Counsels of Imperfection

It is all very well for mischievous writers to maintain that we cannot

serve God and Mammon. Granted that it is not easy, but nothing that is

worth doing ever is easy. Easy or difficult, possible or impossible, not

only has the thing got to be done, but it is exactly in doing it that the

whole duty of man consists. And when the righteous man turneth away from

his righteousness that he hath committed and doeth that which is neither

quite lawful nor quite right, he will generally be found to have gained

in amiability what he has lost in holiness.

If there are two worlds at all (and that there are I have no doubt) it

stands to reason that we ought to make the best of both of them, and more

particularly of the one with which we are most immediately concerned. It

is as immoral to be too good as to be too anything else. The Christian

morality is just as immoral as any other. It is at once very moral and

very immoral. How often do we not see children ruined through the

virtues, real or supposed, of their parents? Truly he visiteth the

virtues of the fathers upon the children unto the third and fourth

generation. The most that can be said for virtue is that there is a

considerable balance in its favour, and that it is a good deal better to

be for it than against it; but it lets people in very badly sometimes.

If you wish to understand virtue you must be sub-vicious; for the really

virtuous man, who is fully under grace, will be virtuous unconsciously

and will know nothing about it. Unless a man is out-and-out virtuous he

is sub-vicious.

Virtue is, as it were, the repose of sleep or death. Vice is the

awakening to the knowledge of good and evil—without which there is no

life worthy of the name. Sleep is, in a way, a happier, more peaceful

state than waking and, in a way, death may be said to be better than

life, but it is in a very small way. We feel such talk to be blasphemy

against good life and, whatever we may say in death’s favour, so long as

we do not blow our brains out we show that we do not mean to be taken

seriously. To know good, other than as a heavy sleeper, we must know

vice also. There cannot, as Bacon said, be a “Hold fast that which is

good” without a “Prove all things” going before it. There is no

knowledge of good without a knowledge of evil also, and this is why all

nations have devils as well as gods, and regard them with sneaking

kindness. God without the devil is dead, being alone.

The Note-Books of Samuel Butler · 第 25 / 602 题