ARISTOTLE TAUGHT THE SAME THING.

Aristotle, who lived at a later period, says that the First Principle

is separated from (sense-objects), and that it is intelligible.[252]

But when Aristotle says that He thinks himself, Aristotle degrades Him

from the first rank. Aristotle also asserts the existence of other

intelligible entities in a number equal to the celestial spheres,

so that each one of them might have a principle of motion. About

the intelligible entities, therefore, Aristotle advances a teaching

different from that of Plato, and as he has no plausible reason for

this change, he alleges necessity. A well-grounded objection might here

be taken against him. It seems more reasonable to suppose that all the

spheres co-ordinated in a single system should, all of them, stand

in relation to the One and the First. About Aristotle's views this

question also might be raised: do the intelligible entities depend on

the One and First, or are there several principles for the intelligible

entities? If the intelligible entities depend on the One, they will

no doubt be arranged symmetrically, as, in the sense-sphere, are the

spheres, each of which contains another, and of which a single One,

exterior to the others, contains them, and dominates them all. Thus, in

this case, the first intelligible entity will contain all entities up

there, and will be the intelligible world. Just as the spheres are not

empty, as the first is full of stars, and as each of the others also

is full of them, so above their motors will contain many entities, and

everything will have a more real existence. On the other hand, if each

of the intelligible entities is a principle, all will be contingent.

How then will they unite their action, and will they, by agreement,

contribute in producing a single effect, which is the harmony of

heaven? Why should sense-objects, in heaven, equal in number their

intelligible motors? Again, why are there several of these, since they

are incorporeal, and since no matter separates them from each other?

Plotinos: Complete Works, v. 1 In Chronological Order, Grouped in Four Periods · 第 325 / 467 题