We are what we do

In the contemporary world, communication is progressively reified

and takes place more and more through the intermediary of the

product. Its source is human work. Characteristics of the

languages involved in the work are also projected into them. A

new underlying structure replaces that which made literacy

possible and necessary. In the physical or spiritual reality of

the product, specialized languages are re-translated into the

universal language of satisfying needs, or creating new needs,

which are afterwards processed through the mediating mechanisms

of the market. Reification (from the Latin res: transformation

of everything-life, language, feeling, work-into things) is the

result of the alienating logic of the market and its semiosis.

Markets abstract individual contributions to a product. In the

first place, language itself is reified and consumed. Markets

reify this contribution, turning life, energy, doubts, time, or

whatever else-in particular language-into the commodity embodied

in the product. The very high degree of integration leads to

conditions in which high efficiency-the most possible at the

lowest price-becomes a criterion for survival. The consequence

is that human individuality is absorbed in the product. People

literally put their lives, and everything pertaining to

them-natural history, education, family, feelings, culture,

desires-in the outcome of their practical experiences. This

absorption of the human being into the product takes place at

different levels. In the second place, the individual

constituted in work is also reified and consumed: the product

contains a portion of the limited duration of the lives of those

who processed it.

Each form of mediated work depends upon its mediating entities.

As one form of work is replaced by another, more efficient, the

language that mediated is replaced by other means. Languages of

coordination corresponding to hunting, or those of incipient

agriculture, made way for subsequent practical experience of

self-constitution in language. This applies to any and all forms

of work, whether resulting in agricultural, industrial,

artistic, or ideological products. The metaphors of genetics and

evolutionary models can be applied. We can describe the

evolution of work in memetic terminology, but we would still not

capture the active role of sign processes. Moreover, human

reproduction, between its sexual and its cultural forms, would

become meaningless if separated from the pragmatic framework

through which human self-constitution takes place.

To illustrate how language is consumed, let us shortly examine

what happens in the work we call education. In our day, the need

for continual training increases dramatically. The paradigm of a

once-for-life education is over, as much as literacy is over.

Shorter production cycles require changes of tools and the

pertinent training. A career for life, possible while the linear

progress of technology required only maintenance of skills and

slight changes of knowledge, is an ideal of the past. Efficiency

requirements translate into training strategies that are less

costly and less permanent than those afforded through literacy.

These strategies produce educated operators as training itself

becomes a product, offered by training companies whose list of

clients includes fast food chains, nuclear energy producers,

frozen storage facilities, the U.S. Congress, and computer

operations. The market is the place where products are

transacted and where the language of advertising, design, and

public relations is consumed. Training, too, focused more and

more on non-literate means of communication, is consumed.

The Civilization of Illiteracy · 第 69 / 217 题