TRUTH IS STRANGER THAN FICTION.
THIS astonishing statement was received by Claude with a disbelieving
smile; and so convinced was he of its untruth that he affected anger at
what he really believed to be the flippancy of Tait's conduct.
"It is no doubt very amusing for you to ridicule my story," said he,
with cold dignity, "but it is hardly the act of a friend. Some matters
are too serious to form the subject of a jest; and this----"
"I am not jesting," interrupted Tait eagerly. "I assure you that the
tragedy which concerned your parents forms the subject-matter of this
novel. You can read the book yourself, and so be convinced that I am
speaking the truth. The names and places are no doubt fictional, but the
whole story is narrated plainly enough."
Larcher turned over the three volumes with a puzzled expression. That a
story with which he had only become acquainted within the last
twenty-four hours should be printed in a book, and that the book itself
should be brought so speedily under his notice, seemed to him quite
inexplicable. The strangeness of the occurrence paralyzed his will, and,
contrary to his usual self-dependence, he looked to Tait for guidance.
"What do you think of it?" he asked irresolutely.
"Ah! That requires some consideration, my friend. But before we go into
the matter let us understand our position toward each other. You believe
this story of your father's death?"
"Certainly. Mr. Hilliston would not tell me an untruth, and moreover
this bundle of extracts from provincial newspapers confirms his
statement. I truly believe that my father, George Larcher, was murdered
at Horriston in 1866 by--and there you have me--I know not by whom. My
own opinion is that Jeringham is----"
"One moment, Claude! Let us settle all preliminaries. Are you resolved
to take up this matter!"
"I am! I must clear the memory of my mother, and avenge the death of my
father."
"Would it not be better to let sleeping dogs lie?" suggested Tait, with
some hesitation.
"I do not think so," replied Claude quietly. "I am not a sentimental
man, as you know; and my nature is of too practical a kind to busy
itself with weaving ropes of sand. Yet in this instance I feel that it
is my duty to hunt down and punish the coward who killed my father. When
I find him, and punish him, this ghost of '66 will be laid aside;
otherwise, it will continue to haunt and torture me all my life."
"But your business?"
"I shall lay aside my business till this matter is settled to my
satisfaction. As you know, I have a private income, and am not compelled
to work for my daily bread. Moreover, the last four years have brought
me in plenty of money, so that I can afford to indulge my fancy. And my
fancy," added Claude in a grim tone, "is to dedicate the rest of my life
to discovering the truth. Do you not approve of my decision?"
"Yes, and no," said Tait evasively. "I think your hunt for an
undescribed criminal, whose crime dates back twenty-five years, is
rather a waste of time. All clews must have disappeared. It seems
hopeless for you to think of solving the mystery. And if you do,"
continued the little man earnestly, "if you do, what possible pleasure
can you derive from such a solution? Your father is a mere name to you,
so filial love can have nothing to do with the matter. Moreover, the
criminal may be dead--he may be----"
"You have a thousand and one objections," said Larcher impatiently,
"none of which have any weight with me. I am in the hands of Fate. A
factor has entered into my life which has changed my future. Knowing
what I now know, I cannot rest until I learn the truth. Do you know the
story of Mozart?" he added abruptly.
"I know several stories of Mozart. But this special one I may not know."
"It is told either of Mozart or Mendelssohn! I forget which," pursued
Larcher, half to himself. "When Mozart--let us say Mozart--was ill in
bed, one of his friends struck a discord on the piano, which required
what is technically known as a resolution for its completion. The
omission so tortured the sensitive ear of the musician that, when his
friend departed, he rose from his bed and completed the discord in
accordance with musical theory. Till that was done he could not rest."
"And the point of your parable?"
"Can you not see? This incomplete case of murder is my discord. I must
complete it by discovering the criminal, and so round off the case, or
submit to be tortured by its hinted mystery all my life. It is not
filial love, it is not sentiment, it is not even curiosity, it is simply
a desire to complete a matter hitherto left undone. Till I know the
sequel to the Horriston tragedy, I shall feel in a state of
suspense--and suspense," added Claude emphatically, "is torture to men
of my temperament."
"Your reason is a trifle whimsical," said Tait, smiling at the
application of this musical theory to the present instance, "but I can
understand your feelings. Indeed, I feel the same way myself."
"You!"
"Why not? In reading 'A Whim of Fate,' I could not go to rest without
knowing the end, and I feel a like curiosity toward this tragedy of real
life. I shall not be content till I learn the truth. My feelings are
precisely the same as your own. Therefore," pursued Tait, with emphasis,
"I propose to assist you in your search. We will discuss the matter
calmly, and see what is best to be done. In spite of the lapse of
five-and-twenty years, who knows but what we may lay hands on the
murderer of your father, who is no doubt now living in fancied
security."
"Unless he is dead."
"Who is making the objections now?" said Tait, smiling. "Well, Claude,
will you accept me as your brother detective in this matter?"
"Willingly, and I thank you for this proof of your friendship."
"I am afraid there is an element of selfishness mixed up in my offer,"
said Tait, shrugging his shoulders. "It is not every day that one can
find an interesting case like this to dissect. Excitement is the joy of
life, and I rather think we will be able to extract a great deal from
this investigation. Come! We now understand one another."
Larcher grasped the hand held out to him, and gratefully accepted the
aid thus offered. From that moment the two dedicated themselves to hunt
down the criminal at whose hands George Larcher had met his death. It
was as strange a compact as had ever been made. Halting Nemesis, who had
rested all these years, once more resumed her stealthy progress, and
before her ran these two young men, as ministers of her long-delayed
revenge. This junction of unforeseen circumstances savored of the
dramatic.
"The first thing to be done," said Tait, when the compact was thus
concluded, "is to read both cases."
"Both cases!" repeated Claude curiously.
"Yes! You remember how Browning gives half a dozen aspects of the same
case in his 'Ring and the Book.' In a minor degree we benefit in the
same manner. There," said Tait, pointing to the roll of newspapers, "is
the case from the real point of view, and here, in these three volumes,
we will find the same case as considered in a fictional fashion by the
novelist. By reading both we may come to some conclusion whence to start
in our talk. Last night you read the newspapers; I the novel. To-day we
will reverse the process. I will view the affair as set forth by the
provincial press, and you will devour the three volumes of John Parver
as I did last night."
"And afterward?"
"Eh! Who can say?" replied Tait, shrugging his shoulders. Several
sojourns in Paris had left their trace in Gallic gestures, and possibly
in Gallic flippancy. "We must know what foundation we have before we
build."
Claude nodded. He was of the same way of thinking himself, and commented
on his friend's speech after his own fashion.
"Yes," said he a trifle vindictively, "we must build our gallows stanch
and strong. You can proceed with your toilet, and afterward we will read
novels and newspapers, as you suggest. The result of our reading must
appear in our actions. I rather think," he added slowly, "that the
result will be a visit to Mr. Hilliston."
"Without doubt. He was an eye-witness, and it is always preferable to
obtain evidence first hand."
"Then," said Claude reflectively, "there is Mrs. Bezel."
"Quite so! The enterprising lady who started the whole thing. Was she
also an eye-witness?"
"I can't say. Her name does not appear in the newspapers."
"Humph!" muttered Tait, scratching his chin. "Nor in those three volumes
can I find a character likely to develop into Mrs. Bezel of Hampstead."
"I wonder who she can be," said Claude curiously, "or what she can have
to do with the case."
"That we must find out. Depend upon it, there is more in this case than
in newspapers or novel. We must find out all about Mrs. Bezel, and,"
said Tait, with emphasis, "we must learn all that is to be learned
concerning John Parver."
"Who is John Parver?"
"Who was the Man in the Iron Mask?" replied Tait, in a bantering tone.
"I cannot say. But whomsoever he may be, he knows all about this case."
"There is that possibility, certainly," assented the other smoothly,
"but I think it hardly likely. A man of to-day would not readily come
across the account of a tragedy occurring in a little known town
twenty-five years ago. Do you know," he added, after a pause, "that it
occurs to me that the publication of this book, containing an account of
the case, may have been the cause which incited Mrs. Bezel to write the
letter."
"I thought so myself. Mrs. Bezel may think that John Parver is a _nom de
plume_ assumed by Claude Larcher."
"Or another alternative. Mrs. Bezel may be John Parver herself. It is
the fashion nowadays for women to write under the names of men."
There was a few minutes' silence, during which each man was intent on
his own thoughts. Tait, whose brain turned quicker than that of
Larcher, was the first to break the silence.
"Well," said he, moving briskly toward his bedroom door, "before we can
say or do anything we must learn the facts of the case."
As he vanished into his room Claude laid his hand on the first of the
three volumes.