Fallacy of the "Crusade."

For indeed it is not possible to name any book out of which a

perverted mind will not draw food for its disease. The whole fallacy

lies in supposing literature the cause of the disease. Evil men are

not evil because they read bad books: they read bad books because they

are evil: and being evil, or diseased, they are quickly able to

extract evil or disease even from very good books. There is talk of

disseminating the works of our best authors, at a cheap rate, in the

hope that they will drive the Penny Dreadful out of the market. But

has good literature at the cheapest driven the middle classes from

their false gods? And let it be remembered, to the credit of these

poor boys, that they do buy their books. The middle classes take

_their_ poison on hire or exchange.

But perhaps the full enormity of the cant about Penny Dreadfuls

can best be perceived by travelling to and fro for a week

between London and Paris and observing the books read by those

who travel with first-class tickets. I think a fond belief in

Ivanhoe-within-the-reach-of-all would not long survive that

experiment.

Adventures in Criticism · 第 65 / 95 题