"PER INCERTAS, CERTA AMOR."
Sir Arthur glanced round the bleak little wayside station with
disapproval. The December day was grey and raw; the December wind
blustered along the exposed platform, in chilling tempestuous gusts;
and the upland country that stretched to right and left of the line,
wore a highly uninviting aspect.
"Now, what is Margaret doing in this desolate part of the world?" he
reflected irritably; "and why does she send me such a ridiculously
mysterious telegram? Women have no sense of proportion; they must
always indulge in subtleties and mysteries." These irascible
meditations brought him to the station exit, before which stood a
closed brougham, the only conveyance of any sort within sight. Beyond
the tiny station, a white road wound away over the moors, but,
excepting for two cottages on the brow of the first hill, there was no
sign to be seen of any human habitation.
"Has that carriage been sent to meet Sir Arthur Congreve?" the old
gentleman enquired of the one porter lounging by the gate, and the man
nodded before replying with bucolic slowness:--
"That carriage be come from t' 'White Horse' up to Graystone, to fetch
Sir Arthur Congreve. Driver he told me so hisself."
"Very well, very well," Sir Arthur said impatiently, making his way to
the carriage door, and opening it, before the porter, now engaged in
thoughtfully scratching his head, had collected his wits sufficiently
to perform this act of courtesy for the traveller. "I conclude you
know where I am to be driven," he added, speaking to the man on the box.
"Yes, sir; to the house in the valley; the house where the
gentleman----"
"That will do, as long as you know where you are to go," Sir Arthur
said, cutting short the coachman's volubility, and entering the
brougham, glad to sit back amongst the cushions, and shut the window
against the sweeping blast.
The uplands looked their very greyest and worst on that December day.
A low grey sky stooped to meet the hill-sides, on which brown heather
and brown bracken made a depressing tone of colour, to mingle with the
greyness of the clouds, and of the mists that crept up from the
valleys. The bareness of the wide stretch of moor was broken here and
there by a clump of fir-trees, which showed dark and sombre against the
grey background, and the fogginess of the atmosphere obscured the great
view, which was usually the chief charm of the uplands. Sir Arthur was
at no time an admirer of scenery, and to-day he turned his gaze
shudderingly from the barren landscape; and, drawing a paper from his
pocket, proceeded to bury himself in its contents, and to thrust the
outer world as far as possible away from his consciousness. By nature
an unimaginative man, he had ruthlessly stamped out any germ of
imagination or poetry, which might have been latent within him, setting
himself with grim resolution to thrust away the beautiful as a snare,
and to regard everything about him as merely temporal and destructible.
He forgot, or perhaps he deliberately chose not to recognise, that the
eternal is set around the temporal, not as a thing apart, but
encompassing it, permeating it, so that temporal and eternal are one.
He had sternly set his face against all the softer aspects of life,
doing his duty grimly, and with stiff back, disinclined at any time to
any relaxation in discipline either for himself or his
fellow-sinners--more ready to rule by fear than by love, a man who
would have made an equally excellent Ironside or Grand Inquisitor,
according to the peculiar turn of his religious convictions.
As he drove now along the lonely white road, his thoughts chiefly
centred themselves upon Margaret, his beautiful sister Margaret, who,
in spite of her sins and follies, as he considered them to be, had
always held a place in her brother's heart. He gave her the place
grudgingly; he would have gone to the stake rather than confess that
her beauty made, or ever had made, any appeal to him. And yet, as he
was driven quickly onwards under the lowering skies, it was his
sister's beautiful face that rose persistently before him, her face, as
he had last seen it, when she was a radiant girl, in the glory of her
happy girlhood. It was odd; it was even annoying to him that just this
particular vision out of the past should fill his mind now, but for
once in his grim and well-disciplined life, he was unable to drive away
the haunting vision.
The garden of the old house made the setting of the picture--the garden
that was now his own, and the sunk lawn, with the sun-dial amongst the
rose-trees, that had been his father's pride. Margaret had stood
beside the sun-dial, on that far-off June day, her fingers lightly
tracing the motto that ran round the dial's face, her laughing eyes
lifted to her brother.
"Ah! but you don't believe in the motto, you see." The words came
echoing back to him across the years, until he almost felt as though he
could actually hear the low voice again, and Margaret's voice had
always had such unspeakable charm.
"You think a motto like this just silly and sentimental, don't you,
Arthur?" And once more her fingers had traced the faint lettering,
whilst she slowly read the words aloud.
"_Per incertas, certa amor_." (Through uncertainty, certain is love.)
"I mean that to be my motto, as well as the motto of the sun-dial";
just a tiny ring of defiance seemed to creep into her voice with the
last words; Sir Arthur remembered it even now, and he had answered her
gravely, out of the depths of his convictions. He had spoken with
solemnity, of duty, as higher than love; and she had laughed again, her
deep soft laugh, though the look in her eyes had belied her laughter.
"Love is the greatest thing in the world," she had said, very slowly,
very quietly, but the words rang with the sureness of a great
certainty. "Love is the only thing that matters in all the world,
because to love properly is to be perfect. Duty, right, goodness, they
all follow upon love--real love. Love is the greatest thing in the
world. Through all uncertainty--love is--sure."
Well, she had acted up to her creed. She had loved and suffered for a
man who was not worthy to touch the hem of her garment, in his, Sir
Arthur's, opinion;--but women, as he had before reflected, women had no
sense of proportion; they were incomprehensible; Margaret no less
incomprehensible than all the rest of her sex. He had reached this
point in his reflections when he observed that the carriage was no
longer bowling along the smooth high road, but had turned into a steep,
and rather rough lane, which wound downwards between high hedges, that
presently merged themselves into dense woods, ending abruptly at last
in a small clearing, upon which stood a house surrounded by a wall.
Before the green gate in this wall, the carriage stopped. Sir Arthur's
keen eyes noted with approval, the quietly respectful manner of the old
servant who admitted him; he had been more than half expecting to find
himself in some kind of dread and unwonted Bohemia, the very thought of
which sickened his soul; and Elizabeth, with that air of the
old-fashioned maid, who has only lived in the right sort of house,
impressed him favourably.
"My mistress wished me to take you straight to her room, sir," she
said; "and the doctor asked me to say, that any great agitation would
be very bad for her."
"Is she ill, then?" The question came with sharpness.
"Yes, sir, very ill. The doctor is anxious to keep her as quiet as
possible; but he thought it best she should see you, her heart is so
set upon it."
Those words made Sir Arthur's own heart contract a little, and before
his mental vision there flashed again the beautiful radiant face of the
girl in the white gown, the girl who had stood beside the sun-dial,
saying in her deep sweet voice--
"Love is the greatest thing in the world."
The words still rang in his brain as Elizabeth ushered him into a big
bedroom, and his eyes fell upon the woman propped up with pillows, her
face turned towards the door.
The radiant face of the girl beside the sun-dial seemed to fade slowly
from his mind, whilst he stood silently looking at the woman in the
bed, the woman who put out her hand to him with a faint smile, and said
softly--
"It was good of you to come, Arthur. You will let us meet now as
friends after all these years?"
The words were a question rather than an assertion, but he did not
answer the question. He stood as though rooted to the floor, staring
at her, in an astonishment too great at first for words. Then he said
slowly--
"But I shouldn't have known you--I shouldn't have known you, Margaret.
I can't believe----" He broke off abruptly, a tremor in his voice, and
Margaret said gently--
"I daresay I am very much changed since you last saw me. In those days
I was only a girl; now I am a woman, who has known so much of life--so
very much of life. It seems as though my irresponsible girlhood
belongs to another existence, and life has set its marks upon my face."
"Yes," he answered vaguely, still staring at her. "I am afraid--your
life----"
"There has been very much sorrow--and very much joy," she interrupted,
as gently as she had spoken before; "and now--I am within sight of the
end, and--I am glad."
He came close to her, and for the first time touched her hand.
"Why do you say that?" he asked, his usually grim voice curiously
softened. "You are ill now, but I hope with care--in time----"
She interrupted him again, a smile on her face.
"No, it is not a question of care, or time. I am glad it is not. It
is only a question of how long my strength will hold out. You
know--Max--is--dead?" She said the words as simply as though she were
merely saying that somebody had gone into the next room, and her
brother started.
"Dead?" he exclaimed. "No; I did not know. I heard he was in England,
heard it vaguely and undecidedly, and I have been trying to find you
both. I wanted to prevent any--any talk--any scandal."
"There need never be any talk now. He came to England--only a few
weeks before he died. He--had been--wandering about Europe--and then
he came--to England--to die." She spoke quietly, but the pauses in her
sentence, seemed to show what a mental strain she was enduring.
"Marion helped him to get here. I was too ill to do it, and--I did not
dare to do too much, lest through me any clue to his whereabouts should
be given. I do not think he was ever safe--not safe for a single
instant. But--he is out of their reach now--safe at last."
Sir Arthur's mouth set tightly, there was a gleam of indignation in his
eyes, but he remembered the doctor's orders, and refrained from
uttering the biting speech upon his lips.
"Marion--who is Marion?" he said.
"She was English maid to Max's mother--a faithful soul, such a faithful
soul. All our letters to one another passed through her hands. She
took this house; she brought Max here; she sent for me; and then--the
long strain told. She had borne so much; she could bear no more.
It--was all very dreadful; she lost her reason; she went suddenly mad;
and the doctors do not think she can ever be well again. She is quite
happy now, quite peaceful, they tell me, like a little child, but her
mind has gone."
"And you, Margaret, surely now you must regret," Sir Arthur began
impetuously, the natural man asserting itself, in spite of all the
doctor's warnings. But again his sister's low voice broke the thread
of his speech.
"Regret?" she said. "Oh! no. It hurts me to think that I hurt our
father and mother, but for myself--I cannot be sorry. I love him so,
and for all our lives together, I had his love--he was always mine."
"But"--do what he would, Sir Arthur felt impelled to give voice to the
flood of thought within him--"he was not worthy of you, Margaret. You
can't pretend that he was worthy of your love?" A great rush of colour
poured over her white face, her thin hands trembled.
"Worthiness or unworthiness do not seem to come into it at all," she
answered, her voice all shaken and low. "When one loves, one loves in
spite of everything--in spite of everything."
Something in her tone, and in the strange illumination of her eyes,
momentarily silenced Sir Arthur; he dimly felt himself to be in the
presence of a force infinitely greater than anything that had ever come
into his own experience. He would not have owned that he had
limitations--to a man of his type, the difficulty of owning to
limitations is almost insuperable--but far down in the depths of his
mind, he vaguely realised that Margaret had reached a height to which
he had never attained.
"And--after all, Arthur--whatever you may feel," Margaret went on, more
quietly, the colour ebbing from her face, "doesn't it still seem fairer
to say--_De mortuis_----"
Sir Arthur bent his head; and before his mind rose the half-defaced
letters of that other Latin proverb, which Margaret had traced with her
finger on the sun-dial, out amongst the roses in the sunshine of June.
"_Per incertas, certa amor_."
And she was still certain of her love--in spite of--everything!
Silence fell between them after those last words of hers; and it was
she who presently broke it, speaking with an effort, and in more
ordinary and matter-of-fact tones.
"But I did not telegraph to you to come here, in order to worry you
with any of my own affairs. I thought I ought to ask you to come,
because a strange thing has happened--a most curious coincidence.
Bring that chair nearer to the bed, and sit down. You look so judicial
standing over me."
Sir Arthur meekly obeyed, feeling within himself a faint wonder, at his
own unquestioning obedience, yet compelled to do what that low voice
commanded. There was a certain queenliness about this woman, a
dignified aloofness, which had a curiously compelling effect upon those
about her. The man who so obediently drew up a chair, and seated
himself, felt it hard to realise that this was his own sister, his
younger sister Margaret, whom in the days of their unregenerate youth,
some people had called "Peg." It had been almost impossible to see in
her changed face, the features of the beautiful girl who had laughed
amongst the roses by the sun-dial, and yet, in spite of the change
wrought by sorrow, and suffering, and the ploughshares of life, she was
regally beautiful, even more beautiful than in the days of her girlhood.
"I understood from your telegram that you wanted to see me about
Ellen's pendant, though I cannot conceive why you should know anything
about its whereabouts."
"I am afraid I don't know anything about _Ellen's_ pendant," was the
answer. "But I do know something about the pendant you mistook for
Ellen's, on Christmas Day. The ornament Christina Moore was wearing,
was not Ellen's, but her own."
"Nonsense, my dear Margaret," Sir Arthur answered testily. "The jewel
is unique, and I know every detail of it. I hope you have not brought
me here to try to persuade me not to prosecute that wretched nurse of
Cicely's. Cicely herself is also trying to make me act against my
better judgment, and refrain from calling in the police."
"I think you won't want to prosecute, when you hear why I sent for
you," was the gentle rejoinder. "It was a very weighty reason that
made me ask you to come, Arthur."
"Why did you telegraph to me?" he asked. "Tell me those weighty
reasons----"
"A very strange coincidence has happened, one of those coincidences
which are more common in real life, than people think. I--have
discovered--beyond all possibilities of doubt, that Christina Moore--is
our own niece. She is Helen's daughter."
For a long moment Sir Arthur said no single word; he only looked at his
sister blankly, with a stare of incredulous astonishment. Then he said
slowly:--
"Our--our--niece? Helen's daughter? Impossible--quite, quite
impossible. My dear Margaret--you have been taken in by an impostor.
Such an idea is incredible. And--what proofs have you?"
"There is no question of being deceived. The discovery was not forced
upon my attention; I made it for myself. Christina had no idea that
there was any relationship between us. She was taken completely by
surprise, when I told her she was my sister's child."
"You have let your imagination run away with you, Margaret. How can
you be sure of what you say? Where are your proofs? I don't believe
for a moment, that Miss Moore had any connection with Helen. I don't
believe it at all."
And as Sir Arthur's lips went into a determined line, Margaret smiled
faintly, remembering the days of their youth, when her brother had set
his mouth in just such obstinate curves, if he were in disagreement
with any of his family.
Very quietly, but very firmly, Margaret made herself heard, dominating
the man by that strength of personality, of which he had already become
strangely aware; forcing him, against his own inclinations, to hear her
story, from beginning to end.
"At present I have, as you say, no proofs," she said. "No legal
proofs. But those should be the least difficult to find. We must get
Helen's marriage certificate, and Christina's birth and baptismal
certificates. I have been thinking it all out, when I lay awake at
night. And we must make all necessary enquiries at Staveley--the
village where Christina lived with her father and mother.
Unfortunately, the clergyman she knew there, is dead; and the
solicitor, who seems to have done Helen's business for her, is in
Africa, and Christina does not know his address. But--the pendant, the
emerald pendant, was certainly sent to Helen by our mother; and before
Helen died, she tried to send you a message. She sank into
unconsciousness with your name on her lips--'Tell Arthur'--those were
the very last words she spoke."
Sir Arthur's severe face softened; some of the hardness in his eyes
died away; it was in a shaken and softened voice that he said:
"It is difficult even now to believe that all this can be true; and
yet--there is a certain ring of truth about it. I should like to see
this Miss Moore. I cannot understand why, if she was innocent of
theft, she ran away from Bramwell."
"She is very young; she was very frightened. She knew she could
produce no proof of her innocence. And you must remember, Arthur, that
I am the only person living, who knows there was a replica of Ellen's
pendant. Christina's coming to me was providential. I--think she was
sent into my care."
Sir Arthur was silent; indeed, he spoke no more until Christina,
summoned by Margaret's bell, came into the room, her face flushing and
paling by turns, when she saw the upright figure seated beside the bed.
"I wished to see you," Sir Arthur said, in the magisterial tones which
were wont to strike terror into the hearts of guilty offenders. "My
sister tells me a very remarkable story; and although, pending much
more absolute proof, I suspend judgment, I should like to hear your own
view of this strange thing."
"I don't know what to think about it all," the girl answered, a little
shrinking fear in her eyes, as they met those piercing blue ones. "I
have told--everything I know--to--to--her," she faltered, glancing at
Margaret. "I can only say it all over again to you. It is all true.
I have never in all my life said anything that wasn't true," she added
proudly.
"Your mother never mentioned any of her relations to you, by name?
Never spoke of her old home?"
"She spoke of her home, and always as if she had loved it dearly, as if
it had broken her heart to leave it. But she never told me where it
was; she never said any name, until the day she died; until she gave me
the----and said 'Tell Arthur'--I think perhaps she could not bear to
speak of her people, because she loved them all so much, that it hurt
her to talk about them."
"The whole matter must be carefully investigated. I can accept nothing
without proof, but, naturally, if it can be proved that you are our
sister's child, suitable care will be taken of you. And for the
present," he still spoke in the judicial tones, to which the Bench was
accustomed, "for the present I shall waive the matter of the pendant.
Meanwhile----"
"Meanwhile, my own strong feeling is that Christina should go back to
Bramwell," Margaret put in; "it is not fair to put Lady Cicely to
inconvenience, and Christina feels, with me, that she had no right to
run away, and leave such a kind and considerate employer in the lurch.
If Lady Cicely would like to have her back, Christina is sure she ought
to go."
"Yes, indeed," Christina said eagerly, a little shamed look in her
eyes. "I know I ought never to have come away, but I was so
frightened, so dreadfully frightened," and she clasped her hands
together, with an unconsciously childlike gesture, that stirred the
latent humanity in Sir Arthur. Beneath his crust of frigidity, there
was a certain kindliness of heart, and Christina's appealing eyes, and
suddenly clasped hands, moved him to say, not ungently--
"Well, well, there is no occasion to be frightened now. I will look
into the whole of this strange business, and nothing more shall be said
about the pendant, until I have found out whatever there is to be
found."
"I shall leave the pendant here," Christina said quickly, her eyes
meeting those of the old man with a flash of pride, that seemed to give
man and girl a sudden curious likeness to one another. "I will fetch
it now and give it to her, and then you will know that I am
honest--that I shall not run away with it. I will fetch it directly,
and give it--to--Aunt Margaret!"