_History of American Literature_, Moses Coit Tyler.
_Introduction to American Literature_, Henry S. Pancoast.
_Studies in American Literature_, Charles Noble.
_Introduction to American Literature_, Brander Matthews.
"Gloom and Cheer in Hawthorne," _Critic_, 45: 28-36.
"Hawthorne and his Circle," _Nation_, 77: 410-411.
"Hawthorne as seen by his Publisher," _Critic_, 45: 51-55.
"Hawthorne from an English Point of View." _Critic_, 45: 60-66.
"Hawthorne's Last Years," _Critic_, 45: 67-71.
"Life of Hawthorne," _Atlantic Monthly_, 90: 563-567,