Ronald Branston’s Story
“Branston! Branston after all!” insinuated Sergeant Godfrey to the
Inspector as they made their way back to the station.
“Before proceeding any further, Godfrey,” said Bannister, turning to
his companion, “tell me all you know about this Mr. Ronald Branston,
the dentist. We can’t get away from the hard fact that the only
corroboration of Branston’s story comes from one of his own staff—that
Mrs. Bertenshaw of his—the housekeeper.”
“Quite right, Inspector,” said the Sergeant. “I’ve been thinking the
same thing myself.”
“Yet there’s something else to remember, Godfrey, when you come to
think of it. Something most important. In fact, in my opinion, it
would be difficult to over-estimate its importance. I’ve thought so
all along. You know what I mean, don’t you, Godfrey?”
“Not exactly, sir.”
“I mean this. If it hadn’t been for Branston’s story—his account of
his imprisonment and so on—it would have been at least ten to one on
the affair being accepted as a plain case of suicide. If Branston
wanted to murder the girl what on earth was to prevent him murdering
her in exactly the same way as Doctor Renfrew considered she _was_
murdered—walking quietly to his work-room as he states that he
did—walking just as quietly back to the extraction room or whatever
they call it and discovering upon his return, that ‘Miss Delaney had
committed suicide during his absence’? There was no need for any
fantastic story such as he has told us, Godfrey.” He continued in
emphasis of his point. “Moreover, Godfrey, who would have doubted him?
Would there have been anything to cause people to doubt him?”
Godfrey rubbed his chin critically. “How would he explain the missing
notes? That fact was bound to come out sooner or later.”
“That she had no money with her when she arrived at his surgery! She’d
given it away! Thrown it away! Done anything with it!” He looked at
Godfrey—then added, “Suicides don’t need money, you know, Sergeant. It
would have added colour to his story.”
“I’ve got a good answer to that, Inspector,” countered Godfrey.
“What’s that?”
“Suicides don’t want aching teeth pulled out. A man who has decided to
cut his throat and spend the evening in the mortuary doesn’t go out to
get a hair-cut beforehand—or a shave,” added the Sergeant.
Bannister nodded. “It’s a damned good point, Godfrey—that—but I very
much doubt whether Branston would consider it big enough to upset
successfully his edifice of ‘suicide.’ If he did—he’s a smarter chap
than I’ve taken him for?”
“Don’t you think this criminal we’re hunting for _is_ a smart chap,
Inspector?” queried Godfrey. “I do—and that’s a fact. I shouldn’t like
to meet many smarter.”
“Not so bad,” conceded Bannister, “not so bad—but I’ll wager to prove
myself his equal—don’t worry.”
They entered the Police Station, Bannister confident, Godfrey
pessimistic. “Do as I told you when we started the discussion,
Godfrey,” said Bannister, “tell me all you know about Branston. It got
side-tracked just now.”
“Well—we’ve looked into him pretty thoroughly ever since the affair
started—as you know. Nothing’s been brought out to his discredit. He’s
been practising in Seabourne about three years, came down here from
somewhere in the Midlands. His business has been very successful and
continues to develop—he’s certainly prosperous. He’s unmarried and as
far as we know—unattached. If there’s a lady in his life—Seabourne
hasn’t seen her. He’s addicted to a flutter on the ‘Turf’ and is a
magnificent dancer. I have been told he’s the finest dancer in the
whole of Seabourne. That’s his history, Inspector, as far as we’ve
been able to pick it up.”
“H’m!” muttered Bannister, “not very much to help there. There’s
another thing that gets me, Godfrey. Those notes! Listen carefully to
what I’m going to say now. Do you think any murderer who also stole
those notes would circulate them? Do you think he’d run the risk of
such a procedure?”
“Well,” answered Godfrey, “come to that—he might and he might not. On
the whole, I don’t think he would. But on the other hand he might
think it a thousand to one against the numbers of the notes being
known to anybody—that’s the point, you see.” He struck a match and lit
his cigarette. “But I’ll tell you what, Inspector,” he supplemented,
“since you’ve asked the question of me, I think if the murderer or
murderess rather—I _should_ say—were a _woman_—that _she_ might have
done. I’ve noticed from my own experience of our class of work that a
woman often makes a mistake of that kind.”
“Godfrey,” said Bannister, “you know something or you suspect
somebody! What are you hinting at?”
But Godfrey shook his head. “I know nothing, Inspector that you don’t
know! But I’ll admit that I’m hinting at something.”
“Let’s have it, Godfrey!”
“You said just now that we had only one person’s corroboration of
Branston’s story of his temporary imprisonment in his work-room.”
“That’s so—go on, I don’t see——”
“Has it ever struck you that Mrs. Bertenshaw, the housekeeper who
arrived so opportunely, shall we say, to release Branston—might just
as easily have shot the bolt that held him prisoner? She was the only
person that you can swear was in the house with Branston and the
murdered girl.” He looked at Bannister anxiously—scanning the
Inspector’s impassive face to see how his theory was being received.
“By Jove,” whispered Bannister—almost to himself. Then he shook his
head in disagreement. “Where did she get the poison from, Godfrey—have
you thought of that?”
Godfrey shrugged his shoulders. “Of course, I can’t answer that for
the moment—but it might be answered in several ways.”
“Have you looked her up at all? I’m relying on you for spade work,”
asked Bannister.
Godfrey was ready with his facts. “She’s a widow—lost her husband
about nine years ago. She’s got one son—believed to be abroad—in
India, I believe. She herself comes of a West Country family. Her
maiden name was Warrimore.”
“Nothing against her, then?”
“Nothing.”
“How do you explain the stolen notes getting to Branston? You can’t
get away from Morley’s story.”
“Suppose we go to see him, Inspector,” declared Godfrey.
“I don’t think we can do better. We’ll go up by car at once. Get one
sent up here, will you?”
As they rounded the corner to Coolwater Avenue half an hour later,
Bannister touched the Sergeant on the arm. “Something I’ve had on the
tip of my tongue to ask you all day, Godfrey. Finger-prints! What
results are there? I hear the report’s through—I’m told it came
through this morning.”
“Scarcely any help at all. The brass bolt on the door of the room
where Branston was imprisoned, gave us Mrs. Bertenshaw and Branston
himself. The glass gave us Branston and Miss Delaney. Nothing there,
you see—that you wouldn’t naturally expect.” For the second time in a
few days Bannister was admitted by Mrs. Bertenshaw and on this
occasion he subjected her to a more careful scrutiny than on the
occasion before. She piloted them into what was evidently Branston’s
library. The Inspector seized the occasion to have a good look round.
Like the other parts of the establishment that he had previously seen,
it was handsomely furnished. Moreover, the books on the shelves
displayed the discriminating taste of the cultured reader. A cough
heralded Ronald Branston’s entry.
“Good afternoon, gentlemen—what can I do for you—or is there news of
importance?” His dark, good-looking face broke into a slight smile.
Bannister suddenly found himself unable to believe that Mr. Branston
had managed to steer entirely clear of the feminine society of
Seabourne. That story was a strain upon ordinary belief. At the same
time he came to the point of his visit. “There _is_ news, Mr.
Branston,” he said curtly, “you may as well know it at once—Miss
Delaney was undoubtedly robbed as well as murdered.”
“Robbed?” echoed Branston. “Robbed of what?”
“Something like a hundred pounds in notes—the numbers of which notes
are known.”
Godfrey could have sworn that Branston whitened a trifle as he heard
this piece of news.
“Not only are they known, Mr. Branston—but what is more important
still, some of them have already been traced. And traced to _you_!” A
pause. “I shall be happy to hear your explanation, Mr. Branston.”
Bannister’s voice held a relentless note.
The young dental surgeon winced. “Before I can do that,” he said, “I
must ask you to tell me more. I don’t understand. How have the notes
been traced to me?”
Bannister recounted the chain of events leading from Captain
Willoughby down to Branston himself. The latter’s face quivered
emotionally when he heard the story of how Jacob Morley had stated the
way in which he had come to possess the nomadic notes. He sprang from
his chair and paced the room in obvious agitation. Then he swung round
resolutely on to Bannister.
“I’ll tell you the whole story of those notes as far as it affects me.
Those notes were given to me by a lady. I advanced that lady fifty
pounds a year ago at a time when she sorely needed it. I knew the
reason for which it was needed and I fully approved of it. One day
last week—Friday to be precise—the lady concerned paid me the fifty
pounds back. Gentlemen, the lady in the case is Mrs. Bertenshaw, my
housekeeper.”
Bannister’s eyes sought those of Sergeant Godfrey. They met.