The leeward side of the island went very gently into the water. From
a boat offshore--say, a couple of miles out--the shoreline looked low
and flat and peaceful. There were houses in view, and there were boats
afloat. But they were much smaller than those that had been towing a
twenty-mile-long oil-slick out to sea. These boats did not ply back
and forth. Most of them seemed anchored. On some of them there was
activity. Men went overboard, without splashing, and things came up
from the ocean bottom and were dumped inside their hulls, and then
baskets went back down into the water. At long intervals--quite long
intervals--men emerged from underwater and sat on the sides of the
boats and smoked with an effect of leisure.
There was sunshine, and the land was green, and a seeming of
vast tranquillity hung over the whole seascape. But the small
Survey-personnel recreation-boat moved in toward the shore, and the
look of things changed. At a mile, a mass of green that had seemed to
be trees growing down to the water's edge became a thicket of tumbled
trunks and overset branches where a tree-thicket had collapsed. At half
a mile the water was opaque. There were things floating in it--the
roof of a house; the leaves of an ornamental shrub, with nearby its
roots showing at the surface, washed clean. A child's toy bobbed past
the boat. It looked horribly pathetic. There were the exotic planes
and angles of three wooden steps, floating in the ripples of the great
ocean.
"Ignoring the imminent explosion of the fuel store," said Hardwick
dryly, "we need to find out something about what has to be done to the
soil to stop its creeping. I hope you remembered, lieutenant, to ask a
great many useless questions."
"Yes, sir," said Barnes. "I tried to, sir. I asked everything I could
think of."
"Those boats yonder?"
Hardwick indicated a boat from which something like a wire basket
splashed into the water as he gestured.
"A garden boat, sir," said Barnes. "On this side of the island the sea
bottom slopes so gradually, sir, that there are sea gardens on the
bottom. Shellfish from Earth do not thrive, sir, but there are edible
sea plants. The gardeners cultivate them as on land, sir."
Hardwick reached overside and carefully took his twentieth sample of
the sea water. He squinted, and estimated the distance to shore.
"I shall try to imagine someone wearing a diving mask and using a hoe,"
he said dryly. "What's the depth here?"
"We're half a mile out, sir," said Barnes promptly. "It should be about
sixty feet, sir. The bottom seems to have about a three per cent grade,
sir. That's the angle of repose of the mud. There's no sand to make a
steeper slope possible."
"Three per cent's not bad!"
Hardwick looked pleased. He picked up one of his earlier samples and
tilted it, checking the angle at which the sediment came to rest. The
bottom mud, here, was essentially the same as the soil of the land. But
the soil of the island was infinitely finely-divided. In fresh water it
floated practically like a colloid. In sea water, obviously, it sank
because of the salinity which made suspension difficult.
"You see the point, eh?" he asked. When Barnes shook his head, Hardwick
explained, "Probably for my sins I've had a good deal to do with swamp
planets. The mud of a salt swamp is quite different from a fresh-water
swamp. The essential trouble with the people ashore is that by their
irrigation they've contrived an island-wide swamp which happens to be
upside down--the mud at the bottom. So the question is, can it acquire
the properties of a salt swamp instead of a fresh-water swamp without
killing all the vegetation on the surface? That's why I'm after these
samples. As we go inshore the water should be fresher--on a shallowing
shore like this with drainage in this direction."
He gestured to the Survey private at the stern of the boat.
"Closer in, please."
Barnes said:
"Sir, motorboats are forbidden inshore. The vibrations."
Hardwick shrugged.
"We will obey the rule. I've probably samples enough. How far out do
the mudflats run--at the surface?"
"About two hundred yards at the surface, sir. The mud's about the
consistency of thick cream. You can see where the ripples stop, sir."
Hardwick stared. He turned his eyes away.
"Er ... sir," said Barnes unhappily. "May I ask, sir--"
Hardwick said dryly:
"You may. But the answer's pure theory. This information will do no
good at all unless all the rest of the problem we face is solved. But
solving the rest of the problem will do no good if this part remains
unsolved. You see?"
"Yes, sir. But ... the others seem more ... urgent, sir."
Hardwick shrugged.
* * * * *
There was a shout from a nearby boat. Men were pointing ashore.
Hardwick jerked his eyes to the shoreline.
A section of seemingly solid ground moved slowly toward the water. Its
forefront seemed to disintegrate, and a singularly slow-moving swell
moved out over the rippleless border of the sea, where mudbanks like
thick cream reached the surface.
The moving mass was a good half-mile in width. Its outer edge dissolved
in the sea, and the top tilted, and green vegetation leaned downwind
and very deliberately subsided into the water. It was remarkably like
the way an ingot of non-ferrous metal slides into the pool made by its
own melting.
But the aftermath was somehow horrifying. When the tumbled soil was
all dissolved--and the grass undulated like a floating meadow on the
water--there remained a jagged shallow gap in the land-bank. There were
irregularities: vertical striations and unevennesses in the exposed,
broken soil.
Hardwick snatched up glasses and put them to his eyes. The shore seemed
to leap toward him. He saw the harsh outlines of the temporary cliff
go soft. The bottom ceased to look like soil. It glistened. It moved
outward in masses which grew rounder as they swelled. They flowed after
the now-vanished fallen stuff, into the water. The topsoil was suddenly
undercut. The wetter material under it flowed away, leaving a ledge
which bore carefully tended flowering shrubs--Hardwick could see specks
of color which were their blossoms--and a brightly-colored, small trim
house in which some family had lived.
The flow-away of the deeper soil made a greater, more cavernous hollow
beneath the surface. It began to collapse. The house teetered. It fell.
It smashed. More soil dropped down, and more, and more.
Presently there was a depression, a sort of valley leading inland away
from the sea, in what had been a rampart of green at the water's edge.
It was still green, but through the glasses Hardwick could see that
trees had fallen, and a white-painted fence was splintered. And there
was still movement.
The movement slowed and slowed, but it was not possible to say when
it stopped. In reality, it did not stop. The island's soil was still
flowing into the ocean.
Barnes drew a deep breath.
"I ... thought that was it, sir," he said shakily. "I mean ... that the
whole island would start sliding."
"The ground's a bit more water-soaked down here," Hardwick said
briefly. "Inland the bottom-soil's not nearly as fluid as here. But I'd
hate to have a really heavy rainfall right now!"
Barnes' mind jerked back to the Sector Chief's office.
"The drumming would set off the ship-fuel?"
"Among other things," said Hardwick. "Yes." Then he said abruptly: "How
good are you at precision measurements? I've messed around on swamp
planets. I know a bit too much about what I ought to find, which is not
good for accuracy. Can you take these bottles and measure the rate of
sedimentation and plot it against salinity?"
"Y-yes, sir. I'll try, sir."
"If we had soil-coagulants enough," said Hardwick vexedly, "we could
handle that upside-down swamp the civilians have so carefully made,
here. But we haven't got it! But the freshened sea water they've been
irrigating with is practically mineral-free! I want to know how much
mineral content in the water would keep the swamp-mud from acting like
wet soap. It's entirely possible that we'd have to make the soil too
salty to grow anything, in order to anchor it. But I want to know!"
Barnes said uncomfortably:
"Wouldn't you, sir ... wouldn't you have to put the minerals in
irrigation-water to get them down to the ... the swamp?"
Hardwick grinned, very surprisingly.
"You've got promise, Barnes! Yes. I would. And it would increase the
rate of slide before it stopped it. Which could be another problem. But
it was good work to think of it! When we get back to Headquarters, you
commandeer a laboratory and make those measurements for me."
"Yes, sir," said Barnes.
"We'll start back now," said Hardwick.
* * * * *
The recreation-boat obediently turned. It went out to sea until the
water flowing past its hull was crystal-clear. And Hardwick seemed
to relax. On the way they passed more small boats. Many of them were
gardeners' boats, from which men dived with diving masks to tend or
harvest the cultivated garden-patches not too far down. But many were
pleasure boats, from double-hulled sailing craft intended purely for
sport, to sturdy though small cabin cruisers which could venture
far out to sea, or even around to the windward of the island for
sport-fishing. All the pleasure craft were crowded--there were usually
some children--and it was noticeable that on each one there were always
some faces turned toward the shore.
"That," said Hardwick, "makes for emotional thinking. These people
know their danger. So they've packed their children and their wives
into these little cockleshells to try to save them. They're waiting
offshore here to find out if they're doomed regardless. I wouldn't
say"--he nodded toward a delicately designed twin-hull sailer with more
children than adults aboard--"I wouldn't call that a good substitute
for an Ark!"
Young Barnes fidgeted. The boat turned again and went parallel to the
shore toward where Headquarters land came down to the sea. The ground
was firmer, there. There had been no irrigation. Lateral seepage had
done some damage at the edge of the reserve, but the major part of
the shoreline was unbroken, unchanged solid ground, looming above the
beach. There was, of course, no sand at the edge of the water. There
had been no weathering of rock to produce it. When this island was
upraised, its coating of hardened ooze protected the stone. The small
lee-side waves merely lapped upon bare, curdled rock. The wharf for
pleasure boats went out on metal pilings into deep water.
"Excuse me, sir," said young Barnes embarrassedly, "but ... if the fuel
blows, it'll be pretty bad, sir."
"That's the understatement of the century," Hardwick commented. "Yes.
It will. Why?"
"You've something in mind, sir, to try to save the rest of the island.
Nobody else seems to know what to do. If ... if I may say so, sir, your
... safety is pretty important. And you could do your work on the
cliffs, sir, and ... if I could stay at Headquarters and--"
He stopped, appalled at his own presumption in suggesting that he could
substitute for a Senior Officer even as a message-boy, and even for his
convenience or safety. He began to stammer:
"I m-mean, sir, n-not that I'm capable of it, sir--"
"Stop stammering," grunted Hardwick. "There aren't two separate
problems. There's one which is the compound of the two. I'm staying
at Headquarters to try something on the ship-fuel side, and Werner
will specialize on the rest of the island since he hasn't come up with
anything but shifting people to the ice pack. And the situation isn't
hopeless! If there's an earthquake or a storm, of course we'll be wiped
out. But short of one of those calamities, we can save part of the
island. I don't know how much, but some. You make those measurements.
If you're doubtful, get a Headquarters man to duplicate them. Then give
me both sets."
"Y-yes, sir," said Young Barnes, miserably.
"And," said Hardwick formidably. "Never try to push your ranking
officer into a safe place, even if you're willing to take his risk!
Would you like it if a man under you tried to put you in a safe place
while he took the chance that was yours?"
"N-no, sir!" admitted the very junior lieutenant. "But--"
"Make those measurements!" snapped Hardwick.
* * * * *
The boat came into the dock. Hardwick got out of the boat. He went to
Sandringham's office.
Sandringham was in the act of listening to somebody in the
phone-screen, who apparently was on the thin edge of hysteria. The
brown dog was sprawled asleep on the rug.
When the man in the vision-screen panted to a stop, Sandringham said
calmly:
"I am assured that before the soil of the island is too far gone,
measures now in preparation will be applied to good effect. A Senior
Survey Officer is now preparing remedial measures. He is a ... ah ...
specialist in problems of exactly this nature."
"_But we can't wait!_" panted the civilian fiercely. "_I'll proclaim a
planetary emergency! We'll take over the reserve area by force! We have
to_--"
"If you try," Sandringham told him grimly, "I'll mount paralysis-guns
to stop you!" He said with icy precision: "I urged the planetary
government to go easy on this irrigation! You yourself denounced me in
the Planetary Council for trying to interfere in civilian affairs! Now
you want to interfere in Survey affairs! I resent it as much as you
did, and with much better reason!"
"_Murderer!_" panted the civilian. "_Murderer!_"
Sandringham snapped off the phone-screen. He swung his chair and
nodded to Hardwick.
"That was the planetary president," he said dryly.
Hardwick sat down. The brown dog blinked his eyes open and then got up
and shook himself.
"I'm holding off those idiots!" said the Sector Chief in suppressed
fury. "I daren't tell him it's more dangerous here than outside! If
or when that fuel blows--Do you realize that the falling of a single
tree limb might set off an explosion in the Reserve-area here that
would--But you know."
"Yes," admitted Hardwick.
He did know. Even forty tons of ship-fuel going off would destroy
this entire end of the island. It would be at least the equivalent of
a megaton fusion bomb explosion. And almost certainly the concussion
would produce violent movement of the rest of the island's surface. But
he was uncomfortable about putting forward his own ideas. He was not a
good salesman. He suspected his own opinions until he had proved them
with extremely painstaking care--for fear of having them adopted on his
past record rather than because they were sound. And then, too, his
plan involved junior ranks being informed about the proposal. If they
accepted a dubious plan on high authority, and the plan miscarried,
it made them share in the mistake. Which hurt their self-confidence.
Young Barnes, now, would undoubtedly obey any order and accept any hint
blindly, and Hardwick honestly did not know why. But as a matter of the
training of junior ranks--
"About the work to be done," said Hardwick. "I imagine the sea-water
freshening plants have closed down?"
"They have!" said Sandringham curtly. "They insisted on piling them up
over my protests. Now if anybody proposed operating one, they'd scream
to high heaven!"
Hardwick felt uncomfortable.
"What was done with the minerals taken out of the sea water?"
"You know how the fresheners work!" said Sandringham. "They pump sea
water in at one end, and at the other, one pipe yields fresh water, and
another heavy brine. They dump the heavy brine back overboard and the
fresh water's pumped up and distributed through the irrigation systems."
"It's too bad some of the salts weren't stored," said Hardwick. "Could
a freshener be started up again?"
Sandringham said with irony:
"Oh, the civilians would love that! No! If any man started up a
water-freshener, the civilians would kill him and smash it!"
"But I think we'll need one. We'll want to irrigate some ground up
here."
"My God! What for?" demanded Sandringham. Then he said shortly: "No!
Don't tell me! Let me try to work it out."
* * * * *
There was silence. The brown dog blinked at Hardwick. He held out his
hand. The dog came sedately to him and bent his head to be scratched.
Hardwick scratched.
After a considerable time, the Sector Chief growled:
"I give up. Do you want to tell me?"
Hardwick said painstakingly:
"In a sense, the trouble here is that there's a swamp underground,
made by irrigation. It slides. It's really a swamp upside down. On
Soris II we had a very odd problem, only the swamp was right-side-up
there. We'd several hundred square miles of swamp that could be used
if we could drain it. We built a soil-dam around it. You know
the trick. You bore two rows of holes twenty feet apart, and put
soil-coagulant in them. It's an old, old device. They used it a couple
of hundred years ago back on Earth. The coagulant seeps out in all
directions and ... well ... coagulates the dirt. Makes it water-tight.
It swells with water and fills the space between the soil-particles. In
a week or two there's a water-tight barrier, made of soil, going down
to bedrock. You might call it a coffer-dam. No water can seep through.
On Soris II we knew that if we could get the water out of the mud
inside this coffer-dam, we'd have cultivable ground."
Sandringham said skeptically:
"But it called for ten years' pumping, eh? When mud doesn't move,
pumping isn't easy!"
"We wanted the soil," said Hardwick. "And we didn't have ten years. The
Soris II colony was supposed to relieve population-pressure on another
planet. The pressure was terrific. We had to be ready to receive some
colonists in eight months. We had to get the water out quicker than it
could be pumped. And there was another problem mixed up with it. The
swamp vegetation was pretty deadly. It had to be gotten rid of, too.
So we made the dam and ... well ... took certain measures and then we
irrigated it. With water from a nearby river. It was very ticklish. But
we had dry ground in four months, with the swamp-vegetation killed and
turning back to humus."
"I ought to read your reports," said Sandringham dourly. "I'm too busy,
ordinarily. But I should read them. How'd you get rid of the water?"
Hardwick told him. He felt uncomfortable about it. The telling required
eighteen words.
"Of course," he added, "we did pick a day when there was a strong wind
from the right quarter."
Sandringham stared at him. Then he said vexedly:
"But how does that apply here? It was sound enough, though I'd never
have thought of it. But what's it got to do with the situation here?"
"This ... swamp, you might say," said Hardwick, "is underground. But
there's forty feet, on an average, of soil on top."
He explained painstakingly what difference that made. It took him three
sentences to make the difference clear.
Sandringham leaned back in his chair. Hardwick scratched the dog,
somewhat embarrassed. Sandringham thought concentratedly.
"I do not see any possible chance," said Sandringham distastefully,
"of doing it any other way. I would never have thought of that! But at
least ninety per cent of the people on this island, Civilian and Survey
together, will die if we don't do something. So we will do this. But
I'm taking it out of your hands, Hardwick."
Hardwick said nothing. He waited.
"Because," said Sandringham, "you're not the man to put over to the
civilians what they must believe. You're not impressive. I know you,
and I know you're a good man in a pinch. But this pinch needs a
salesman. So I'm going to have Werner make the ... er ... pitch to the
planetary government. Results are more important than justice, so
Werner will front this affair."
Hardwick winced a little. But Sandringham was right. He didn't know how
to be impressive. He could not speak with pompous conviction, which
is so much more convincing than reason, to most people. He wasn't the
man to get the co-operation of the non-Service population, because he
could only explain what he knew and believed, and was not practiced in
persuasion. But Werner was. He had the knack of making people believe
anything, not because it was reasonable but because it was oratory.
"I suppose you're right," acknowledged Hardwick. "We need civilian help
and a lot of it. I'm not the man to get it. He is." He did not say
anything about Werner being the man to get credit, whether he deserved
it or not. He patted the dog's head and stood up. "I wish I had a good
supply of soil-coagulant. I need to make a coffer-dam in the reserve
area here. But I think I'll manage."
Sandringham regarded him soberly as he moved to the door. As he was
about to pass out of it, Sandringham said:
"Hardwick--"
"What?"
"Take good care of yourself. Will you?"