THIS WOULD INTERFERE WITH SELF-CONSCIOUSNESS AND RESPONSIBILITY.

To begin with, this Necessity and Fate would by their excess destroy

themselves, and render impossible the sequence and concatenation of

the causes. It is, indeed, absurd to insist that our members are moved

by Fate when they are set in motion, or innervated, by the "governing

principle." It is a mistake to suppose that there is a part which

imparts motion, and on the other hand, a part which receives it from

the former; it is the governing principle that moves the leg, as it

would any other part. Likewise, if in the universe exists but a single

principle which "acts and reacts," if things derive from each other

by a series of causes each of which refers to the preceding one, it

will no longer be possible to say truly that all things arise through

causes, for their totality will constitute but a single being. In that

case, we are no longer ourselves; actions are no longer ours; it is no

longer we who reason; it is a foreign principle which reasons, wills,

and acts in us, just as it is not our feet that walk, but we who walk

by the agency of our feet. On the contrary, common sense admits that

every person lives, thinks, and acts by his own individual, proper

life, thought and action; to each must be left the responsibility of

his actions, good or evil, and not attribute shameful deeds to the

universal cause.

Plotinos: Complete Works, v. 1 In Chronological Order, Grouped in Four Periods · 第 198 / 467 题