TRANSLATION OF AESCHYLUS

A search for Aeschylus in English is deadly, accursed, mind-rending.

Browning has "done" the Agamemnon, or "done the Agamemnon in the eye" as

the critic may choose to consider. He has written a modest and an

apparently intelligent preface:

"I should hardly look for an impossible transmission of the reputed

magniloquence and sonority of the Greek; and this with the less regret,

inasmuch as there is abundant musicality elsewhere, but nowhere else

than in his poem the ideas of the poet."

He quotes Matthew Arnold on the Greeks: "their expression is so

excellent, because it is so simple and so well subordinated, because it

draws its force directly from the pregnancy of the matter which it

conveys ... not a word wasted, not a sentiment capriciously thrown in,

stroke on stroke."

He is reasonable about the Greek spelling. He points out that _γόνον

ἰδὼν κάλλιστον ἀνδρῶν_ sounds very poorly as "Seeing her son the fairest

of men" but is outshouted in "Remirando il figliuolo bellissimo degli

uomini," and protests his fidelity to the meaning of Aeschylus.

His weakness in this work is where it essentially lay in all of his

expression, it rests in the term "ideas"--"Thought" as Browning

understood it--"ideas" as the term is current, are poor two dimensional

stuff, a scant, scratch covering. "Damn ideas, anyhow." An idea is only

an imperfect induction from fact.

The solid, the "last atom of force verging off into the first atom of

matter" is the force, the emotion, the objective sight of the poet. In

the Agamemnon it is the whole rush of the action, the whole wildness of

Kassandra's continual shrieking, the flash of the beacon fires burning

unstinted wood, the outburst of

_Τροιάν Αχαιῶν οὖσαν_,

or the later

_Τροίαν Ἀχαιοὶ τήδ' ἔχουσ' ἐν ἡπέρα._

"Troy is the greeks'." Even Rossetti has it better than Browning:

"Troy's down, tall Troy's on fire," anything, literally anything that

can be shouted, that can be shouted uncontrolledly and hysterically.

"Troy is the Greeks'" is an ambiguity for the ear. "Know that our men

are in Ilion."

Instigations Together with An Essay on the Chinese Written Character · 第 172 / 178 题