EVEN INVOLUNTARINESS DOES NOT AFFECT SPONTANEITY THAT IS RESPONSIBLE.

Unjust actions are involuntary only in this sense that one does not

have the will to commit a fault; but this circumstance does not hinder

the spontaneity of the action. However, when one acts spontaneously,

one is responsible for the fault; one would avoid responsibility for

the fault only if one were not the author of the action. To say that

the wicked are such necessarily, does not mean that they undergo

an external constraint, but that their character is constituted by

wickedness. The influence of the course of the stars does not destroy

our liberty, for, if every action in us were determined by the exterior

influence of such agents, everything would go on as these agents

desired it; consequently, men would not commit any actions contrary

to the will of these agents. If the divinities alone were the authors

of all our actions, there would be no impious persons; therefore,

impiety is due to men. It is true that, once the cause is given, the

effects will follow, if only the whole series of causes be given. But

man himself is one of these causes; he therefore does good by his own

nature, and he is a free cause.

Plotinos: Complete Works, v. 4 In Chronological Order, Grouped in Four Periods · 第 45 / 382 题