THE BATTLE OF FESTUBERT
The 1st Battalion
[Sidenote: May 1915.]
In May the French resolved to make a determined attack on the German
line in Artois, and in order to prevent the enemy moving up any
reinforcements to support that part of the line, Sir John French agreed
to attack simultaneously at Festubert, where the German Seventh Corps
was posted.
[Sidenote: May 9.]
Sir Douglas Haig, who was entrusted with the task, began operations on
May 9, when the Eighth Division captured some of the enemy's first-line
trenches at Rougebanc, while the First and Indian Divisions attacked
south of Neuve Chapelle. But the enemy's positions proved much stronger
than had been expected, and little progress was made in either place.
During this attack the 1st Battalion Grenadiers was never engaged, but
remained in close support. Lieut.-Colonel Corkran himself accompanied
the Eighth Division, and remained with it in case the services of the
Battalion should be required.
[Sidenote: May 10-11.]
A second attack was made by the Eighth Division east of Festubert on the
10th, preceded by a long artillery bombardment, the Seventh Division
remaining in reserve. During the interval between the attacks of the 9th
and 15th, the Seventh Division was brought up on the right of the First
Corps, the Canadian Division being in support, while the Indian Corps
still remained on the left.
On the night of the 10th the 1st Battalion marched to Bethune, where it
was billeted in a tobacco factory, and on the 11th moved to Hinges. The
roll of officers of the Battalion was as follows:
Lieut.-Colonel C. E. Corkran, C.M.G., Commanding Officer.
Major G. F. Trotter, M.V.O., D.S.O., Second in Command.
Lieut. C. Mitchell, Adjutant.
2nd Lieut. E. H. J. Duberly, Machine-gun Officer.
Lieut. J. Teece, Quartermaster.
Capt. M. E. Makgill-Crichton-Maitland, King's Company.
Capt. W. S. Pilcher, King's Company.
Lieut. F. C. St. Aubyn, King's Company.
Lieut. Lord Dalkeith, King's Company.
2nd Lieut. C. G. Goschen, King's Company.
Capt. F. L. V. Swaine, No. 2 Company.
Lieut. Lord Stanley, No. 2 Company.
Lieut. R. P. de P. Trench, No. 2 Company.
2nd Lieut. C. Dudley Smith, No. 2 Company.
Capt. J. S. Hughes (attached from 2nd Batt.), No. 3 Company.
Lieut. O. Wakeman, No. 3 Company.
2nd Lieut. P. K. Stephenson, No. 3 Company.
2nd Lieut. L. E. Parker, No. 3 Company.
Capt. G. C. G. Moss, No. 4 Company.
2nd Lieut, the Hon. C. Hope Morley, No. 4 Company.
2nd Lieut. A. B. Lawford, No. 4 Company.
2nd Lieut. E. O. R. Wakeman, No. 4 Company.
Capt. W. E. Nicol, Grenade Company.
Capt. C. H. Greville, Grenade Company.
Capt. G. Petit, R.A.M.C.
_Attached_--Lieut. F. M. Dickinson.
[Illustration: Festubert. Position on the evening of May 17th.]
[Sidenote: May 15.]
On the 15th the Seventh Division moved up to the trenches north of
Festubert, and the 1st Battalion Grenadiers marched to the assembly
trenches in and around Dead Cow Farm. The attack was opened by the 20th
Brigade. On the right was the 2nd Battalion Scots Guards, supported by
the 2nd Battalion Gordon Highlanders, and on the left the 2nd Battalion
Border Regiment, supported by the 1st Battalion Grenadiers, while the
6th Battalion Gordon Highlanders was in reserve. On the right of the
20th Brigade was the 22nd Brigade, and on the left the Second Division.
[Sidenote: May 16.]
The attack began at 3.15 A.M. on the 16th. The Scots Guards met with
little opposition, and easily secured their objective, but the 2nd
Border Regiment had hardly started when it came under a murderous
machine-gun fire. It lost a large number of men and most of its
officers, including the Commanding Officer, Lieut.-Colonel Wood, but it
succeeded nevertheless in reaching the enemy's trenches. In the
meantime, however, the 2nd Battalion Scots Guards had pushed on beyond
the German support line, so that its left was in the air. Even in the
support trenches, which were only thirty yards in rear of the front
line, the 1st Battalion Grenadiers came in for a great deal of shelling,
and one shell burst in the middle of No. 8 Platoon, killing four men and
wounding many others, including Lieutenant Dickinson and Lieutenant St.
Aubyn, who was struck in the face by a piece of shrapnel. All the time a
stream of wounded from the front trenches was passing by, some walking
and some on stretchers.
The machine-guns under Lieutenant Duberly were sent up to support the
Scots Guards, and helped them greatly. With a view to protecting their
left flank, the 1st Battalion Grenadiers was now ordered forward. It was
about 10 A.M. Lieut.-Colonel Corkran, who saw clearly that his Battalion
would share the same fate as the Border Regiment, if they advanced
against the machine-guns, which had inflicted such loss, decided to move
his Battalion farther to the south, and advance from the original
forming-up trench of the 2nd Battalion Scots Guards, where a
communication trench was being constructed by the Gordon Highlanders.
Down this trench the 1st Battalion rushed, jumping over a mass of
wounded men as it went, and when it reached the German front-line
trench, the King's Company under Captain Maitland, and No. 3 under
Captain Hughes, remained to consolidate it, while No. 4 under Captain
Moss, followed by No. 2 under Captain Swaine, pushed on to prolong the
left of the Scots Guards.
Lieut.-Colonel Corkran met Lieut.-Colonel Cator, commanding the 2nd
Battalion Scots Guards, and discussed the situation, which was very
obscure. One and a half companies of the Scots Guards had most gallantly
pushed on right through the German lines, and had completely lost touch
with the rest of the Battalion. It was afterwards discovered that they
had been surrounded, and cut off by the enemy. The left of that
Battalion was consequently in the air. It was determined that the Scots
Guards and No. 2 Company Grenadiers under Captain Swaine should
consolidate the line they had reached, namely, the German third line;
No. 4 Company under Captain Moss was to advance over the open on the
left, and attack a small house still held by the enemy about six hundred
yards off; No. 3 Company under Captain Hughes, from the original German
front trench, was to make a bombing attack down a German communication
trench leading apparently to the small house; and the King's Company
under Captain Maitland was to remain where it was in the German front
trench in reserve.
Captain Hughes with No. 3 Company made a most successful advance down
the German trench, clearing about three hundred yards of it, and killing
a number of Germans, while the bombers under Captain Nicol were equally
successful down another German communication trench in which they
captured a large number of prisoners. But the advance of No. 4 Company
was held up almost immediately by machine-gun fire from the small house.
The leading platoon under Lieutenant E. O. R. Wakeman was practically
annihilated, and its gallant commander, as he pluckily led his men on to
this death-trap, was killed. Second Lieutenant C. Hope Morley was struck
by a bullet in the eyes and blinded. Finding any farther advance
impossible, No. 4 Company received orders to prolong the left of No. 2
Company, and keep in touch with No. 3 Company, which was in the German
communication trench.
At 1 P.M. Lieut.-Colonel Corkran went back to the 22nd Brigade
Headquarters, and got into communication by telephone with General
Heyworth, who ordered him to push his Battalion as far forward as he
could and assist any advance made by the 22nd Brigade on the right.
Rain began to fall at 6 P.M., and grew into a steady downpour. The two
companies, which had been moved up on the left of the Scots Guards,
found themselves in some old German trenches, which had to be
reconstructed, as they faced the wrong way, and would have been
lamentably weak if they had been left as they were. In these ill-covered
trenches the men were soaked to the skin, and spent a miserable night,
which was not improved by the fact that all the time the officers were
busy in getting them into their right order, so that they might be ready
to attack at daybreak. Everywhere the wounded, both British and Germans,
lay about groaning.
Lieut.-Colonel Corkran, having returned to his Battalion, sent Major G.
Trotter to the 22nd Brigade Headquarters as liaison officer, so that
close touch might be kept with it.
As soon as it was dark, No. 2 Company was ordered to establish itself as
close to the small house as possible and to dig itself in, at the same
time gaining touch with No. 3 Company in the German communication
trench. The King's Company was to fill up the gap in the line created by
the advance of No. 2. It was hoped that the small house might be rushed,
but when No. 2 pushed forward it came under such a heavy machine-gun
fire that it had to abandon all idea of seizing the house. It had
accordingly to leave one platoon to hold the line, which it had gained,
and to return to the main line.
[Sidenote: May 17.]
Early next morning the 1st Battalion advanced another 400 yards, and the
men began to dig themselves in, but as the rain continued in torrents
the trenches were knee-deep in mud, and it was difficult to provide
adequate shelter from the enemy's artillery.
It was while the 1st Battalion was lying in this position that the 4th
Guards Brigade was observed coming up in artillery formation, under a
hail of shells and bullets; and--a memorable incident--the 1st and 2nd
Battalions Grenadiers suddenly found themselves fighting side by side.
Although the Seventh Division had carried several lines of trenches, the
part of the German line opposite the extreme left of the 20th Brigade
was still in the hands of the enemy. In certain sections of the line the
attack had been most successful, while in others the enemy had offered a
stubborn resistance. Thus the advance had not been uniform, and there
were consequently several places where the German machine-guns were able
to enfilade our men. But, in spite of the constant counter-attacks, the
enemy had not been able to retake any considerable portion of the ground
they had lost on a front of over two miles.
On the evening of the 17th the 21st Brigade received orders to relieve
the 20th Brigade, and the 1st Battalion Grenadiers consequently withdrew
to the second line, where it remained throughout the 18th.
[Sidenote: May 19.]
The attack continued next day with varying results. As the weather was
heavy, artillery observation was difficult, and the guns were unable to
support the infantry attacks. The 1st Battalion Grenadiers was ordered
back to Brigade Headquarters in the Rue du Bois, where it bivouacked in
a field, and presently moved back to Hinges.
Thus ended the first phase of the battle of Festubert. The Second and
Seventh Divisions had succeeded in cutting two gaps in the German line,
but unfortunately between the two gaps there lay an untouched and
strongly held line, stretching for nearly three-quarters of a mile,
which made any farther advance a matter of great difficulty.
On the 20th of May the attack was renewed by the Canadian Division, and
on the 24th the Forty-seventh London Territorial Division joined in, but
although considerable progress was made, and a large number of Germans
accounted for, our defective ammunition supply did not at that time
allow us to compete with the Germans on even terms. The net result of
the battle was that we pierced the enemy's lines on a total front of
four miles. The whole first-line system of trenches was captured on a
front of 3200 yards. The total number of prisoners taken was 8 officers
and 777 of other ranks, and a number of machine-guns were captured and
destroyed.
The 2nd Battalion.
[Sidenote: 2nd Batt. May 1915.]
The following is the list of officers of the 2nd Battalion at the battle
of Festubert:
Lieut.-Colonel W. R. A. Smith, C.M.G., Commanding Officer.
Major G. D. Jeffreys, Second in Command.
Lieutenant the Hon. W. R. Bailey, Adjutant.
2nd Lieut. D. Abel-Smith, Machine-gun Officer.
Lieut. W. E. Acraman, Quartermaster.
Major Lord Henry Seymour, No. 1 Company. (Brigade Transport Officer)
2nd Lieut. J. N. Buchanan, No. 1 Company.
2nd Lieut. A. H. Penn, No. 1 Company.
Capt. P. A. Clive, No. 2 Company.
Capt. G. L. Derriman, No. 2 Company.
2nd Lieut. J. C. Craigie, No. 2 Company.
2nd Lieut. Viscount Cranborne, No. 2 Company.
2nd Lieut. the Hon. P. P. Cary, No. 2 Company.
Major B. H. Barrington Kennett, No. 3 Company.
Lieut. A. V. L. Corry, No. 3 Company.
2nd Lieut. C. O. Creed, No. 3 Company.
2nd Lieut. R. S. Corkran, No. 3 Company.
Major C. R. C. de Crespigny, No. 4 Company.
Capt. I. St. C. Rose (Divisional Observation Officer), No. 4
Company.
2nd Lieut. E. G. Williams, No. 4 Company.
2nd Lieut. O. Lyttelton, No. 4 Company.
2nd Lieut. the Hon. G. S. Bailey, No. 4 Company.
_Attached_--Captain F. G. Howell, R.A.M.C.
[Sidenote: May 16.]
The 4th Brigade did not take part in the first phase of the battle, and
on the 16th it was moved up to the old line of breastworks at Rue du
Bois, to support the 6th Brigade. The 2nd Battalion Grenadiers and Irish
Guards were placed immediately behind the 6th Brigade, while the two
battalions of Coldstream remained still farther back. The attack of the
5th and 6th Brigades was successful, and the first German line of
trenches was taken, but the Indian Division was held up, and could not
advance as the barbed wire had not been destroyed.
The 2nd Battalion Grenadiers was not called on to do anything that day,
and remained behind the breastworks, where it was subjected to a heavy
shelling. Although there were few casualties, the noise was terrific,
for not only were the enemy's shells dropping all round, but our own
artillery was firing just over the men's heads. It stood by all day, and
withdrew in the evening to Lacouture.
[Sidenote: May 17.]
Next day the 4th Brigade was sent up into the front line. The men had
breakfast at 3.30 A.M., an unusually early hour even for those about to
take part in the fighting, and after standing by all the morning marched
at 1 P.M. to Le Touret, where they received orders to make good the line
of La Quinque Rue. This involved not only getting up to the front line,
but also attacking La Quinque Rue, which ran about five hundred yards
east of it. The Germans were systematically shelling all the roads
leading to the trenches, and it was therefore some time before the 2nd
Battalion Grenadiers could be moved up in artillery formation across the
open _via_ Cense du Raux Farm, Rue de l'Epinette, and the hamlet known
as "Indian Village."
When it reached the supports of the front line, it was by no means easy
to ascertain precisely what line the Battalion was expected to occupy.
Units had become mixed as the inevitable result of the previous attack,
and it was impossible to say for certain what battalion occupied a
trench, or to locate the exact front. An artillery observation officer
helped, however, by pointing out the positions on the map.
It was not till late in the afternoon that the 2nd Battalion began to
move up into the front line. Progress was necessarily slow, as after the
heavy rain the ground was deep in mud, and the shell-holes were full of
water. It advanced gradually through a maze of old British and German
trenches, much knocked about and obstructed with troops' material and a
great many wounded, and passed through the Scots Fusiliers, the Border
Regiment, and the Yorkshire Regiment. Its orders were to pass over what
had originally been the German front line, and to establish itself about
five hundred yards from the German trench at La Quinque Rue. The 5th and
6th Brigades had in the meantime been sent back in reserve, while the
Canadian Division had been ordered to come up on the right and take the
place of the 20th and 22nd Brigades.
It was dark before the 2nd Battalion Grenadiers reached the line it was
ordered to occupy. The men had stumbled over obstacles of every sort,
wrecked trenches and shell-holes, and had finally wriggled themselves
into the front line. The enemy's trenches over which they passed were a
mass of dead men, both German and British, with heads, legs, and other
gruesome objects lying about amid bits of wire obstacles and remains of
accoutrements. Lieut.-Colonel Smith had originally intended to launch
the attack on La Quinque Rue at once, but decided to wait until dawn.
Brought up in the dark to an entirely strange bit of country, without
any landmarks to guide him, or any means of reconnaissance, and not even
certain as to what troops were on each flank, the Commanding Officer was
faced with many anxious problems.
The 4th Brigade, however, was no novice at this type of fighting, and it
was astonishing to see how quickly the men settled down. The 2nd
Battalion Grenadiers was on the right, the Irish Guards on the left,
while the 1st and 2nd Battalions Coldstream were in reserve some way
back. Lieut.-Colonel Smith ordered Major Jeffreys to take charge of the
front line, while he remained in the proper place assigned to the
Commanding Officer, which was with the supports. No. 2 Company under
Captain P. Clive on the right, and No. 3 under Major Barrington Kennett
on the left were in the firing line, and No. 1 under Lord Henry Seymour,
and No. 4 under Major C. de Crespigny were in reserve, in some old
German breastworks. As No. 1 Company moved up, Second Lieutenant A. H.
Penn was shot by a sniper through both legs.
By a curious coincidence the 1st Battalion Grenadiers in the Seventh
Division was immediately on the right, so that for the first time in the
war the 1st and 2nd Battalions were side by side in the line. Second
Lieutenant C. J. Dudley-Smith came over from the 1st Battalion to get
touch, and to his surprise found himself amongst brother officers.
The men had only their little entrenching tools, and with these they dug
frantically, and managed to scrape up some sort of protection before the
morning. The Germans fired a good deal at first, but finding it
difficult to locate exactly the position of the line they determined
later to save their shells, and as the morning went on did not molest
the Battalion much. The Battalion Headquarters and Reserve Companies
came in for a lot of shelling, but owing to the soft ground many shells
failed to explode. Sleep in such an advanced position was out of the
question, more especially as every moment was precious.
[Sidenote: May 18.]
The 4th Brigade was ordered to attack a point marked P 14 and Cour
l'Avoué at 9.30 A.M., but owing to the mist and bad weather the attack
was indefinitely postponed, and the 2nd Battalion had to remain all day
in its hastily made trench, which really offered very little resistance
to artillery fire. The weather cleared about 10 A.M. and the enemy began
a terrific bombardment, which made things very unpleasant, although it
did very little actual damage. It was not till 3.45 P.M. that the 2nd
Battalion received orders to attack at 4.30 P.M., which gave no time for
adequate preparation. Soon afterwards a second message arrived to the
effect that, if the Canadians were late in relieving the 20th Brigade on
the right, the attack was not to be delayed, although there would
necessarily be a gap on that flank.
The front of the Canadian attack was to extend to the left, so that it
overlapped No. 2 Company. The attack was therefore to be made by No. 3
Company alone, although a platoon from No. 2 was to be pushed forward as
far as the barricade.
Our guns began their preparation about forty minutes before the attack
was ordered, and although they undoubtedly did a good deal of damage,
they never succeeded in knocking out the enemy's machine-guns, which
remained hidden during the bombardment. The advance was made by No. 3
Company in short quick rushes by platoons, but as the ground was very
flat, with no possible cover from the machine-guns, the men never had
any real chance of reaching the German trenches. The distance was about
600 yards, and the ground was intersected with ditches full of water.
The first platoon was mown down before it had covered a hundred yards,
the second melted away before it reached even as far, and the third
shared the same fate. The Irish Guards on the right attacked on a much
wider front, but were also held up by the machine-guns which swept the
whole ground. It was magnificent to see the gallant manner in which they
brought up reinforcements on reinforcements, unfortunately with no
success.
In the first rush of the Grenadiers Major Barrington Kennett was killed,
and Second Lieutenant the Hon. P. Cary was hit soon afterwards. Second
Lieutenant Creed was mortally wounded as he rushed on to the attack, and
died of his wounds some days later. The only officer left in the Company
was Lieutenant Corry, who behaved with great gallantry when the enemy's
machine-guns opened fire with a storm of bullets.
Lieutenant Lord Cranborne who commanded the platoon from No. 2 Company,
which had been pushed up as far as the barricade, was completely
deafened by the shells which burst incessantly round his platoon during
the attack. Lieut.-Colonel Smith was struck in the head by a bullet as
he watched the attack from behind a mound of earth, and though he was
carried by Major Jeffreys and Major Lord Henry Seymour into a place of
safety, and eventually taken to the dressing-station, he never recovered
consciousness, and died the following day. He was buried in the British
Soldiers' Cemetery near Le Touret, and his funeral was attended by Lord
Cavan and many officers and non-commissioned officers of his battalion.
Never was a Commanding Officer more mourned by his men; he had endeared
himself to them by his soldier-like qualities and constant care for
their welfare. He was a gallant and distinguished soldier, imperturbable
in action, never flurried or disconcerted in perilous situations, a
strict disciplinarian, but the kindest and best of friends, and his loss
was keenly felt by all ranks of the regiment.
Major Jeffreys, now in command of the Battalion, ordered No. 2 Company
to reinforce No. 3 and continue the attack, but Captain Clive
represented that it would be practically impossible for his Company to
cross over the exposed ground under so heavy a fire. The enemy's
machine-guns were absolutely undamaged, and commanded the ground over
which it would be necessary to pass, and Major Jeffreys was forced to
the conclusion that it would be merely throwing men's lives away to ask
them to advance. At this moment Captain Lord Gort (Brigade-Major) came
up to investigate the situation, and Major Jeffreys told him that he did
not propose to renew the attack until darkness gave the Battalion some
chance of reaching the objective.
Lord Cavan, on hearing from Lord Gort how matters stood, sent orders to
the 2nd Battalion to dig in where it was. It had gained 300 yards, and
before it could possibly advance any farther it would be necessary to
wait until the Canadians came up on the right. Soon after dark the
Canadians arrived, and, true to their reputation, carried out their
attack in a very dashing manner. They met with very little opposition at
first, and got on very well until they were stopped by machine-gun fire.
In all probability, if the two attacks had taken place simultaneously,
there would have been a far greater prospect of success, but, as things
happened, first the 4th Brigade and then in turn the Canadians drew on
themselves the attention of all the German troops in that part of the
line.
Major Jeffreys contemplated a combined attack all down the line by
night, but the Corps Commander sent instructions that the 4th Brigade
was to remain where it was, and join up with the Canadians. So another
gruesome night had to be spent amongst the dead and dying, and the men
had to work hard to make the trench fit to remain in.
[Sidenote: May 19.]
All the next day the 2nd Battalion held this line, and came in for a
great deal of shell-fire, but the trenches that had been dug during the
night proved sufficient protection, and there were not many casualties.
That night the 2nd Battalion Grenadiers was relieved by the 3rd
Battalion Coldstream, and went into reserve with the rest of the Second
Division.