Compare with this the real text of Maimonides:[376]

קד עלמת קול אלאטבא קוי׳ נפסאניה וקוי׳ חיואניה וקוי׳ טביעיה.‏‎

ולנפס אנא אלאן פי הדה אלאצטלאח גמיע אפעאל בדן אלאנסאן אלאפעאל

אלבדניה [ואשרף אלאפעאל אלתנפש ובעדה אלנבט[377]] ובעדה אל אחסאס.‏‎

ואשרף אלחואס אלבצר. תם אלסמע ובעד אלאחסאס שהוה אלטעאם

ואלשראב. ובעד דאלך אלכלאם. ובעד דאלך אלתמייז. אעני בה אלתכייל

ואלפכר ובעד דאלך חדכה סאיר אלאעצא עלי מעתאדהא והדה אלרטבה‪(sic)[378]‬

פי אלשרף אנמא הי בחסב צרוריה אלחיאה או צלאחיה אסתמראהא״

ובעד הדה אלמקדמה פלתעלם אן אלטביעה אסם משתרך יקאל עלי

מעאני כתירת ומן גמלה תלך אלמעאני אלקוה אלמדברה לבדן אלחיואן

פאנהא אלאטבא יסמונהא איצי טביעה והדב אלקוה הי איצי . . . . . .‏‎

פאן גלבת ען דלך בדלת מא הוא אשרף ותמסכת באלשרף פאלאשרף

.ובחסב הדה אלתרתיב יעלם אלמרץ אלח׳

‘Thou knowest the opinion of the physicians [concerning] animal

power, vital power, and natural power. But it is my intention

here to call all the functions of man’s body by the one name of

“bodily functions”. [The noblest of the functions is breathing,

next the pulse,[377]] and lastly the senses. Of the senses, the

noblest is sight, which is followed by hearing. Following on the

senses is the appetite for food and drink, after it being speech

and then the mind, by which I mean the thoughts and the intellect.

Next comes the motion of the other parts of the body according to

their customary manner. This arrangement in order of nobility is

only according to the requirements of life or the health of its

faculties.

‘From this preface you will recognize that “nature” is an equivocal

term which can be used in many meanings. One of these meanings [for

example] is “the motive power in the bodies of animals” which the

physicians call “nature” too.... And if you discover this, you will

exchange that which is nobler and retain that which is noblest. By

means of this process of arrangement, a disease can be recognized,’

&c.

This introduction was added when the folios stood in a state of

disorder different from their present one. The catchword at the bottom

of the page [وهذا = and this] points forward to the title already

mentioned,[379] which appears on folio thirty-nine of the present

arrangement. The text below this title is part of the chapter on

discharges and catarrh, so that the folio once followed immediately on

the introduction, being then, too, out of its proper place.

The last page, written in the same hand as the introduction, bears a

piece of some unidentified work and a colophon which reads:

وقد تم هذا الكتاب الشريف تاليف موسى ابن ميمون القرطبى

الاسرايلى رحمه الله مما الف وجرب هذا الكتاب المبارك وعدد فصوله

امراض البدن مما رتبه على اوضاعه (_sic_)مائة وست فصول للجميع

سبع مالة وخمسة وستين (_sic_)٦٥٢٧ تم الكتاب فى سنة

‘This noble book is finished; the composition of Mûsa ibn Maimûn

the Cordovan, the Israelite, to whom God be gracious. This blessed

book is part of that which he composed and tested. The number of

its chapters is 106, dealing with all the diseases of the body,

which he arranged in their proper order.

‘The book was completed in the year 765.’[380]

The number 106, which according to the colophon is the number of

chapters in the book, is really the number of titles in the MS. written

in large hand. Fragments of many chapters whose titles are lost still

remain in it however, while many of the chapters that have preserved

their titles are no longer complete.

Again it may be pointed out that all the known medical works of

Maimonides were written in Arabic and therefore did not need to be

translated into that language as the Bodleian MS. claims to have been.

The spurious title-page thus further betrays itself by saying that this

work was translated from _Hebrew_.

Finally, the identification of the real contents of the Paris MS.

disposes of the last foundation of the idea that Maimonides wrote any

compendium of medicine known as ‫كتاب الاسباب والعلامات‬ (_Tractatus de

Causis et Indiciis Morborum_), and clears up the confusion caused by

the faulty entries in the Paris and Bodleian catalogues.

Studies in the History and Method of Science, vol. 1 (of 2) · 第 143 / 171 题