First, those which were of a temporal and present consideration of this

life: blessings and curses of all sorts opened at large, Lev. xxvi. and

Deut. xxviii., which cannot possibly be made good in any state, country,

or kingdom, but in a spiritual sense in the church and kingdom of Christ.

[Sidenote: The spiritual prosperity of God’s people now, the antitype.]

The reason is this: such a temporal prosperity of outward peace and

plenty of all things, of increase of children, of cattle, of honour, of

health, of success, of victory, suits not temporally with the afflicted

and persecuted estate of God’s people now: and therefore spiritual and

soul-blessedness must be the antitype, viz., in the midst of revilings,

and all manner of evil speeches for Christ’s sake, soul-blessedness. In

the midst of afflictions and persecutions, soul-blessedness, Matt. v. and

Luke vi. And yet herein the Israel of God should enjoy their spiritual

peace, Gal. vi. 16.

[Sidenote: What Israel’s excommunication was.]

Out of that blessed temporal estate to be cast, or carried captive, was

their excommunication or casting out of God’s sight, 2 Kings xvii. 23.

Therefore was the blasphemer, the false prophet, the idolater, to be cast

out or cut off from this holy land: which punishment cannot be paralleled

by the punishment of any state or kingdom in the world, but only by the

excommunicating or out-casting of person or church from the fellowship of

the saints and churches of Christ Jesus in the gospel.

[Sidenote: The corporal stoning in the law, typed out spiritual stoning

in the gospel.]

And therefore, as before I have noted, the putting away of the false

prophet, by stoning him to death, Deut. xiii., is fitly answered, and

that in the very same words, in the antitype: when, by the general

consent or stoning of the whole assembly, any wicked person is put away

from amongst them, that is, spiritually cut off out of the land of the

spiritually living, the people or church of God, 1 Cor. v., Gal. v.

[Sidenote: The rewards or punishments of the laws of Israel not to be

paralleled.]

Lastly, the great and high reward or punishment of the keeping or breach

of these laws to Israel, was such as cannot suit with any state or

kingdom in the world beside. The reward of the observation was life,

eternal life. The breach of any one of these laws was death, eternal

death, or damnation from the presence of the Lord. So Rom. x., James ii.

Such a covenant God made not before nor since with any state or people

in the world. For, _Christ is the end of the law for righteousness to

every one that believeth_, Rom. x. 4. And, _he that believeth in that Son

of God, hath eternal life; he that believeth not hath not life, but is

condemned already_, John iii. and 1 John v.

CHAP. CXXII.

[Sidenote: The wars of Israel typical.]

_Peace._ Dear Truth, you have most lively set forth the unparalleled

state of that typical land and people of the Jews in their peace and

quiet government: let me now request you, in the last place, to glance at

the difference of the wars of this people from the wars of other nations,

and of their having no antitype but the churches of Christ Jesus.

[Sidenote: Israel’s enemies round about.]

[_Truth._] First, all nations round about Israel, more or less, some

time or other, had indignation against this people—Egyptians, Edomites,

Moabites, Ammonites, Midians, Philistines, Assyrians, and Babylonians,

&c., as appears in the history of Moses, Samuel, Judges, and Kings, and

in all the prophets: you have an express catalogue of them, Ps. lxxxiii.,

sometimes many hundred thousand enemies in pitched field against them: of

Ethiopians ten hundred thousand at once in the days of Asa, 2 Chron. xiv.

[9,] and at other times as the sand upon the sea shore.

[Sidenote: The enemies of mystical Israel.]

Such enemies the Lord Jesus foretold his Israel, The world shall hate

you, John xv. [18, 19.] You shall be hated of all men for my name’s

sake, Matt. xxiv. [9.] All that will live godly in Christ Jesus must be

persecuted, or hunted, 2 Tim. iii. [12.] And not only by flesh and blood,

but also by principalities, powers, spiritual wickedness in high places,

Eph. vi. [12,] by the whole pagan world under the Roman emperors, and the

whole anti-christian world under the Roman popes, Rev. xii. and xiii., by

the kings of the earth, Rev. xvii. And Gog and Magog, like the sand upon

the shore, (Rev. xx.)

_Peace._ Such enemies, such armies, no history, no experience proves ever

to have come against one poor nation as against Israel in the type; and

never was nor shall be known to come against any state or country now,

but the Israel of God, the spiritual Jews, Christ’s true followers in all

parts and quarters of the world.

[Sidenote: Enemies against Israel in her own bowels.]

[_Truth._] Beside all these without, Israel is betrayed within her own

bowels: bloody Sauls, Absaloms, Shebas, Adonijahs, Jeroboams, Athaliahs,

raising insurrections, conspiracies, tumults, in the antitype and

parallel, the spiritual state of the Christian church.

Secondly, consider we the famous and wonderful battles, victories,

captivities, deliverances, which it pleased the God of Israel to dispense

to that people and nation, and let us search if they can be paralleled by

any state or people, but mystically and spiritually the true Christian

Israel of God, Gal. vi. 16.

[Sidenote: The famous typical captivities of the Jews.]

How famous was the bondage and slavery of that people and nation 430

years in the land of Egypt, and as famous, glorious, and miraculous was

their return through the Red Sea, a figure of baptism, 1 Cor. x. [2,] and

Egypt a figure of an Egypt now, Rev. xi. 8.

How famous was the seventy years’ captivity of the Jews in Babel,

transported from the land of Canaan, and at the full period returned

again to Jerusalem, a type of the captivity of God’s people now,

spiritually captivated in spiritual Babel, Rev. xviii. 4.

[Sidenote: Their wonderful victories.]

Time would fail me to speak of Joshua’s conquest of literal Canaan, the

slaughter of thirty-one kings, of the miraculous taking of Jericho and

other cities: Gideon’s miraculous battle against the Midianites: Jonathan

and his armour-bearer against the Philistines: David, by his five smooth

stones against Goliah: Asa, Jehoshaphat, Hezekiah, their mighty and

miraculous victories against so many hundred thousand enemies, and that

sometimes without a blow given.

What state, what kingdom, what wars and combats, victories and

deliverances, can parallel this people, but the spiritual and mystical

Israel of God in every nation and country of the world, typed out by that

small typical handful, in that little spot of ground, the land of Canaan?

[Sidenote: The mystical battles of God’s Israel now.]

The Israel of God now, men and women, fight under the great Lord General,

the Lord Jesus Christ: their weapons, armour, and artillery, are like

themselves, spiritual, set forth from top to toe, Eph. vi.; so mighty and

so potent that they break down the strongest holds and castles, yea, in

the very souls of men, and carry into captivity the very thoughts of men,

subjecting them to Christ Jesus. They are spiritual conquerors, as in all

the seven churches of Asia, _He that overcometh_: _He that overcometh_,

Rev. ii. and iii.

Their victories and conquests in this country are contrary to those

of this world, for when they are slain and slaughtered, yet then they

conquer. So overcame they the devil in the Roman emperors, Rev. xii.

[11,] _By the blood of the Lamb_: 2. _By the word of their testimony_:

3. The cheerful spilling of their own blood for Christ; for _they loved

not their lives unto the death_: and in all this they _are more than

conquerors through him that loved_ them, Rom. viii. 37.

[Sidenote: The mystical army of white troopers, Rev. xix.]

This glorious army of white troopers, horses and harness—Christ Jesus and

his true Israel, Rev. xix.—gloriously conquer and overcome the beast, the

false prophet, and the kings of the earth, up in arms against them, Rev.

xix.; and, lastly, reigning with Christ a thousand years, they conquer

the devil himself, and the numberless armies, like the sand on the sea

shore, of Gog and Magog: and yet not a tittle of mention of any sword,

helmet, breastplate, shield, or horse, but what is spiritual and of a

heavenly nature. All which wars of Israel have been, may be, and shall be

fulfilled mystically and spiritually.

I could further insist on other particulars of Israel’s unparalleled

state, and might display those excellent passages which it pleaseth God

to mention, Neh. ix.

CHAP. CXXIII.

_Peace._ You have, dear Truth, as in a glass, presented the face of old

and new Israel, and as in water face answereth to face, so doth the face

of typical Israel to the face of the antitype, between whom, and not

between Canaan and the civil nations and countries of the world now,

there is an admirable consent and harmony. But I have heard some say, was

not the civil state and judicials of that people precedential?

[Sidenote: Whether the civil state of Israel was precedential.]

_Truth._ I have in part, and might farther discover, that from the king

and his throne to the very beasts, yea, [to] the excrements of their

bodies (as we see in their going to war, Deut. xxiii. 12,) their civils,

morals, and naturals were carried on in types; and however I acknowledge

that what was simply moral, civil, and natural in Israel’s state, in

their constitutions, laws, punishments, may be imitated and followed

by the states, countries, cities, and kingdoms of the world: yet who

can question the lawfulness of other forms of government, laws, and

punishments which differ, since civil constitutions are men’s ordinances

(or creation, 2 Pet. ii. 13), unto which God’s people are commanded even

for the Lord’s sake to submit themselves, which if they were unlawful

they ought not to do?

_Peace._ Having thus far proceeded in examining whether God hath charged

the civil state with the establishing of the spiritual and religious,

what conceive you of that next assertion, viz., “It is well known that

the remissness of princes in Christendom in matters of religion and

worship, devolving the care thereof only to the clergy, and so setting

their horns upon the church’s head, hath been the cause of anti-christian

invention, usurpation, and corruption in the worship and temple of God.”

[Sidenote: The true Christendom.]

_Truth._ It is lamentably come to pass by God’s just permission, Satan’s

policy, the people’s sin, the malice of the wicked against Christ, and

the corruption of princes and magistrates, that so many inventions,

usurpations, and corruptions are risen in the worship and temple of God,

throughout that part of the world which is called Christian, and may most

properly be called the pope’s Christendom in opposition to Christ Jesus’s

true Christian commonweal, or church, the true Christendom; but that

this hath arisen from princes’ remissness in not keeping their watch to

establish the purity of religion, doctrine, and worship, and to punish,

according to Israel’s pattern, all false ministers, by rooting them and

their worships out of the world, that, I say, can never be evinced; and

the many thousands of glorious souls under the altar whose blood hath

been spilt by this position, and the many hundred thousand souls, driven

out of their bodies by civil wars, and the many millions of souls forced

to hypocrisy and ruin eternal, by enforced uniformities in worship, will

to all eternity proclaim the contrary.

[Sidenote: Great unfaithfulness in ministers to cast the chiefest burden

of judging and establishing true Christianity upon the commonweal or

world itself.]

Indeed, it shows a most injurious idleness and unfaithfulness in such as

profess to be messengers of Christ Jesus, to cast the heaviest weight

of their care upon the kings and rulers of the earth, yea, upon the

very commonweals, bodies of people, that is, the world itself, who have

fundamentally in themselves the root of power, to set up what government

and governors they shall agree upon.

Secondly, it shows abundance of carnal diffidence and distrust of the

glorious power and gracious presence of the Lord Jesus, who hath given

his promise and word to be with such his messengers to the end of the

world, Matt. xxviii. 20.

That dog that fears to meet a man in the path, runs on with boldness at

his master’s coming and presence at his back.

[Sidenote: To govern and judge in civil affairs load enough on the civil

magistrate. Magistrates can have no more power than the common consent of

the people shall betrust them with.]

Thirdly, what imprudence and indiscretion is it in the most common

affairs of life, to conceive that emperors, kings, and rulers of the

earth, must not only be qualified with political and state abilities to

make and execute such civil laws which may concern the common rights,

peace, and safety, which is work and business, load and burden enough for

the ablest shoulders in the commonweal; but also furnished with such

spiritual and heavenly abilities to govern the spiritual and Christian

commonweal, the flock and church of Christ, to pull down, and set up

religion, to judge, determine, and punish in spiritual controversies,

even to death or banishment. And, beside, that not only the several sorts

of civil officers, which the people shall choose and set up, must be so

authorized, but that all respective commonweals or bodies of people are

charged (much more) by God with this work and business, radically and

fundamentally, because all true civil magistrates, have not the least

inch of civil power, but what is measured out to them from the free

consent of the whole: even as a committee of parliament cannot further

act than the power of the house shall arm and enable them.

[Sidenote: Thousands of lawful magistrates, who never hear of the true

church of God.]

Concerning that objection which may arise from the kings of Israel and

Judah, who were born members of God’s church, and trained up therein all

their days, which thousands of lawful magistrates in the world, possibly

born and bred in false worships, pagan or anti-christian, never heard of,

and were therein types of the great anointed, the King of Israel, I have

spoken sufficiently to such as have an ear to hear: and therefore,

[Sidenote: The spiritual and civil sword cannot be managed by one and the

same person. The Lord Jesus refused to manage both.]

Lastly, so unsuitable is the commixing and entangling of the civil with

the spiritual charge and government, that (except it was for subsistence,

as we see in Paul and Barnabas working with their own hands) the Lord

Jesus, and his apostles, kept themselves to one. If ever any in this

world was able to manage both the spiritual and civil, church and

commonweal, it was the Lord Jesus, wisdom itself: yea, he was the true

heir to the crown of Israel, being the son of David: yet being sought for

by the people to be made a king, John vi. [15,] he refused, and would not

give a precedent to any king, prince, or ruler, to manage both swords,

and to assume the charge of both tables.

Now concerning princes, I desire it may be remembered, who were most

injurious and dangerous to Christianity, whether Nero, Domitian, Julian,

&c., persecutors: or Constantine, Theodosius, &c., who assumed this power

and authority in and over the church in spiritual things. It is confessed

by the answerer and others of note, that under these latter, the church,

the Christian state, religion, and worship, were most corrupted: under

Constantine, Christians fell asleep on the beds of carnal ease and

liberty; insomuch that some apply to his times that sleep of the church,

Cant. v. 2, _I sleep, though mine heart waketh._[225]

CHAP. CXXIV.

_Peace._ Yea; but some will say, this was not through their assuming of

this power, but the ill-managing of it.

_Truth._ Yet are they commonly brought as the great precedents for

all succeeding princes and rulers in after ages: and in this very

controversy, their practices are brought as precedential to establish

persecution for conscience.

[Sidenote: Who force the consciences of others, yet are not willing to be

forced themselves.]

Secondly, those emperors and other princes and magistrates acted in

religion according to their consciences’ persuasion, and beyond the light

and persuasion of conscience can no man living walk in any fear of God.

Hence have they forced their subjects to uniformity and conformity unto

their own consciences, whatever they were, though not willing to have

been forced themselves in the matters of God and conscience.

[Sidenote: Constantine and others wanted not so much affection as

information of conscience.]

Thirdly, had not the light of their eye of conscience, and the

consciences also of their teachers, been darkened, they could not have

been condemned for want of heavenly affection, rare devotion, wonderful

care and diligence, propounding to themselves the best patterns of the

kings of Judah, David, Solomon, Asa, Jehoshaphat, Josiah, Hezekiah. But

here they lost the path, and themselves, in persuading themselves to be

the parallels and antitypes to those figurative and typical princes:

whence they conceived themselves bound to make their cities, kingdoms,

empires, new holy lands of Canaan, and themselves governors and judges in

spiritual causes, compelling all consciences to Christ, and persecuting

the contrary with fire and sword.

[Sidenote: Sad consequences of charging the civil powers with the care of

spirituals.]

Upon these roots, how was, how is it possible, but that such bitter

fruits should grow of corruption of Christianity, persecution of such

godly who happily see more of Christ than such rulers themselves: their

dominions and jurisdictions being overwhelmed with enforced dissimulation

and hypocrisy, and (where power of resistance) with flames of civil

combustion: as at this very day, he that runs may read and tremble at?

_Peace._ They add further, that the princes of Christendom setting their

horns upon the church’s head, have been the cause of anti-christian

inventions, &c.

[Sidenote: Civil rulers giving and lending their horns or authority to

bishops, both dangerous to the truth of Christ. The spiritual power of

the Lord Jesus compared in scripture to the incomparable horn of the

rhinoceros.]

_Truth._ If they mean that the princes of Europe, giving their power and

authority to the seven-headed and ten-horned beast of Rome, have been

the cause, &c., I confess it to be one concurring cause: yet withal it

must be remembered, that even before such princes set their horns, or

authority, upon the beast’s head, even when they did, as I may say, but

lend their horns to the bishops, even then rose up many anti-christian

abominations. And though I confess there is but small difference, in

some respects, between the setting their horns upon the priests’ heads,

whereby they are enabled immediately to push and gore whoever cross their

doctrine and practice, and the lending of their horns, that is, pushing

and goring such themselves, as are declared by their bishops and priests

to be heretical, as was and is practised in some countries before and

since the pope rose: yet I confidently affirm, that neither the Lord

Jesus nor his first ordained ministers and churches (gathered by such

ministers), did ever wear, or crave the help of such horns in spiritual

and Christian affairs. The spiritual power of the Lord Jesus in the hands

of his true ministers and churches, according to Balaam’s prophecy, Num.

xxiii., is the horn of that unicorn, or rhinoceros, Ps. xcii. [10,] which

is the strongest horn in the world: in comparison of which the strongest

horns of the bulls of Bashan break as sticks and reeds. History tells us

how that unicorn, or one-horned beast the rhinoceros, took up a bull like

a tennis ball, in the theatre at Rome, before the emperor, according to

that record of the poet:[226]

Quantus erat cornu cui pila taurus erat!

Unto this spiritual power of the Lord Jesus, the souls and thoughts of

the highest kings and emperors must [be] subject, Matt. xvi. and xviii.,

1 Cor. v. and x.

CHAP. CXXV.

_Peace._ Dear Truth, you know the noise is made from those prophecies,

Isaiah xlix. 23, kings and queens shall be nursing fathers, &c., and

Rev. xxi. 24, the kings of the earth shall bring their glory and honour

to the new Jerusalem, &c.

[Sidenote: A time when God’s people are wholly at a loss for God’s

worship.]

_Truth._ I answer with that mournful prophet, Ps. lxxiv., I see not that

man, that prophet, that can tell us how long. How many excellent penmen

fight each against other with their pens (like swords) in the application

of those prophecies of David, Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, Daniel,

Zechariah, John, when and how those prophecies shall be fulfilled!

[Sidenote: Nursing fathers and mothers.]

Secondly, whenever those prophecies are fulfilled, yet shall those kings

not be heads, governors, and judges in ecclesiastical or spiritual

causes; but be themselves judged and ruled, if within the church, by the

power of the Lord Jesus therein. Hence saith Isaiah, those kings and

queens shall lick the dust of thy feet, &c.

_Peace._ Some will here ask, What may the magistrate then lawfully do

with his civil horn, or power, in matters of religion?

[Sidenote: The civil horn or power being of a human constitution cannot

but be of a human operation.]

_Truth._ His horn not being the horn of that unicorn, or rhinoceros, the

power of the Lord Jesus in spiritual cases: his sword not the two-edged

sword of the Spirit, the word of God, hanging not about the loins or

side, but at the lips, and proceeding out of the mouth of his ministers,

but of a human and civil nature and constitution; it must consequently

be of a human and civil operation: for who knows not that operation

follows constitution? and therefore I shall end this passage with this

consideration:

[Sidenote: The civil power owes three things to the true church of

Christ.]

The civil magistrate either respecteth that religion and worship which

his conscience is persuaded is true, and upon which he ventures his soul:

or else that and those which he is persuaded are false.

Concerning the first; if that which the magistrate believeth to be true,

be true, I say he owes a threefold duty unto it:

[Sidenote: 1. Approbation.]

First, Approbation and countenance, a reverent esteem and honourable

testimony, according to Isaiah xlix., Rev. xxi., with a tender respect of

truth, and the professors of it.

[Sidenote: 2. Submission.]

Secondly, Personal submission of his own soul to the power of the Lord

Jesus in that spiritual government and kingdom, according to Matt.

xviii., 1 Cor. v.

[Sidenote: 3. Protection.]

Thirdly, Protection of such true professors of Christ, whether apart,

or met together, as also of their estates from violence and injury,

according to Rom. xiii.

[Sidenote: The civil magistrate owes to false worshippers.]

Now secondly, if it be a false religion, unto which the civil magistrate

dare not adjoin: yet, he owes,

[Sidenote: 1. Permission.]

First, Permission, for approbation he owes not to what is evil, and this

according to Matt. xiii. 30, for public peace and quiet’s sake.

[Sidenote: 2. Protection.]

Secondly, he owes protection to the persons of his subjects, though of a

false worship, that no injury be offered either to the persons or goods

of any, Rom. xiii.

_Peace._ Dear Truth, in this eleventh head concerning the magistrates’

power in worship, you have examined what is affirmed the magistrate _may

do_ in point of worship; there remains a second, to wit, that which they

say the magistrate _may not do_ in worship.

They say, “The magistrate may not bring in set forms of prayer: nor

secondly, bring in significant ceremonies: nor thirdly, not govern and

rule the acts of worship in the church of God;” for which they bring an

excellent similitude of a prince or magistrate in a ship, where he hath

no governing power over the actions of the mariners: and secondly, that

excellent prophecy concerning Christ Jesus, that his government should be

upon his shoulders, Isa. ix. 6, 7.

The Bloudy Tenent of Persecution for Cause of Conscience Discussed and Mr. Cotton's Letter Examined and Answered · 第 25 / 37 段