness. He knew what skeletons the house concealed, what physiological

and moral torture and wretchedness lay beneath all the dazzling wealth

and power. There was here an envenomed, bleeding sore, ever spreading, a

cancer eating into father, mother, daughter and son, who one and all had

thrown social bonds aside. However, the priest made his way out of the

_salons_, half stifling amidst the throng of lady-purchasers who were

making quite a triumph of the bazaar. And yonder, in the depths of the

gloom, he could picture Salvat still running and running on; while the

corpse of Laveuve seemed to him like a buffet of atrocious irony dealt to

noisy and delusive charity.

II

SPIRIT AND FLESH

How delightful was the quietude of the little ground-floor overlooking a

strip of garden in the Rue Cortot, where good Abbe Rose resided!

Hereabouts there was not even a rumble of wheels, or an echo of the

panting breath of Paris, which one heard on the other side of the height

of Montmartre. The deep silence and sleepy peacefulness were suggestive

of some distant provincial town.

Seven o'clock had struck, the dusk had gathered slowly, and Pierre was in

the humble dining-room, waiting for the _femme-de-menage_ to place the

soup upon the table. Abbe Rose, anxious at having seen so little of him

for a month past, had written, asking him to come to dinner, in order

that they might have a quiet chat concerning their affairs. From time to

time Pierre still gave his friend money for charitable purposes; in fact,

ever since the days of the asylum in the Rue de Charonne, they had had

accounts together, which they periodically liquidated. So that evening

after dinner they were to talk of it all, and see if they could not do

even more than they had hitherto done. The good old priest was quite

radiant at the thought of the peaceful evening which he was about to

spend in attending to the affairs of his beloved poor; for therein lay

his only amusement, the sole pleasure to which he persistently and

passionately returned, in spite of all the worries that his inconsiderate

charity had already so often brought him.

Glad to be able to procure his friend this pleasure, Pierre, on his side,

grew calmer, and found relief and momentary repose in sharing the other's

simple repast and yielding to all the kindliness around him, far from his

usual worries. He remembered the vacant bed at the Asylum, which Baroness

Duvillard had promised to keep in reserve until he should have asked Abbe

Rose if he knew of any case of destitution particularly worthy of

interest; and so before sitting down to table he spoke of the matter.

"Destitution worthy of interest!" replied Abbe Rose, "ah! my dear child,

every case is worthy of interest. And when it's a question of old toilers

without work the only trouble is that of selection, the anguish of

choosing one and leaving so many others in distress." Nevertheless,

painful though his scruples were, he strove to think and come to some

decision. "I know the case which will suit you," he said at last. "It's

certainly one of the greatest suffering and wretchedness; and, so humble

a one, too--an old carpenter of seventy-five, who has been living on

public charity during the eight or ten years that he has been unable to

find work. I don't know his name, everybody calls him 'the big Old'un.'

There are times when he does not come to my Saturday distributions for

weeks together. We shall have to look for him at once. I think that he

sleeps at the Night Refuge in the Rue d'Orsel when lack of room there

doesn't force him to spend the night crouching behind some palings. Shall

we go down the Rue d'Orsel this evening?"

Abbe Rose's eyes beamed brightly as he spoke, for this proposal of his

signified a great debauch, the tasting of forbidden fruit. He had been

reproached so often and so roughly with his visits to those who had

fallen to the deepest want and misery, that in spite of his overflowing,

apostolic compassion, he now scarcely dared to go near them. However, he

continued: "Is it agreed, my child? Only this once? Besides, it is our

only means of finding the big Old'un. You won't have to stop with me

later than eleven. And I should so like to show you all that! You will

see what terrible sufferings there are! And perhaps we may be fortunate

enough to relieve some poor creature or other."

Pierre smiled at the juvenile ardour displayed by this old man with snowy

hair. "It's agreed, my dear Abbe," he responded, "I shall be very pleased

to spend my whole evening with you, for I feel it will do me good to

follow you once more on one of those rambles which used to fill our

hearts with grief and joy."

At this moment the servant brought in the soup; however, just as the two

priests were taking their seats a discreet ring was heard, and when Abbe

Rose learnt that the visitor was a neighbour, Madame Mathis, who had come

for an answer, he gave orders that she should be shown in.

"This poor woman," he explained to Pierre, "needed an advance of ten

francs to get a mattress out of pawn; and I didn't have the money by me

at the time. But I've since procured it. She lives in the house, you

know, in silent poverty, on so small an income that it hardly keeps her

in bread."

"But hasn't she a big son of twenty?" asked Pierre, suddenly remembering

the young man he had seen at Salvat's.

The Three Cities Trilogy: Paris, Volume 3 · 第 1 / 9 段