CHAPTER 9. THE LAW OF DIMINISHING RETURNS

1. Is it possible to do twice the amount of business in any store-room

by doubling the stock and the force of clerks?

2. Is it possible to expand a university indefinitely by increasing the

force of teachers and the equipment, without enlarging the buildings?

3. Why do men cultivate two acres instead of one? Where land is

plentiful, why do not men cultivate two acres instead of one?

4. Are there any things, not free goods, that could be indefinitely

increased without increasing difficulty?

5. English farmers raise thirty-five bushels of wheat per acre,

Americans perhaps fifteen; why this difference?

6. Why did people go to Dakota and Iowa when there was still room in New

England?

7. Why put up a twenty-story building? Why not build a fifty-story one?

NOTE.--The broad reading here given to the law of

diminishing returns is so recent that even the latest texts

have recognized it only in a partial manner, defining "the

law" in the old terms confined to land. For the old

statement see J. S. Mill, _Principles of Political Economy_

(1846), Bk. I, ch. XII. Writers even so advanced as Alfred

Marshall follow Mill with no essential modification. For a

good historical account of the doctrine see Edwin Cannan,

_History of the Theories of Production and Distribution_,

pp. 147-182 (1893; 2d ed., with additions, 1903), which

advances no positive theory, but makes evident many

inconsistencies in the older view. A keen analysis and

important contribution to economic thought was made by J.

R. Commons, _Distribution of Wealth_, pp. 116-159 (1895).

John B. Clark, in various earlier articles, and in his

_Distribution of Wealth_ (1900), has done more than any one

else to develop the conception of "a universal law of

economic variation." In magazine articles by various

writers, the same idea has been developed, but no

thorough-going application of it has been made in the

available text-books.

The Principles of Economics, with Applications to Practical Problems · 第 9 / 57 章